Tankali on the PBE? (Please read!)

Hold up on the pitchforks and just hear me out for a bit, aIright? I understand that the purists (AKA most of ye on r/akalimains) feel that AP Akali is the ONLY way to go. That's a perfectly logical line of thought -- her kit plays like an assassin and she should stay that way. But let me preface this by saying that I play AP Akali exclusively in the midlane (AKA most of the time), and only go Tankali when I have to bring her up top for whatever reason. So I'm NOT biased towards Tankali (in fact like most of you I prefer the AP build) but I'm not adverse to the Tank build either.

 

I mean, it's not difficult to see why the Tank build appeals to some. With decent damage and amazing mobility for a tank, literally the only thing she lacks is CC, and that can be made up for with a good team comp. When it comes down to it, you still have more than enough damage to wipe the floor with their ADC, and -- perhaps more importantly -- you don't melt in a second when being focused. Sure, you fall off late game, but what tank, when faced by a late-game farmed ADC, doesn't?

 

If you'll look through my comments for the past few days, you'll notice that most of them have been on this sub. I've been advocating for QoL buffs/positive changes for the Akali rework on the PBE, complaining that they've inherently changed her playstyle by removing her spellvamp and replacing it with a clunky two-part passive. But here's the thing: I think her new passive actually REWARDS the Tank build. Correct me if I'm wrong, but with AP Akali's inherent squishiness she's not going to have an easy time surviving long enough to land two whole autos come mid/late-game. With a Tank build, however, she has all the time (and health) in the world to proc those two autos and then some. The E nerfs (the core of her Tank build is spamming that skill for all it's worth) aren't really major enough to discourage the Tank build either, IMO. After all, 3 sec isn't a particularly long time with cooldown reduction (Spirit Visage, runes) and she'll still have her autos AND new passive to continually deal damage.

 

Ultimately, my point is, why can't the AP and Tank builds co-exist in harmony? AP for the midlane, and Tank for when you need a really mobile tank for some reason. I mean, when you think about it, the ult damage nerfs on the PBE mean that her R can no longer be counted on as a reliable source of damage (C'mon, a 25% AP ratio?) and is pretty much only used for the mobility from now on. And that's precisely my point -- you pick Tankali for the fact that she's mobile AND a tank. The E nerfs are obviously meant to be a hit to Tankali, but her new passive and nerfed ult damage seem to say otherwise. Can I have your thoughts, please? Thank you!

 

EDIT: Minor formatting changes.

Posted Nov 4, 2016, 12:29 PM UTC · edited

425
Megguido•

I kind of like the idea of Tankali (shame on me) since I love those mobile-bruiser champs. BUT, I disagree on the passive part. I find the old passive better on an offtank Akali.

First, the old passive gives... passive stats. The longer you last in a fight, the more auto attacks you land, the more damage you deal / heal. That's a skirmisher passive, not an assassin's.

Second, the new "clunky" passive allows her to burst both heal and damage in only two autos. The delay between two autos is about 1s to 1.5s. You land a mark, dash on your victim, AA, E, wait less than a sec, AA again. And if you can't survive 1 second of combat, then you have either your shroud or a zhonya's to wait and dash + mark + AA your target again. Also, lots of her regen comes from the gunblade. Early on, I barely heal for 20 HP on a Q+AA combo on a minion. Later in the game I don't care because the gunblade heals me for half of my HP in one rotation. Well, I don't understand why so much people call this passive clunky, since her old passive is poorly designed for an assassin.

Oh, and a Tankali would AA lots more than twice in a fight. And a Tankali with no AP nor AD, will heal nor deal any damage with the new passive.

3
SupportScrubOP•

Ah, you're right. That's something I didn't think of; the passive doesn't scale if you don't build AP and AD, so while early game is fine you basically become redundant by mid-game. You're a really solid brick wall with tons of mobility, but ultimately a completely useless one because you don't have the CC or damage to do anything to the opponent team.

 

Okay then, let me rephrase the question and get back to my original point. Do you think there's any way Tankali can still work with the PBE update? Or is it dead and gone for good? Personally, I'll be disappointed to see it go, but as you convinced me with your points, AP Akali can make use of the new passive just as well as Tankali can (probably even more so as she can make it scale).

 

EDIT: A word.

1
RedShade183,488 forevershade NA•

Tank Akali lost a lot of damage. Passive has more scaling that bases, so if you don't have any Ap or bonus ad, you do no damage, and you heal for nothing. R bases being gutted means you will tickle the enemy with it. E was actually buffed. Even if you build no AD it should outdamage live E for a while. But by the time it's mid game I'm pretty sure Live E will outdamage PBE E since it scales with bonus ad now, rather than total.

1
LunaticMouse•

"Even if you build no AD it should outdamage live E for a while", what? A 40-60 base damage and a +10%AP scaling doesn't compensate at all for the increased cooldown and loss of base AD scaling. Plus it's not like E was ever a big part of her damage output anyway because of its big energy costs, it's mostly a wave clearing tool and now more than ever.

1
LunaticMouse•

It's pretty clunky that you get the heal part of it when she's in fullhealth and the damage part after she's been damaged herself. Plus coupled with how her new shroud really gimps how much control she has during her lanning phase, it's pretty clunky to have it so you can proc it on the enemy and not waste it on minions instead, specially pre-6.

1
myzuk7790,649 euw - MyzukGoesMid•

you need a better reason for going diver akali than just you being top

2
SupportScrubOP•

That's a very fair point, but if there isn't any good reason for a tank diver Akali to exist, then why was it meta a while back? I understand that the game has changed a lot since then, but if high elo players were spamming it at one point then there must have been some logic to their decision. I'm not detracting from your point (the logic is sound), but I'm just saying it as it is.

2
myzuk7790,649 euw - MyzukGoesMid•

I didnt say that there isn't any good reason for a diver Akali to exist, i just said that building tank items just because you went top is stupid, the same way as just building cookie cutter ap build just because you went mid is also stupid.

There are times when stacking defensive items is optimal, I cant be asked to give an in depth answer so just look through my post history and you'll see when i believe you should go for diver akali

3
myzuk7790,649 euw - MyzukGoesMid•

copy pasted one of my previous answers: You probably are playing the 'tank' build incorrectly. I suggest going for the 'tank' build only when you are against a heavy ad team as that's when it excels because of the items synergy. You get gunblade first because you are playing akali, ninja tabis - the effect from tabis scales multiplicatively with armor then either sunfire cape/ thornmail 3rd and the other one 4th (get thornmail before sunfire if you are ahead by a lot). Your 5th item should usually be void staff as everything you do apart of E is magic damage, this will increase the heal you get from thornmail. Gunblade heals you off thornmail (and sunfire though its a lot less) .Go 0/18/12 and make sure you take 5 points in runic armor. Both hourglass and qss are not needed as ,unlike the offensive build, this build wont die from a lulu polymorph or whatever hard cc. Stats from hourglass are not bad so if you are at least diamond 1 (so you actually use it correctly) and can actually think, get it if you feel the need. (if you run out of energy before you kill both carries or you didnt ban janna) Also you are not a tank, you do not have any utility and your job is not to peel. You are an unkillable diver. This build still kills carries in ~2 seconds unless they go mr (make sure you are not playing a triple ap comp). Added benefits of stacking armor are that you can tank turrets and nashor for days.

5
SupportScrubOP•

Thank you! I've learnt a lot from your reply. You're right, going for the tank/bruiser build should depend on the opponent's teamcomp as well and not just yours alone. So it's viable in some circumstances, but not all of them, and not just 'cause you were going top.

 

Maybe I have been a bit of a meta slave. Thanks again for your respectful reply. There's one thing I do have to ask, though: if you don't go tank/bruiser as Akali top because of the aforementioned reasons, then I assume you go AP? Won't your team then have the problem of not having a proper tank? (Or do you just not pick Akali in that case?)

2
Salty_Akali_Main412,162 rip main account•

Not to mention all you really need for "diver" Akali is ga and zhonyas which are core 90% of games

1
myzuk7790,649 euw - MyzukGoesMid•

works extremely well, especially against caitlyn

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
ferventdenial•

Bruiser builds have always been viable for melee damage dealers if they don't wanna get blown up instantly. Building defensively is a strategy.

2
SupportScrubOP•

Agreed. I mean, who wouldn't build an Abyssal Scepter against an Ahri as AP Akali? Tank Akali pretty much builds on the same idea, just putting more focus on the tank part than the damage part; even then she still comes off as more of a bruiser than a true tank. Still, I can understand what the purists mean when they say that Akali's kit isn't built for tank. That level of mobility on a tanky champion (that still deals very respectable amounts of damage) makes for very unhealthy levels of no counterplay once the ball gets rolling.

2
CarlosLopez_69•

Hate on me all you want but I think sheen items will be good on akali since they will promote auto attacking since they do a lot of damage. Myself I will probably be picking lich bane the most but I might fiddle with triforce it might me pretty good because it will make her updated combo (r) aa, q, aa, e, r smoother with the attack speed. Plus sheen will make pushing better since passive doesn't affect towers anymore.

1
Salty_Akali_Main412,162 rip main account•

No

-1
SupportScrubOP•

Fair enough. But here's the thing: I'm not really looking for people to agree with me here. I'm looking for honest discussion backed up by logical answers. If you can substantiate your "No" with anything more than, well, "No", I'll be more than happy to listen and reply with respect, as you can see from my other comments. If not, well...

 

I don't know, maybe you're just keeping in character with that relevant username?

3
Salty_Akali_Main412,162 rip main account•
  1. No cc

  2. Worse Irelia

  3. No %hp damage

  4. Shit base damage

  5. Gets more effective tank off building AP and zhonyas/ga/rylai

  6. Will get shredded by adc which you won't be able to solo because you build like a moron

  7. Horrid scaling and falls off hard if you build tank

  8. Useless moment you can't 100-0 the enemy adc/mid

  9. Just flat out worse than AP in every way imaginable

  10. Better options

  11. AP. Fucking. Burst. Assassin.

  12. Shit lane phase compared to other meta tanks

  13. It will never ever fucking be good or better than just AP, only reason it had a tiny fotm spree was because of riot making sunfire and e cancer and all the scrubs circle jerking some Koreans borderline troll build

  14. Doesn't fit her play style

  15. Play the pbe or wait for live before theorising stupid shit

  16. No benefit from building tank

  17. Makes her rely way too hard on your team not having downs and any success can just be correlated to getting carried

  18. No peel

  19. Shit team fight

  20. No real power spikes

  21. Shit heal now that it scales with AP

Go ahead and play her tank if you want I don't care but it's stupid and worse than AP in literally every way. Id love to hear at least one way that it out performs AP Akali or any other decent meta mobile off tank ie Ekko/Irelia.

Compare to Irelia or ekko:

Ekko has: cc, shield, %hp damage, good base damage, can peel, gets hp heal if ult used correctly

Irelia has: cc, peel, true damage shred, better early, big power spike with triforce

-1
SupportScrubOP•

Thank you! I've learnt a lot from your reply. You're right, going for the tank/bruiser build should depend on the opponent's teamcomp as well and not just yours alone. So it's viable in some circumstances, but not all of them, and not just 'cause you were going top.

Semi copy-pasted from my previous reply to u/myzuk77. If you look through our whole comment chain you'll notice that he (she?) said that the 'tank' build is viable under certain circumstances. Now I'm not trying to pit your opinions against each other (looking through your points, most of them make sense in their own right), but you seem to be one of the purists that simply hate Tankali for existing -- not because it's inherently bad.

 

Now, you're much higher elo than me and I respect that, so let's agree to disagree. If you're thinking that I'm purposefully pitting myself against you, I'm not -- I legitimately wanted good discussion and your reply actually had some pretty good parts of that, with decent justification on your part as to why Tankali fails in comparison to the other meta offtank options. However, maybe if there comes a time when you can answer with a little more mutual respect, instead of every reply having a tinge of arrogance and saltiness... :) we could have a much better and lighthearted discussion, mate.

 

Either way, thanks for your reply! I do appreciate the time you took to type it out, at least.

5
Salty_Akali_Main412,162 rip main account•

I don't mean any offence to you personally or course. It just seems like every couple days there seems to be some new player who probably doesn't even main Akali wondering if tank is good when there's a billion other posts where we have said it's worse than AP, it gets annoying after a point.

I could probably come up with another 40 and better reasons why she's bad as a tank considering I came up with those off the top of my head at 2 am but I think we can just agree to disagree.

I think the main reason we're disagreeing is that I'm looking at this from a competitive "is it better than AP if not then it's bad" perspective and you're looking at it from a "could it work" perspective.

1
Vyrzez180,453•

^ This

-1