Would anyone be interested in a weekly "How do you solve this problem" thread?

I'm not a regular here but I come here enough to understand what the most common themes are. I see a lot of users struggle with breaking down problems into sub problems. Would anyone be interested in having a weekly thread where users can post problems and other users can break them down into sub problems? Ideally with explanations and resources along the way?

Posted Oct 26, 2016, 4:41 PM UTC

72350
marco262•

I would love another excuse to lord my programming knowledge over other people.

I mean, uh... help people learn by example, and, uh, stretch my mental muscles.

... yeah.

85
bryntheskits•

You joke, but the second reason is almost the only reason I code now days. My job doesn't require me to, but coding a program to bring the 6 or 7 different programs together onto one informative page not only makes the job easier, but helps me keep my coding knowledge relevant and lets me know I still got it.

Also lauding it over people.

7
myrrlyn•

It's lording when you say you're better than us; it's lauding when we say you're better than us.

11
redditorium•

Way to lord your english knowledge over bryn.

11
myrrlyn•

Thank you for lauding me for having done so :p

7
brbpizzatime•

I don't know about others, but I hangout in r/learnprogramming/new/ when looking for posts, so I would never see new posts made to a weekly thread.

Also, if people can't be bothered to read the FAQ before posting, I guarantee you they wont post in a weekly thread either.

25
MRBO94•

We gotta sticky dat shit!

7
brbpizzatime•

Stickies don't show in the new queue

3
MRBO94•

Well fuck

4
Saefroch•

They do... When they're new. As another person who browses /new it bugs me that I sometimes miss stickies... Kinda defeats the point.

3
solrflow•

I too would like to see this happen. It would be really useful to see step by step how to problem is solved at each stage in detail

19
Micker216•

There's another subreddit called dailyprogrammer that is somewhat in that line of thinking I believe

13
LeCyberDucky•

On r/dailyprogrammer it's more about challenges being posted for other people to solve. To my understanding OP doesn't want people to post challenges but more like questions they need help with.

8
BernoulliRandomOP•

Exactly. I think it would be a good compliment to those problems. Instead of people posting solutions, people would be posting in depth responses on how to solve the problem, by breaking it down so it can be followed in a step-by-step fashion.

10
RozJC•

So would r/askprogramming be the answer?

1
Alexanderdaawesome•

I actually would like a "solve this problem" thread once a week, where a problem is asked and we all solve it, picking up strengths and weaknesses of each others code.

12
Starcast•

Your should check out the daily programmer subreddit

7
andwhatlol•
3
Vok250•

Sounds like something that would attract a lot of low effort questions and homework questions. I don't see this being an improvement over the current structure here. You're just giving people an excuse to put less effort into solving it themselves.

4
kungtotte•

Yeah, I think it would be more worthwhile with a more lesson-based approach where a problem/question is posed by the OP and beginners are invited to explain their way of solving it and then everyone can help and critique their proposed solutions.

Kind of a "show your work" kind of thing, to help people iron out the kinks in their problem solving, as opposed to just reviewing a final working code example like on dailyprogrammer.

2
dmux•

Along with your idea mentioned, I'd also love to see a "deep dive" done into a specific area / topic. As an example, I spent a lot of time over the weekend attempting to understand Spark's memory management

3
veive•

Yes

3
garrypig•

Yes

3
YohohohoYohohoho•

If we're gonna do that, can we have other weekly threads like 'where are you at in learning?' or 'introductions monday' or some such?

3
SirSharpest•

My biggest programming issue is not understanding languages, syntax or methods of manipulation of data, it is the amount of ways things can be done and done wrong. I'd love to see ideal solutions to problems from those more experienced

2
Dmdrapp•

As a new programmer, I would love this. I have been wanting problems to put my newfound knowledge into.

2
Rugby8724•

I think it is a great idea

1
OkeepTooth•

yessss.

1
kingkickass531•

I would love to see that. It'd be good to have differing levels of difficulty for new and experinced people so i think having it as a thread is best.

1
theunseen•

Do it :)

1
the_H_man•

I think that's a great idea.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^0.0225

What is this?

1
ArdentFire•

That would be fantastic

1
Daforce1•

Yes

1