[MAJOR SPOILERS] Endgame Theories on Otus, Solus, Noctae, ect.

TLDR; LOOP IS CYCLICAL HISTORY, WE ARE REINCARNATES OF OWLS IN THE SANCTUARY, WE BUSTED THAT LOOP, AND HOT DAMN WE LIVED DOING IT

    At the end of the game, we're left with a lot of ambiguity regarding The Loop, the current status of The Loop, Otus, and just owl history in general. Me and my s/o have been talking about this non-stop and think we have some pretty good theories.

There's a ton of information regarding all of this at the end of the game. Some of it plays out in the final sequence, some of it we get through blurbs in the Floating Continent, most of it we get in The Sanctuary accessed by finding the 3 Owl Coins. There is definitely more than one way to view the information given, but this is the way we've been able to put things together with minimal ambiguity.

 

THE LOOP THEORY:

Current Hypothesis: The Loop is a cycle of rebirth/reincarnation, where history must repeat itself. We believe The Loop describes a "soft reset", which is described more below.

Proof: While The Loop is mentioned plenty of times, it is rarely described in detail, save for one instance. The only person who describes the effects of The Loop is Noctae. Within the mathematics he views countless lives and deaths, most importantly (for now) his own. He describes his demise as a wave function out to infinity. His death happens over and over and over again throughout history.

Ambiguity: The biggest ambiguity here is whether The Loop describes a "hard reset" or "soft reset". A hard reset would imply the eventual end of the entire universe, only for it to start again, owls to form, owls to rise, Noctae to be born, predict his own death, die, The Hex to be built, ect ect. The entirety of Owl History and the game we are playing would all be part of one Loop. A soft reset would be a looser repetition of history, where current beings live out a series of events that is in many ways similar to their historical counterparts that existed in the Loop prior to theirs.

Discussion: So why did we choose a soft reset, and why does that matter? There's a few reasons we went with a soft reset. The easiest reason is simply the number of parallels between the owl holograms in The Sanctuary, and the characters in the game. I will discuss that at length below. The short version is that every hologram in the Sanctuary, even the busted ones, correspond to a relevant owl from the most recent generation.

Other reasons for our theory regard how Owl society reacted to knowledge of The Loop. For The Loop to describe a cyclical process that takes billions of years with the end of the universe, it seems unlikely that it would cause mass controversy. It raises important philosophical questions about the nature of free will and all related discussions, and the owls of all beings would certainly take such a discussion very seriously, but would it cause mass "infighting and chaos"? What is described by Solus implies that the ancient owls were worried about something much more pertinent and tangible.

 

REINCARNATIONS:

Current Hypothesis: Solus is the reincarnation of Noctae, Otus is the Reincarnation of Aegolius, Asio is the reincarnation of the hologram that triggers Geddy's dialogue, Strix and his students are reincarnates of the first three holograms in The Sanctuary, Otus's parents are reincarnates of the broken holograms.

Proof: Asio: The game goes out of its way to point out that the third to last hologram is a reference to Asio. It gives us a brief cutscene with Geddy that highlights the skeptical and haughty nature of this owl. It mirrors the behavior of Asio very well. The fact that this hologram talks down on Aegolius will also become relevant.

Asio Ambiguity: None

 

Solus: Solus is a tall and slender owl who's name is not directly derived from a real world species of owl. The only owls in the game, alive or dead, to not be named after a real owl are Solus, Noctae, Fib and Bonacci. The first three letters of Solus and Noctae are prefixes corresponding to night and day respectively. The classmates of Solus are named Fib and Bonacci, a clear reference to the mathematician Fibonacci. This mirrors the presence of mathematics in Noctaes life. Both characters are reclusive and do not speak to others unless strongly prompted by others. In each of their respective time periods, they were also the first to learn of The Loop. Each only had one real friend. Noctae had Aegolius, Solus had Otus. The fact that Solus almost died at the hands of Molstrom adds to this even more, but we'll come back to that

Solus Ambiguity: There is some ambiguity here, that leaves room for interpretation. While Solus is an obvious choice for the reincarnation of Noctae, the story of Otus also connects somewhat with Noctae. Otus is also not one for speaking with others, because he can't. He is also the one who dies by the hand of Aegolius's automation at the end of the game, rather than Noctae.

 

Otus: Aegolius matches up to Otus in a lot of ways. Visually speaking, they are likely the same species of owl. The scenarios they find themselves in are also quite similar. While Noctae is the one to devise a plan to deal with The Loop, Aegolius is the one to put it into action. Similarly, Solus is the one who sets up the Anti-Hex, but Otus is the one to actually use it. In the same way that Otus is berated by Asio through much of his life, Asio's predecessor seems to have had a similar tone with Aegolius. Aegolius also directly refers to himself as "the weakest of the owls". This feels like a fairly blatant reference to Otus's shortcomings as an Owl. Until the events of the game, Otus is definitively the weakest of the owls.

Otus Ambiguity: We're pretty confident Aegolius must be Otus, but Solus actually has a few things going for him as well. Each are deeply ashamed about how the Hex turned out, and made it a point to hide the truth of their actions from their fellow Owls. Solus and Aegolius are also the two Owls with the closest ties to the Automations. As mentioned above, there are decent arguments for Noctae being Otus and Solus being Aegolius, but it seems to us that the arguments for the theory presented are much more substantial.

 

Otus Mother: This was a fun one to discuss but a sad one to think about. We never see the parents of Otus in the game, and likewise we never get to see the holograms, we only get little pieces of dialogue. One of them belongs to "The House of Travel", and the other belongs to "The House of Farmers." The House of Travel is the predecessor of his mother, and the House of Farmers is the predecessor of his father. The little bit of dialogue we get from the mother is in regards to letting future generations flourish and create their own destiny. It is the most focused of all the quotes in the sanctuary on the prosperity of the next generation. In comparison with every other hologram in the Sanctuary, this one talks like a parent. The area outside of the sanctuary is one you have likely visited if you have gotten this far in the game. It is a patch of dirt and a pale tree where you can "examine" to stand there quietly. If you have earned the blue shell rumored to "hear the dead," then Otus will hold it to his ear, listening for a loved one. There is a stone right next to that spot that is animated differently from the surrounding grass. The filename of this rock is HouseOfTravelSigil.png

Otus Father: This one is somewhat weaker, but I still believe it is correct. Otus presumably has 2 parents, and there are 2 busted holograms. If the House of Travel is one of them (and it totally is), then the House of Farmers is likely the other. There is an unused sprite set in the game for a female owl. This likely corresponds to what eventually was designed to be Otus's lost mother. There is another unused sprite set that is a male farmer. The space right above our protagonists home is the only spot in the whole game with a scarecrow. As an additional, and somewhat weak, point about these being his parents: Otus is the only owl we really see performing the actions of Travel and Farming. With one exception, Asio carrying the professor, Otus is the only Owl we see carrying people around. He is also the only one in the game we witness pulling food off trees and out of the ground. It's obviously implied that other characters can and have done such things, but he's the only one we as players ever experience, which makes it thematically interesting that his parents predecessors are centered around travel and farming.

Parent Ambiguity: I actually don't think there's much ambiguity left here. It's worth noting that the removed farmer sprites do NOT appear to be an owl, but seeing that they are removed sprites, I'm choosing to overlook that. The only thing that I use them for in my hypothesis is choosing which hologram corresponds to which parent. Even if I'm wrong on which is which, I still have every reason to believe that the holograms are the predecessors of his parents.

 

Strix & Students: I'm going to keep this one fairly short, as I don't think there's a lot here. The first hologram actually inside The Sanctuary (aka the second hologram you find), is likely Strix. He stands tall, is employed in the training of others, speaks very straightforward and very competently. As for the other two, their connection is somewhat weaker. Fib and Bonacci are lesser characters, and it can be argued that the remaining two holograms are probably the least enlightening in the Sanctuary (besides maybe the father). They also have very slight visual similarities. A big reason I'm sold on their correspondence is simply that the number of holograms in the temple match the number of relevant owl characters in the game, and the other holograms are all clearly tied to existing characters.

Strix & Students Ambiguity: None

 

Discussion: In the final sequence, the professor tells us to say hello to Lettia and Scops. Unless those names belong to someone I'm not aware of, I believe those are the name of Otus's parents. This dialogue clearly takes place in the past, and it seems odd to drop names here unless they're extremely important. There will be a few more relevant remarks about Noctae/Aegolius connections when we get to the current status of The Loop, but otherwise I'm confident in what I've put down. I would love to hear more discussion on this topic if you've got more. It's been a lot of fun sorting these out.

 

THE CURRENT STATUS OF THE LOOP

Current Hypothesis: The Loop is broken and the current generation has avoided the repetition of History.

The Proof: Based on our theories regarding Solus reflecting Noctae and Otus reflecting Aegolius, the ending of the game reflects a different outcome from that of Noctae. In Noctaes time, he was the one to be killed by the rampaging robot, where in the current timeline it is heavily implied that Solus and company live. Noctae, in our conversation, also notes that the presence of Otus is an "inconsistency" with his calculations regarding The Loop. He remarks immediately thereafter that it's possible that The Loop was broken after all.

Ambiguity: Loooots of ambiguity here. If you are under the assumption that Otus is the reincarnate of Noctae, then immediately we have to switch the conclusion. If The Loop is broken, would that not also imply that The Hex worked? At first glance that feels like an odd conclusion seeing as it ended in catastrophy. And even if it did work, would that imply that the Anti-Hex put The Loop back together? It's also mentioned in some of the final words of the game that we may learn about The Loop in our current life, or the next, which implies the possibility of rebirth.

Discussion: So we've gone back and forth on this a lot, each of us switching sides more than once, but ultimately this is where we tentatively settled for a few reasons. First, we're fairly sold on the identities of the reincarnates, despite the possible counterpoints. If that's the case then it's incredibly unlikely The Loop could still be intact given the ending of the game. It's also worth noting that no one understood the Hex Machine other than Noctae, and so no one could ever know if the machine succeeded or failed regardless of the creation of floating islands. From Solus, who was implied to have read through tons of books written by owls after the catastrophe, it doesn't seem as though they ever really determined if it worked or not. Under the hypothesis that perhaps the original Hex worked, would the Anti-Hex not undo it? I don't think so. The Anti-Hex is described very specifically. It was designed to counteract the islands floating away. It is unlikely that anyone workng on The Anti-Hex even understood The Loop in the way that Noctae did, seeing that his work on The Loop was beyond even his closest companion. The totem that Solus is activating in the end of the game certainly doesn't look like a continent sized machine that could measure up to the impact that The Hex could have had either.

Another great point we noticed with the loop breaking at the end is embodied in the fight itself. Noctae predicts that we die in a great battle in the sky. In the first round against Solus, we emerge victorious. When we do so, our character model snaps nicely to the side (as it does in many boss fights), and Solus goes through the same animation he does in the beginning. What's more is that the music abruptly restarts as well. This is in stark contrast to the smooth flow of previous boss phases. After beating him a second time, it happens again, but now we're in this weird arena in space/the matrix/an 80's music video. The most interesting part about this new area is actually the background. In the back you can see a purple streak that, for lack of a better word, looks like a tear in space. In it you can see stars and planets. It also shares the same color pallet with some other places in the game relating to The Loop. I think implications are that we are supposed to lose this fight in order to repeat the pattern. In triumph, we break the predetermined cycle. You can argue that the original Hex weakened The Loop, or that we broke through a predetermined destiny by sheer force of will. I fall more in the weakened loop camp, but that's just me.

 

THE STATUS OF OTUS:

Current Hypothesis: HE LIVES.

The Proof: In the ending sequence where we get to talk to all of our neighbors, the final friend we meet in the graveyard tells us that the things we are seeing are past, present and future. Going by the "soft reset" theory we mentioned above, this implies that there is not another Otus who goes by the same name talking to neighbors of perfectly identical shape in the future. This means that one of these pieces of dialogue are for current Otus in his future. The last individual also tells us that we may learn more about The Loop in our current lifetime. Noctae also noted that our presence next to his hologram was inconsistent with our death in the sky.

Ambiguity: Another spot with tons of ambiguity, and I'm fairly certain that this is the most intentional in that regard. He certainly looked quite dead. He was killed by Molstrom, only to be revived by the power of the relics. However, as he completed the Anti-Hex, he lost that power again and his healthbar is empty again. As we see him falling, his twinkle disappears behind the clouds, and we never see if it reaches the ground or not. Given such a drastic fall, it certainly seems unlikely that he survives. It is said that his friends make it out ok, so it is possible to have lived through such an event. It is worth noting that his exit from the scene is distinctly separate from theirs. While his 4 living friends go left, he is blown off to the right, and this may be symbolic of his fate in contrast to theirs. Otus being alive also raises strong questions about where we are during the end sequence. We can walk and talk, but the game tells us directly that we are not dreaming. So where are we if not in the afterlife?

Discussion: If I'm being honest, I don't think we're going to get a great answer here unless the developer speaks up eventually to give fans closure one way or another. That said, there isn't any great way to solve many of these ambiguities without creating other ones. We think this theory is the one that holds up the best considering all of the more solid information we have. For me, the proof listed above is the smoking gun. Each piece of dialogue references you by name, and its confirmed that at least one of them is from the future. Unless literally every conclusion we've made about the game so far is reversed, I feel fairly confident that our feathery friend lives.

 

MISCELLANEOUS

Drifting Islands: The professor notes early in the game that the islands are drifting apart and he attributes that to the machines in the owl temple. Since those machines have not been running, we know that the islands were moving apart simply because they were still drifting upwards. As they rose away from the planet, that naturally creates more space in between them. The catastrophe at the end of the game was not random and spontaneous, it was simply a tipping point of a process that had been going on for years.

The Last Apparition: The final individual that we talk to in our white silhouette walk very clearly uses Asios sprite. I don't think it is Asio. It references distant generations who started The Hex in the first person, and referenced Otus as a future generation. Unless Asio is secretly hundreds of years old, its unlikely that he was part of the society that created The Hex. The individual also states that they lived upon the surface during their time, which is also something that we have no reason to believe Asio has done. The game went out of its way to point out a hologram of an ancient owl that was an Asio precursor, so I believe it was that individual speaking with us.

Colored Otus: When you finish the game the first time and enter your white silhouette walk, your ability to fly is restricted. You're stuck walking until you absolutely need flight. The second time you beat the game, you can fly right off the bat. The third time I beat the game, I noticed that I was also able to spin. I had beat it 3 times, one for each cycle of the fight with Solus maybe? Either way, I made sure to spin such that the extra ability of the cloak kicked in. After that sequence ends, I found I was able to perform the same spin in our which sillhouette "not dream" land. On performing the upgraded spin, Otus gains back his color. I'm not 100% certain that this is intended, but it is reproducible. I can do it every time. So long as I do the spin before activating the Anti-Hex, I can make my color come back in the next scene. I'm under the impression that this feature was known. At the end when you sit to speak with the last individual, Otus sits facing away from the player, so that we never get to see him talking. IF this is intended, it could be another hint that Otus is alive.

Posted Nov 6, 2016, 11:19 AM UTC · edited

3264
Loading comments…