Struggling Arranged Team
While I tend to avoid solo ranked play, I love getting involved in arranged tournaments (previously at school, now at the company where I work). These tournaments are almost always "mixed skill", meaning that players on a given team can range from unranked to Plat/Diamond, but the teams on the whole are generally supposed to balance out with each other.
In the past, I've usually had a very highly ranked player in a proper carry role (mid/top/adc). As a career jungler, this has enabled me to play either tanky initiating champions (like Zac/Sej) or early pressure champions (like Elise/Rek'Sai). This time around, I've found myself as the second highest ranked person on the team at Gold 3 behind only a Platinum 5 support who doesn't really communicate and doesn't even main support.
It's important to note that role swapping is officially disallowed. The team was matchmade, and we're basically stuck together and in the roles we're playing.
Anyway, so unlike most of my previous tournament experiences, this team is willing to practice. We've been playing a few games each day after work for about two weeks now (usually only 1-2 games with all 5 due to scheduling though we usually squeeze in a few partial-team normals before and after), which is more practice than I've ever been able to get a group to have before. Sounds great.
The problem is we just... lose. I believe we've managed to pull out a mere three victories as a full team in the past two weeks, and two of those were simply massive throws from the other team. Our team's morale is soul-crushingly low. We're only a few games away from dropping to Ranked Teams Bronze 5.
Our lanes almost always lose in CS, have no real map pressure, and consistently get killed 1v1/2v2. Our vision control is nonexistent. I've been going back and watching the replays, and the rare proactive plays that we make almost always end up backfiring (despite being good plays in retrospect, i.e., numbers advantage, cooldown advantage, position advantage, etc...) because a key member manages to massively misplay the fight. Late game, our carry roles never seem to deal damage in fights, as is consistently evidenced by the post-game damage graphs.
Essentially, I'm not really sure what to do at this point. I feel like the most success we've had is when I run wildly off-meta damage threats from the jungle like Rumble and Quinn simply because it gives us a mostly reliable damage source later in the game, but then we lack the initiation power of a Skarner or Zac so we can't capitalize on good situations. On the other hand, if I am on Skarner or Zac, then it feels like there are never any good situations to take advantage of. I'm also not delusional enough to believe I have the consistent skill required to play Lee or Nidalee. I've been pulling specific things out of replays for personal improvement like improving my own vision game, but it's unrealistic for me to magically become a Diamond-skilled jungler overnight and hard-carry everyone. Every game also feels like an uphill struggle for me personally since the enemy jungler has two to three winning lanes to gank at virtually all times.
Where do we go from here? What can I do? What can we do? Does anyone have experience in a similar situation?
Posted Oct 28, 2016, 8:00 AM UTC
I am not too experienced in arranged teams, but, to me, it sounds like you are struggling with "soloq-ish" issues. Its not like your gameplan is backfiring horribly or you are getting outrotated much. At least, thats how i read it.
The easiest step i could think of would be to pick easy champs that are meta right now. Hope to fix your lanes with this. As a jungle, your best bet probably is to get at least one lane ahead somehow. Camp it if necessary.
I dont think it is a good idea to focus on everything at once. You will not be able to fix it all at once and you will be frustrated thinking about all these mistakes. Take your time and dont worry too much.