r/printers•
LABoston

Help deciding between 3 printers

Purchase Advice

Hi all!

So I need a new printer because my old one broke. I think I narrowed it down to these three, but I was wondering if I could get some input as to which might be better.

HP OfficeJet Pro 6968 on sale for $89

HP OfficeJet Pro 6978 on sale for $99

Brother MFC J885DW on sale for $99

The only difference I see between the HP's that I'm confused about is the following.

Both HP's say, "Scan size (ADF), maximum--8.5 x 14 in (one-sided) A4, Letter (two-sided)"

The 6968 says, "Duplex ADF scanning--Single-sided"

while the 6978 says, "Duplex ADF scanning--Double-side"

I'm not really sure what that means, but if someone could decipher that for me I'd appreciate it.


The HPs use the same 902 ink, so if I were to buy the XL cartridges ($37 for B&W and $20 for color) the B&W is $0.045/pg and the color is $0.024/pg.

The Brother printer is a little slower in terms of ppm, and the ink is about the same, if I were to buy the XL cartridges ($45 for B&W and $40 for color) the B&W is $0.041/pg and the color is $0.024/pg.

So having said all this, if anyone could let me know which might be the best one I'd really appreciate it! Let me know if I should provide more information.

Thanks all!


Budget: <$200

Color or black and white: both please

Laser or Ink: I don't care

Multifunction (scan, copy fax) or not: yes! (fax not necessary)

Automatic duplex printing: yes please!

New or used: new

For home or business use: half and half (printing text documents and copying/scanning invoices)

Optional details:

Pages Per Minute: I don't care

Pages printed per month/year: maybe 75 pg/month? It fluctuates.

Document feeder: preferable

Automatic duplex sided copying: preferable

Special paper type, sizes and weights: standard stuff (letter, legal, and index cards)

Special resolutions: I don't care

Network or USB: I don't care

Wireless or cable: I don't care

Computer OS: OS X (macbook pro) and Windows 10

Vendor preferences: I don't care

Posted Oct 23, 2016, 7:12 PM UTC · edited

17
Luxtaposition•

Check the cost for maintenance kits for the units... Go with the one that has a better price and duty cycle.

2
LABostonOP•

In terms of duty cycle and price, the HPs are definitely in the lead.

By maintenance kits do you mean this?

1
Luxtaposition•

Yes

1
kheszi•

"Duplex ADF scanning--Single/double-sided"

This indicates whether the automatic document feeder (ADF) can scan one side of your document at a time (double-sided documents will require you to scan, flip and then rescan), or if it can scan both sides in one pass.

For reliability, you might want to consider a good black & white laser printer. The Canon imageCLASS MF229dw is an highly rated feature-packed printer. The MF229dw has an automatic document feeder that can scan, copy, and fax, and will do FULL DUPLEX in ALL modes (full automatic double-sided printing, copying, scanning, faxing), and comes with Ethernet, Apple Airprint, Wi-Fi and also supports tablet and smartphone printing. It's very fast at 28ppm and costs about $150 from Fry's Electronics with FREE shipping.

If you like, you can put the remaining $50 in your budget towards a cheap color printer for the occasional color print. Generic toner cartridges can easily be found for around $10 on Amazon and eBay, which make this printer extremely cheap to operate.

https://www.usa.canon.com/internet/portal/us/home/products/details/printers/black-and-white-laser/mf229dw

http://www.frys.com/product/8284736

2
LABostonOP•

This Canon looks like it has promise, the question is whether I can convince my roommate to have two units instead of an all in one.

Does this Canon also require maintenance kits?

1
kheszi•

No maintenance kits required. If you are interested, Amazon has a ridiculously cheap extended warranty for this printer: 3-Year protection is less than $15.00. The printer is currently priced $20 higher than Fry's (it fluctuates from day to day), so the net difference would be $35 more if you buy it today from Amazon with the 3-year extended protection. Still cheaper than any maintenance kit, and covers pretty much anything including accidental damage.

For clean & crisp black & white printouts without requiring special inkjet paper, nothing beats a laser printer. With generic toner, your consumables cost is an unbeatable 1/2 a cent per page.

2
LABostonOP•

oh that's kinda awesome (the no maintenance kit.)

I'll wonder if I can talk my roomie into it though, I know she's got her heart set on an all-in-one.

Thanks for the help!!!

1