r/asoiaf•
asendra

(No Spoilers) Comparing two 20th Anniversary Illustrated Eds. of GoT

NONE

Like many of you, I preordered my copy of the 20th Anniversary Got Illustrated Edition (thats a mouthful!) months ago. Before release, browsing Amazon I found another version by a different publisher, and it seemed to have a much better cover (and cheaper!) so I ordered it too so I could compare them I keep the one I liked more.

The second one took a while to arrive, but now that I have both, I thought maybe you guys would like photos to compare them.

Front: https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/313914/Got%20-%20Illustrated%20Ed./IMG_9207.jpg

Back: https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/313914/Got%20-%20Illustrated%20Ed./IMG_9206.jpg

Spine: https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/313914/Got%20-%20Illustrated%20Ed./IMG_9212.jpg

Thickness: https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/313914/Got%20-%20Illustrated%20Ed./IMG_9190.jpg

If you guys want more comparison photos just ask and I'll try to upload them later.

The brown one is the one by Penguin Random House, and the black one is by HarperCollins.

I'm from Spain and the version more available in stores here is the one by Penguin Random House, but for what I can gather one is the US version, and the other is the UK version? Correct me If I'm wrong on that.

The HarperCollins version is a bit thicker, because the pages seem to be a little thicker/better. The illustrations look about the same, maybe slightly more contrast on the b&w ones, and more yellowy on the color ones for the Penguin Random House version.

The internal layout is almost identical. the only difference I've seen is sometimes one version has a blank page after or before an illustration, or the start of a new chapter.

They also have a different hinge? design and the HarperCollins one also has a built in page marker.

Posted Nov 5, 2016, 3:37 PM UTC

9820
stickleeHouse of the Dying•

The HarperCollins one looks incredible. On the front and back covers - less is more; I really like it. Thanks for the post!

21
asendraOP•

Yeah, I wasn't particularly excited with the Penguin one, and then I saw the other on Amazon and I just fell in love.

Now, the wait for the illustrated editions of the rest of the books begins 😭

6
Jiyvajelly•

I cant seem to find it on Amazon. A link would be helpful please

2
Shell058Only Cat•

The black one is the UK edition and I don't think it's available in the US Amazon store. I just happened to have relatives in the UK the week of release and they brought me home a copy. I like it way more than the US edition and I wish they'd make it available here.

6
asendraOP•

All I can give you is a link to it in the amazon spanish store.. https://www.amazon.es/gp/product/0008209103/ref=oh_aui_detailpage_o00_s00?ie=UTF8&psc=1

1
Jiyvajelly•

That's fine, I speak spanish so ordering shouldn't be a problem. I'm assuming they still ship to US?

Thanks dude

1
Omrimg2•

They're fucking beautiful.

15
mc_curtis10♫I bless the Reynes down in Castamere!♫•

To anyone considering buying this, I would recommend reading this review first (Warning: some AGoT spoilers).

I was sort of expecting something on par with the World of Ice and Fire world-book in terms of quality, but that does seem to be the case. A few notes to consider:

  • Some of the pictures are apparently in black and white.

  • Some of the artwork is recycled from the World of Ice and Fire.

  • The artwork is arranged in such a way that it sometimes spoils events that occur later in a chapter, i.e. Spoilers AGOT.

I'm not sure if this review applies to both the US and UK versions, since it was written on the US Amazon page, but covers issues that apparently only (or also) appear in the UK version. Personally, though, I'm a little disappointed. Like I said, I was really looking forward to something like the World of Ice and Fire, and this might not be it. Damn, I'd have bought two!

4
Dee_tawb•

I've got the UK edition and it does apply to the UK edition as well.

2
Kienn12Winner 2020 - Best Predictive Theory•

Does the HarperCollins version have a full color illustration in Tyrion V that belongs in Bran V?

3
asendraOP•

Damn!! That's a yes... unfortunately.

Hadn't arrived to that yet in my reread.

3
nickmistaAerys did nothing wrong•

How did that not get picked up in editing? The illustrations were the only thing changed other than the cover and no one noticed?

2
Jiyvajelly•

Link to buy the HarperCollins version? Looks way better. Penguin one looks cheap and gaudy.

3
asendraOP•

By the way, does the audio.ebook sticker on the back of the HarperCollins version mean anything? Do I get an audiobook download for free too? xD

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
thebsoftelevisionThe Wolf that barks•

Does the HarperCollins one have cover art? If so is it the same as the Penguin issue?

1
asendraOP•

Sorry I'm not 100% sure what you mean.

On the outside both eds. are just as I've shown, none have dust jackets or anything (like the TWoIaF book for example)

If you mean the color maps on the inside, both at the front and the back, of the north & the south, then yes.

As far as I've seen, they both have the same illustrations, with the same styles. The color one are in color in both, and the b&w ones the same

2
thebsoftelevisionThe Wolf that barks•

Okay thanks.

1
farerb•

While I agree that the HarperCollins' one looks better, I ordered Bantam's edition because all my ASOIAF books are from Bantam and I have OCD.

1
asendraOP•

I get that. I only owned the kindle versions because when I started this madness it was 2009-2010, and the only really cool editions I found where the slipcase ones which cost a fortune second hand lol.

I'm slightly terrified they won't release the rest of the books to match it to be honest haha

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
mhoey8A Thousand Eyes, and One•

I looked it up on Amazon.co.uk and it says that the yellow version of the book is £45.57 but the black version is £15.00. Why is this?

1