r/space•
tling

Has anyone run the numbers comparing ion thrusters vs. EM drive? EM drives seem useful, but not revolutionary

Discussion

The 34m x 12m solar panels on the ISS pull in 30 kW. Even if a spacecraft averaged a near-Sun orbit of 0.3 AU, where panels can generate 10x the Earth orbit power, they'd still pull in just 300 kW * 1.2 mN = 360 mN, and over 6 years, that's just 6.8 M kg m/s.

On a 300 kg spacecraft, that's 22 km/s, and New Horizons is barreling along at 45 km/s. Am I missing something, or are EM drives useful but not revolutionary?

The fact that SpaceX is promising 550 tons to LEO with ITS seems far more revolutionary since that could potentially be 5000 kg of propellant on a 500 kg craft.

Posted Nov 21, 2016, 6:13 AM UTC

624
Bokbreath•

The bit you're missing is 'propellant'. An EM drive doesn't need any. That means it can accelerate for as long as it can produce power.

7
tlingOP•

Yes, but you need solar power to make an EM drive useful, and solar panels are only effective in the interior solar system. But we have no problems reaching the interior solar system even without an EM drive. So why bother with an EM drive when there are tried-and-true chemical or ion thruster solutions?

1
Bokbreath•

You need power. It does not have to be solar. A nuclear generator would work just as well and would last decades, or if an RTG, possibly centuries.

11
SkyPL•

There are no missions planned nor proposed that would benefit from using EM Drive + Nuclear over far less controversial and expensive, yet offering far more trust Ion Drives. You'd need something that lasts very, very long and preferably goes beyond orbit of Jupiter. And even there RTGs + conventional propulsion have an upper hand (look at the Cassini - it's a dream mission that did more than anyone wanted it to do, and yet - it was done without EM Drive or Ions, in fact some of the aspects of this mission would be impossible to achieve with low thrust engines, so you'd have to have two propulsion systems which even further increases cost and mass).

You have to know that the lower acceleration you have, the more time you need to make a course changes, and time = money. Also remember that that scientists that propose missions in general would like to see them realized during the span of their career, and still have enough time to study the data after its over (which is one of the reasons why missions to the Ice Giants are so rarely proposed). Also lifetime of the hardware used on spacecraft also tends to be limited, which is especially relevant to instruments that rely on precise calibration (either scientific or things like reaction wheels, but even relatively "dumb" things can fail due to age, like harpoon and thruster on Philae lander did in 2014). u/tling certainly has a point - EM drive is not nearly as useful as some people imagine, even if we assume that having NASA launch nuclear reactor into space isn't anywhere nearly as problematic (borderline impossible) as it is in reality.

0
Bokbreath•

So many limiting assumptions. So little time.
First, I'm not sure why you limit discussion to currently proposed missions - and why you limit to currently proposed NASA missions at that. No one proposes a mission that is infeasible and a reactionless thruster changes what is feasible.
Second, time only equals money in finance. It does not equal money in space exploration. Time simply equals time.
Third. Scientists aren't the only people who propose missions and a moment's reflection will let you see how silly it is to limit exploration to the 50yr horizon of one person's career.
Finally of course, you're guilty of a failure of imagination. While we think/thought reactionless drives were impossible, it made no sense to consider what to do with one. Finsing one that works however, alters the balance. I'm not aware of any limitation in thrust other than the engineering of the current design so saying EM drives are not going to be a game changer is, I think, somewhat premature.

4
catsinabox•

Dawn, the most advanced ion spacecraft at the moment carried 425 kg of xenon propellant and had 10,000 m/s of delta-v for missions. 275 kg (64%) of that xenon was used to reach Vesta and perform its mission there. And that was saving propellant by way of a gravity assist from Mars. A further 110 kg (26%) was used to reach and orbit Ceres. Dawn has only 10% of its propellant left. It is essentially out of "fuel" and thus its missions have ended.

As you can see, transfer trajectories use up a lot of propellant. Dawn only reached 3 celestial bodies in total (Mars, Vesta, Ceres) and now its empty, but those 3 bodies were what the mission planners planned.

If (and it's a big if) the EM drive is real, the spacecraft would never run out of fuel because it requires none. Its delta-v is essentially infinite as long as it can generate electricity. It could visit anywhere in the solar system. Are you done with Ceres, then let's make a flyby of Venus. Done there, then let's visit every large asteroid. Got bored of asteroids, let's go visit Jupiter why not.

Telling a rocket scientist they have infinite delta-v for their spacecraft's missions is a big deal.

Whether it is cost effective to build an EM drive spacecraft versus the amount of scientific data generated is another matter however. Right now, scientists are content to send their spacecraft on one way missions.

Call me skeptical but to receive such benefits for no cost is too good to be true.

5
DDE93•

Revolutionary, but not too useful in their present form. As your own calculations show. The powerplant mass may make ion thrusters a more attractive option for most interplanetary missions.

3
tlingOP•

An ion thruster with 5000 kg of propellent * 50 km/s expellent rate would accelerate the same 300 kg craft at 833 km/s, about 40x faster than an EM drive with years of near-sun solar exposure on a 30 kW panel, and also 20x faster than the fastest spacecraft ever created.

3
Patrick26•

Maybe, but only in the long term, with the emphasis on long.

3
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
codeduck•

The key thing to remember is that IF this device works it is at the first step of a long chain of actions, which will focus on:

  1. determining why the hell it does what it does
  2. determining how to make the thruster more efficient

It is not inconceivable that if the EM drive works that there is a lot of efficiency to be gained by tweaking RF frequencies and cavity configuration - There's nothing magic about microwaves; if this phenomenon works for microwaves it should work for radio waves, x-rays, infrared etc with the correct reconfiguration of the resonant cavity.

If this works, it is not inconceivable to expect outputs in the milinewton / kW or higher once large-scale research starts.

3
wackyvorlon•

The big deal with EM drives -- if it proves to be real -- is that they appear to violate Newton's 3rd law of motion. That's really fucking weird. So far as we know the universe doesn't let you do that.

So, if the engine is real, then there's very likely some new physics being exploited by it that we do not yet understand. The thrust isn't the big deal here, it's how the thrust is being produced.

2
Patrick26•

violate Newton's 3rd law

And where does the reaction thrust go ... the one opposite the one that we see. Please don't say Dark Force.

2
wackyvorlon•

I have no idea. This, this is the problem.

I'm not one of the faithful here. I would love to see new physics, but it's useless if it's not real. I'm in the "cautiously optimistic" camp. I hope it's real, but violating newtons 3rd law isn't something you take lightly. You have to rule out everything.

There is only one thing I am certain of: Something, somewhere, is wrong. Unfortunately, I'm no physicist. I'm just an enthusiast. All I can do is wait for the actual physicists. If it turns out to be bunk, I won't be surprised.

2
tlingOP•

By my guesstimate, it would take about two orders of magnitude better performance from the EM drive before there are significantly different trajectories available. Maybe, maybe not -- who knows with something so new?

1
jayman419•

The device as it exists now is more of a proof of concept. 2000 years ago no one looking at an aeolipile could imagine a steam locomotive.

Eagleworks is trying to raise it up to a 0.1N/kw range. If that works, they'll continue to try refining it further while those models go for more testing.

Since we don't know if it works at all, and if it does then we don't know why yet, so it's hard to say how efficient it can become.

5
Oxideist•

It's just like computer processing, 40 years ago a few megabytes took up an entire room, now you can fit a terabyte in your hand.

Once we prove it'll work, we can increase its capabilities to whatever our engineering necessitates.

1
Ian_W•

People need to remember there are now better solar panels than they bought for the ISS.

Here is the relevant page from Spectrolab for space-rated panel.

http://www.spectrolab.com/DataSheets/Panel/panels.pdf

2
tlingOP•

This 'people' is still wondering how much better newer space-rated panels are than the ISS panels.

2
TbonerT•

Right now it is not particularly useful. Installing one capable of counteracting the drag the ISS experiences would increase power consumption by at least 25%. That's a big deal and not worth it. They will likely be able to refine it, increasing thrust and decreasing power requirements.

1
Patrick26•

I wonder if two side-by-side drives would be additive, or one drive inside another. Do they combine, destructively or constructively, or something different?

1
codeduck•

you would need to power both, and it would make sense in that case to simply put double the power through one, because you'd save the mass of the additional wiring, heatsinks etc for the second thruster.

1
Patrick26•

Yes, but only if the two units produce thrust that is additive. Since we don't know the origin and nature of the force that is an assumption.

1
dblmjr_loser•

Asteroid mining. Puttering along from rock to rock without needing to use fuel. Sounds very useful.

1