The question "To be or not to be" is a much darker question than most people realize.

In Hamlet's famous soliloquy, It begins with "To be or not toe be: that is the question". The soliloquy continues with Hamlet talking about all the pains in his life and the good things that could come out of killing himself.

NOTE: I am in no way promoting suicide.

Posted Nov 7, 2016, 2:12 AM UTC

78
Queentoad1•

I'm pretty sure most people recognize this is a contemplation of suicide.

4
FireMax5OP•

All I know is that I had no idea until I studied Hamlet.

3
Queentoad1•

It's a well known quote, so you probably just thought it a cliche of some sort before studying the source material. Understandable.

2
FireMax5OP•

That's basically what happened.

2
LadyGlen•

Obligatory late to the party.

This soliloquoy is not the first time Hamlet contemplates suicide. He talks about it in his first one in Act I, Scene 2.

The "To be or not to be..." speech goes on to Hamlet wondering why people don't just kill themselves. Why put up with all the crap in life? All the unknowns of the future, when you can take control and just end it yourself?

It's the "perchance to dream" part that Hamlet figures it out. He basically concludes that people are scared of what comes after death, and people would rather deal with the life they know than the afterlife that may or may not be waiting for it. Being aware of the finality of mortality and the fear of what's beyond it is what halts people: "Thus, conscience doth make cowards of us all."

There's also something else. Hamlet isn't just talking suicide here. These lines:

"And thus the native hue of resolution/ Is sicklied o'er with the pale cast of thought,/ And enterprise of great pitch and moment/ With this regard their currents turn awry/ And lose the name of action..."

In these lines, Hamlet talks about "action". Hamlet has a problem with taking action for a huge portion of the play. He can't bring himself to do much about his situation and the reason being he is so thoughtful and self-aware that he is, for lack of a better term, "thinking too much.", a direct contrast from Lady Macbeth's advice to Macbeth "Consider it not so deeply."

Hamlet's saying that people are stagnant and don't take action because they think too much on it, the consequences of the actions. It's ironic in a way because thinking before we act makes us not act, but when we do act without thinking, thinks turn chaotic, messy, and mindless. The few times Hamlet does get charged with emotion and do something (i.e. killing Polonius) he kills the wrong person and starts a second revenge subplot where he himself is the villain.

His leaping without looking at that point makes him a villain, for his girlfriend go crazy and die (there were other factors, but this was her breaking point), leads to Hamlet being sent away to die (which in turn results in Rosencrantz and Guildenstern being killed instead). Hamlet's one moment of FINALLY taking charge without thinking too much about it screws up everything.

The problem is as well Hamlet knows this about himself. He is so aware of all his qualities and flaws that he agonizes over them constantly.

In short, Hamlet's "to be or not to be" is not just about his contemplating suicide. It's about taking action in life in general, and how thinking about action, makes people not take any action.

3
FireMax5OP•

Shakespeare has way more emotion and complex stories than most of today's fiction.

1
Kathryn1962•

Not just the good things. The undiscovered country. The unknown makes cowards of us all. Or, at least, Hamlet.

2
FireMax5OP•

Some of the concepts in the soliloquy are just so deep and amazing and I love it.

1