If Undertale Was Realistic 3 (Smash Bits)
Posted Oct 22, 2016, 2:01 PM UTC
Posted Oct 22, 2016, 2:01 PM UTC
https://www.patreon.com/smashbits You can support Smash Bits here.So they can make more awesome animations.
How about not giving money to scumbags who used assets without permission from the authors, and yet had paid writers and "animators" on their project?
What are you talking about?
The 3D models used in this video were not approved for monetary gain by the people who made them. They are stolen assets used without consent for monetization. SmashBits are horrible copyright thieves who up until I approached them about it even hid credits of said 3D artists behind a paywall as the $10-reward on their Patreon, and pleaded ignorance to what they were doing.
Interesting. From my perspective they got all that stuff from an Open Source Community for source engine assets, which are provided through the steam workshop. If what you are saying is true, I assume they didn't check the license for every single thing that is provided there, which is definitely a huge mistake. Normally a huge chunk of the open source community is alright with anyone using their stuff, but yeah, credits normally should be in the video. Besides from that I also see the issue with them saying that the animation is expensive - SFM is actually pretty easy to use.
So what is left? I enjoyed the voice acting and writing by dexter manning which I definitely enjoyed. But I can see the issues with the project.
edit: It seems to be discussed on their youtube channel discussion page: https://www.youtube.com/user/SmashBits/discussion so it's not like they are some evil corporation which blindly steal work of people they don't care about. People should not only see one side of the coin. Also, if you publish stuff in the Steam Workshop you automatically agree to some terms, which also involves the usage of the stuff.
Dexter Manning is a cool dude. This whole series is stupidly funny. Reminds me of Sanity not included.
Finally, an Asgore I can relate to!
I wanted to watch that Flowey TV show too!
This is fucking atrocious. The animation is garbage, they're trying to pass it off as "a 4-month project" - fucking Muffet LITERALLY shows up in a sliding T-pose. Yeah, that time and effort really shows. On top of all that the lighting is trash, and the cinematography is non-existent. Paid animators and a paid scriptwriter. I say "animator" loosely, because this barely even qualifies. Furthermore, they're using stolen assets without the permissions from the authors - whom I have spoken with myself. None of them approved the monetary gain involved in this.
Smashbits are absolute cancer. Don't even bother giving them the time of day, and definetely don't give them your money. Spend it on people who actually give a shit about the content they make.
[have] (http://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=607303223&searchtext=undertale+toriel)
[you] (http://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=589648918&searchtext=undertale+sans)
[heard] (http://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=744916268&searchtext=undertale+alphys)
[of] (http://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=617161924&searchtext=undertale+muffet)
[the] (http://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=551716089&searchtext=undertale+papyrus)
[steam] (http://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=547969315&searchtext=undertale+mettaton)
[workshop?] (http://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=562591095&searchtext=undertale+mettaton)
[removed]
I'll repeat what I've said throughout this thead:
They had paid writers and "animators" who left "higher paying jobs" to work on these videos. So that assumes they dedicated at least the average work-day on these videos. And for that, 400 work hours / 4 months of work should show. But it doesn't. It's utter garbage. The fact that they try to claim they had two "animators" on the job is even more inexcusable and pathetic.
Furthermore, crediting is usually enough if there's no monetary gain for any party involved. Most uploaders are fine with people gaining money through ad revenue, yes, but in this case (and I've talked to the actual 3D artists who made the models) when there are paid employees and the modellers didn't get jack shit, they aren't exactly happy about that. And regardless of how you look at it, their assets are then still protected under copyright law. http://store.steampowered.com/subscriber_agreement/
But that's the artists problem, and if they have that problem then it's them and not you who should sort out that problem. They should ask to be compensated if they feel the need to be, and then if they don't and it was made clear that it's against the authors wishes beforehand then it would become a problem.
But right now there is no clear intention on stepping on anyone's feet here apart from you trying to facilitate a problem but instead creating premature drama.
Why must everything in the Undertale fandom so drama orientated. Everything you are doing right now is creating public drama of private matters. Things needs to be addressed here, but not by you. Public attention is a means to an end and all you are doing here is putting off other potential content creators who want to create without the drama, both the artists and the video creator gets inconvenienced by drama.
Look, usually I wouldn't bat an eye to these kinds of things, it's a terrible Undertale video. Whatever. But in this instance it's a registered company with paid employees.
I immediately contacted the 3D artists and asked if they'd actually given permission, because I felt this was just too shady to slip by. None of them have.
All the ones I've spoken to so far have exclaimed that they're fine with people using their assets, but once money comes into the picture they're not exactly happy about it. And I feel that needs to be adressed.
Don't give scumbags like SmashBits your views and money, because it's not being fairly distributed to the actual people who made these videos possible in the first place.
I am so glad people haven't shat on this for being anything other then their ideal version of Undertale. I really liked this series.
Ain't shitting on it, but the humor ain't my thing.
Honestly, after the first video the novelty kind of wore off for me.
I can see that. It made me laugh a couple of times, sometimes simply because of how stupid it is. And the animation is more "meh".