r/Brawlhalla•
_IZAC_

How exactly do attacks through walls work?

How exactly do attacks through walls work?

Posted Nov 21, 2016, 4:19 AM UTC

1813
pal0poe•

Hitboxes working through walls is very inconsistent regardless of how people think it works

11
_IZAC_OP•

Is this intended? Spear misses, axe misses, but the guns shoot through the wall?

(PS not salt I won)

6
Big_Ratatouilleay lmao•

usually that kind of spear attack will hit, and axes have always hit me through walls

3
_IZAC_OP•

Why?

1
MightyDebospamming dsigs works my guys•

They will hit if the middle of each player's hurtbox can have a line drawn between them and not be interrupted by terrain. It's not the middle for some moves, but that's generally how it works.

4
PluckerpluckQueenNai4Lyfe•

Pretty sure this is how it works, but with a good chance it only works in one direction (i.e you can't hit up, you can hit down). It just needs a bit of tweaking. It's frustrating when stuff like bow recovery seems to hook around corners because of the way it moves the player and how high it reaches (improving the chance of not colliding with the wall)

1
HyperHero•

Seems similiar to the old non clash idea, where it used numbers from health and such to determine the hit. Doesnt use any stats though.

1
pr0hibit3d•

The hitboxes of the attacks are not blocked by terrain however the players have collision boxes which won't let them walk through the wall.

0
_IZAC_OP•

So why does the spear not hit?

1
TrueMoominTIN Pride!•

Because the game handles these situations in a janky and inconsistent way. Some sigs can get really annoying with their whole "hit you through the wall" thing. It should get looked at.

2
BMG_ChillPenguinX•

Yeah we need to look into the consistency with it, but it mostly comes down to how abusable the individual attack is. The spear recovery is one we specifically don't want to hit in that situation because when it used to, people would just camp walls with spear and constantly try to abuse that around-the-corner hit box. It was awful, especially on Thundergard.

1
kardion•

Can you tell us what the general rule is for hitting stuff around-the-corner? Or is every single move individual?

1
BMG_ChillPenguinX•

For the most part it's a line-of-sight test from the source position of the attack (this is typically the center of the player's position, but can get detached from the player for hitboxed special effects like Azoth's Side Bow) to the top, bottom, left, and right edges of the target player's hurtbox. The checks are less strict for most light attacks (including down airs) and more strict for recoveries and signatures that are easier to abuse when wall camping.

Hopefully we'll find time to review and improve upon the system in the future, but the PS4 port is a higher priority at this time.

1