Constructive Criticism if you wouldn't mind :D

Custom Songs

Hey guys,

So i've decided to upload a few videos of myself playing some Rocksmith Tracks, but some of them sound off, or delayed, or just in general played pretty bad. Was hoping a few of you guys could have a butcher's and let me know of any ways of improving?

I'm completely self taught so my technique is all over the place, any advice is welcome.

Channel is here:

https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCZQfD0Rvt7EuqM7Ep5S1y4Q

edit: just wanted to thank anyone that watched, and especially you guys below that gave advice! In the words of good old Bob, One Love!

Posted Nov 9, 2016, 10:00 PM UTC · edited

178
emosoresexhttp://twitch.tv/elatedowl•

Pretty good overall, just seems like on some parts you aren't keeping time. e.g. My Own Summer 1:35; close your eyes and listen intently and you can hear you're a little choppy, you're dragging a bit. Beezleboss you seem a bit off in a few parts, playing on downbeat instead of upbeat before it, playing on rests on the frethand mutes. I think Wires is the best example though. Right in the intro, it's a real simple beat just playing on 1, 2, 3, 4 but it seems you're dragging and then playing catch up. I'd really recommend playing the intro outside the game with a metronome; it's really tempting to let the visual cues of the game tell you when to play but it's really important you actually feel the beat and not rely on the note highway.

4
probablymaybeOP•

Just watched the videos you mentioned and you are completely correct, maybe i should try and focus on the sound and rhythm of the actual song rather than trying to hit the notes in time as they appear on screen. Thanks a bunch for taking the time to watch and give me advice, i very much appreciate it!

1
DeMartini•

Overall, awesome playing. Also, I'm no guitar god. Don't take this as expert advice.

You've got some minor issues with things that Rocksmith doesn't grade very well. Rocksmith is pretty lax on timing in general. Also, I noticed that sometimes you played a smooth, legato style in sections that should have had more punch, thinking of RU Mine in particular.

I love Rocksmith, but one of its big problems is that the original guitar part is always there. That makes it hard to hear yourself and can cover up a lot. I suggest you try playing through an amp and just turning the volume on Rocksmith down to 0. Forget scoring entirely. Really listen and pay close attention to yourself without any backing whatsoever.

If you read tab or music you should try to cut Rocksmith out entirely at least part of the time. Tab is pretty easy to pick up if you haven't tried already.

Rock on.

3
probablymaybeOP•

I can completely see where you're coming from with the timing, I'll try and play a bit (well, let the track play without a cable plugged into the guitar) with just my amp and see if i can get it more accurate. I had the same issue trying to play Lateralus by Tool, it feels as though i'm losing the timing signature when i just follow the notes on the screen. Thanks very much for your advice!

1
ZagatoZeeNot Terrible•

FYI, there is a link in the side bar to ways to use your amp while still getting Rocksmith to score properly. Using the method described, it should cost you about $15 in gear, total.

1
akkular•

Sounded really good to me! Sorry can't offer any constructive critique as i'm pretty much a begineer but I enjoyed watching the videos. If anything, you make it look easy which I hope is of some help/encouragment.

2
probablymaybeOP•

Wow, thank you so much, really wasn't expecting any comments like that, im flattered!

1
EsotericRogueElite Guitarist•

+1 Standing while playing.

2