r/ReefTank•
Neotenens

[Help] Questions about a 20 high no sump/no skimmer

[Help]

I have a spare 20 high kicking around, and I don't want to use it for freshwater. How viable would it be to have it lightly stocked (mostly inverts, they're what interests me most in saltwater), without a protein skimmer or sump (at least to start)? I know that I should probably start with something bigger, but I'm willing to get an auto-topoff system, and upgrade in the future. I have a fair bit of experience with freshwater and very small tanks, so I feel that I can keep it stable. I wouldn't add any organisms until I could keep everything stable in the tank.

Second question, would a clown gopby, rainford's goby, and various inverts be fine together? If I have to be specific about invert stock, I was looking at 1x Lysmata debelius, 1x Lysmata amboinensis, a few Mithraculus sculptus, and various snails. Would they be compatible?

Posted Nov 7, 2016, 2:41 PM UTC

113
thefishestate•

I had both of those gobies together, they were fine and adorable.

You should be fine with a 20gal without a sump&skimmer provided you are strict about weekly water changes.

3
NeotenensOP•

I'm very obsessive about water changes, they would definitely get done weekly. How much should I change, per week?

2
thefishestate•

10% is the typical recommendation, I do 13.5 to 15% depending upon how full my bucket is

3
NeotenensOP•

Thanks! Would what I listed be fine with some corals (probably just leathers and zoas, maybe hammers) in the future?

2
thefishestate•

The shrimp are totally fine. The emerald crabs are great, but they're opportunists so if you don't have algae for them they can and will turn on your soft corals. I do not let emerald crabs stay in my tank after they did their job :-) Though I do love them. I brought back my skunk cleaner shrimp because it was always robbing my LPS.

What were you thinking for lighting?

3