A Thought. (Akali's E)

Hey! I recently made a post about Tankali's potential with the new PBE rework (https://redd.it/5b39b7). It was kinda controversial, but it also garnered some pretty good discussion, so I thought, "Hey, why not make another one?"

 

Hold on to your pitchforks (but don't bring them out yet!) 'cause although this one's about the AP Akali all of you know and love, it's also about a part of Akali that most of you don't really like. It's the part of her kit that became completely redundant once they removed its interaction with her Q:

 

Crescent Slash (ACTIVE): Akali flourishes her kamas, dealing physical damage to nearby enemies.

 

That's right, it's her E! Now I know it still works well as a waveclear ability (perhaps even more so with the PBE rework) but the nerf that made it not proc the Q mark put it in a rather odd place; it simply doesn't have any synergy with the rest of her kit anymore. If one were to look at the similar abilities that other assassins have, Kat's W procs her Q mark (on live) and Zed's E provides a slow if activated by his W shadow. Basically, there's a level of synergy in those kits that make their spin-right-round ability do more than just waveclear. Akali had that once too, but now...

 

Now, on to the discussion portion of things. What would YOU do if you had the chance to change Akali's E? I'd prefer for your suggestion to be something that isn't blatantly OP (e.g. something like a blink-auto with percentage health damage wouldn't work -- Oh look, there's Ekko!) but would actually fit in and not break the game. Something that wouldn't turn her into pick-or-ban status, at least. So, pitchforks down yet? Go, go, GO!

 

P.S: I just came to the realisation that I should have named this "A Discussion" and not "A Thought". Oh well.

Posted Nov 6, 2016, 1:10 PM UTC · edited

318
striker879•

The whole "e" not activating her mark is kinda meh to me. Really you should be proc'ing your mark with your AA anyways, it does more damage. Combo should be: Q, pause, R, AA, Q, AA. Then throw a E in as you walk away if needed. Only real benefit to E proc'ing Q is the fact that E has a slightly larger range than your AA. So this is a moot subject.

If you want better synergy with her kit, do something like give is a slow, since we can no longer place shroud on people to slow them, how about if it slowed champions that way we could escape out in bad trades with it or continue to finish our combo on someone without burning another R to move over a couple inches on screen.

Also what if it refunded energy for hitting multiple champs, or a big speed up for outplays.

4
PutBluntly•

I really like the slow-enemy + speed-self concept. Could add a lot more flavor to an otherwise overlooked spell.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
SupportScrubOP•

Hm...these are some really good ideas. The slow on E I can't really see because it would go against Riot's current idea of BIG COUNTERPLAY, especially because she already has 3 dashes to catch up to someone (plus the blink with the rework). The energy refund, though, that's where I think the possibility for something balanceable lies. Her Q already refunds energy, though, and AFAIK there aren't any other energy-using champions that have refund on more than one of their abilities; maybe Akali could be the first. Thanks for your suggestions!

 

EDIT: Deleted doublepost. That's happening pretty often on mobile -- Reddit bug?

1
striker879•

Yeah I dont see them doing the slow either, and I guess it wouldn't be much different than placing shroud on your self to slow them with new W. But for the energy refund, Zed get energy refunded as along as his mimic'd ability hits with his original, so he can refund from shuriken and slash. Kennen gets energy refunded from applying 4 marks, and from lightning rushing through a enemy. Lee Sin gets energy off 2 AA's after EACH ability casted.

So what if for each champion you hit with E it refunds 10 energy? could offset some of the cost for shroud to escape when outnumbered or refund some to finish someone off.

1
SupportScrubOP•

I was thinking about the energy refund in terms of it taking one "ability slot", not how it interacted with the champion's other skills (e.g. Zed's energy refund being on his W, Lee Sin's on his passive). As for Kennen, I'll give it to you; he does indeed get energy back from both his passive and his E. Well, then. I guess you just made your case for Akali getting some energy back from her E.

 

A refund of 10 energy wouldn't be too huge of a buff, so I think it's a very balanceable idea. Even if it is somehow OP, numbers can still be tweaked, after all. The only thing I'm concerned about (that I didn't really state in my previous comment) is that this change still won't make E synergise with the rest of her kit. Like, yeah, it now refunds energy so you'll want to use it more often, but ultimately it's still the (forgive the odd comparison) black sheep in Akali's kit that doesn't play well with any of her other skills. Still, I really appreciate the effort and thought that you put into this. Thank you!

1
striker879•

Yeah, true. If they could make it interact more, while still providing wave clear that is very much needed. What if it refunded a certain amount of CD on one of her other abilities, like say shroud? Essentially you could trade energy by casting E, for lower CD on shroud? Lowering CD of Q or R wouldnt be that beneficial but on shroud I could see that being useful.

What if E left a mark as well? that could say be proc'd for a slow

1
Xipiz700117,348 Dat Rework :c•

Think that E only slows the target, when it is marked by Q. And you gain MS when you E 2 or more People. Think it wouldnt be OP, but overall adds more Utility to her.

1
Omitson835,132 I play too much•

Too much Roleplaying sentences for my liking in this post

Hold on to your pitchforks (but don't bring them out yet!)

That's right, it's her E!

Having said that, I suggested some mechanics a while ago

2
SupportScrubOP•

Yeah, might have gone a little overboard there. It's just that my previous post (and its ensuing discussion) was a little too serious so I thought that being a bit more lighthearted in this one would work out better.

 

Just so you know, I don't do roleplay. Like at all. So just peg it down to me being a little too enthusiastic with this post and not the fact that I like to pretend I'm another character altogether, alright?

 

Thanks for the link, I'll check it out. Seems very well-constructed (actually IIRC I've already read through it once before) and some of those ideas look really viable on paper. I'll still be keeping this thread open though, if you don't mind, in the hope of some new answers?

1
RumbleControllerFun•

Crescent Slash can be cast during the travel time of Akali's ultimate, doing so extends the duration of it's damaging hitbox as long as akali is dashing.

1
SupportScrubOP•

I'm trying to picture this. Do you mean that if you're on the opponent team and stand anywhere along the line of Akali's dash, you'll take damage from her E? That actually doesn't sound super OP, but it's still technically a pretty big buff. Hypothetically, if this does go through, Riot will most definitely take power from somewhere else in her kit. Would you be willing to compromise somewhere? Like lower damage on her Q, etc.?

2
RumbleControllerFun•

Do you mean that if you're on the opponent team and stand anywhere along the line of Akali's dash, you'll take damage from her E

yep, just some extra utility/synergy that her E desperately needs.

As for the nerf, they could make it so that if she's doing the R->E combination, she'll have lower R damage or longer R travel time.

1
SilverFangAkali•

I've been brainstorming ideas for an Akali rework, but here's what I put for her E. I'd like opinions.

E - Akali casts a shadow to a target location (like Zed W). Akali performs Cresent Slash immediately upon spell cast, and the shadow, after a certain delay (.75 seconds I'm thinking), also performs crescent slash. 9/8/7/6/5 second recharge time, 3/2.5/2/1.5/1 second CD, can hold 2/2/2/3/3 charges

Akali's shadow(s) last for 3.5 seconds, and if Akali casts crescent slash (places another shadow) again within a certain range, any shadow in range also performs crescent slash (at the same time Akali does) and has its duration refreshed.

Crescent slash can proc MotA.

Enemies can be damaged by multiple shadows.

1
SupportScrubOP•

This sounds like a really interesting concept, but IMO it overlaps too much with Zed's kit (as you yourself stated). I think most people would agree with me when I say that Akali's identity is her triple dash and W, and Zed's his duplicate shadows. Still, if Zed were to ever get a rework, your idea would be a pretty damn cool ability to put on his kit.

1
SilverFangAkali•

It's supposed to be similar to Zed's W. She (most likely) was part of his order, and was his best and favorite student. There was/is an easter egg where if Zed kills you, Akali is listed as a minion in the death recap. She should have a skill that involves using a shadow =/; it would fit thematically as the Fist of Shadow.

I would disagree what W is her identity. It's iconic yes, but not her identity. I think spell vamp is more her identity.

I didn't post the entire idea of my rework, but basically E allows her to do a lot of AoE burst have have area control just for a little bit.

1
CarlosLopez_69•

That would be absaloutely broken

1
Xipiz700117,348 Dat Rework :c•

Alright, i have (in my opinion) a pretty damn cool idea for her E. Her E have a 5-3s (lvl) cd. E is a fast and small skillshot (800 Range), or an instant Point and click, when the target is inside a 200-300 Range. It can only hit Champions (dont need to be marked with MotA) or creatures, who are marked with MotA. When it hit it does a small amount of dmg and marks enemies. After 2s the current Crescent slash will be cast at the marked enemy. It will also be casted when a) MotA detonates at the target or b) R on him. When the target dies in the 2s or with the cast of crescent slash, the mark goes over to the 2 nearest enemies (priorities champs). Killing or assisting will reset its cd by 2.5s. This will add some nice Decision making and Mechanics to her kit. For the Visual: Skillshot is a shadowlike, when marked, there is a shadowAkali over them. I know, that this need to be balanced. Any thoughts? Edit: New Thread with Idea posted

1