Most of the Cascadia bioregion is actually owned by the federal government
img.washingtonpost.com/wp-apps/imrs.php?src=h...Posted Nov 21, 2016, 5:53 PM UTC
Posted Nov 21, 2016, 5:53 PM UTC
Not sure how extensively this has been discussed, but it may make the most sense to frame the Cascadian argument in terms of devolution of federal natural resource and land management to the state or (hypothetical) region.
Relevant article: https://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/govbeat/wp/2013/10/15/almost-half-the-west-is-federally-owned-now-some-states-want-their-land-back/
Doing that before Cascadia is its own governing entity is a surefire way to lose those public lands. States do not have the resources to manage those lands the way the federal government does, and many states laws (including those states that would make up Cascadia) stipulate that state lands must be managed for profit. That means they would need to increase resource extraction or charge you a hell of a lot to use it. If they cannot be managed for profit, they must be sold. Federal lands do not have those stipulations. Within the current governing construct, transferring the huge swaths land currently owned by the feds would assuredly result in all Cascadians losing access to most of it over time. We need to work on devolving other powers to us, as Cascadia, not as Oregon, Washington, BC and Alaska, and then we can talk about land transfers. But until Cascadia has a governing body that can and will protect those lands, it's a bad idea.
Good to know. But this could just as well be an argument for getting our act together on the state level, reforming state laws to follow through on the espoused ideal of environmental protection that hasn't even been realized on a state level. If we can't manage to reform our own existing laws to effectively protect Cascadia's natural resources, why should we expect a new regional government to?
Totally agree with you there. If state laws were amended to appropriately protect these lands for public use, I'd be down with transfers. There is one caveat, however, which is the enormous budget necessary to manage those lands. One bad wildfire fire could feasibly wipe out a given states land management budget. There would need to be a lot of work done at the local level, including how to allocate financial resources for daily management and emergency management. I don't think any individual state has the resources for that, which is why I wouldn't fully be comfortable with transferring those lands to local control unless we were transferring it into Cascadian hands, not Oregon's hands or Washington's hands. It really requires a greater management level than states can provide.
Interesting. Maybe there could be some regional coordination mechanism/fund between WA/OR/CA for natural disaster management.
Anyway, I think it's good to think about both formal and informal avenues of regional integration that fall short of independence/secession. Better in my mind to really establish a cohesive regional identity and push for quasi-autonomy through legal avenues/means than to advocate secession from the get-go.
[deleted]
Oregon is currently in the process of selling off state forests to timber companies. We need stronger state-level protections before giving them more land would be a good idea. The timber lobby is very strong in OR/WA.
Both state and national forests are sold off for timber and other natural resources, and not just in Oregon. Ironically, in this system of perverse incentives, private forests are managed more sustainably since they use sustainable yield methods rather than clearcutting.
But yeah that's what I'm saying. More protection on state level.
Most of that are national parks created for the purpose of preserving the land. Its the one thing thats actually good about Federal ownership of the land and Cascadia needs to maintain its protection. Don't fall for the trap of letting it go to the states and private hands. Thats literally the antithesis of so much of the reasoning behind Cascadia.
If you can't trust your own state to steward public lands and natural resources, why would you expect a governmental entity called Cascadia to do it? Or are you not advocating independence?
I also don't think you understand how a lot of federal land (not just state) is used for what is essentially natural resource exploitation. If it doesn't have a high level designation of protection, the lands are effectively put in private hands since the resources are licensed off. In many countries throughout the world, and even to some degree the United States, the level of national ownership of public lands corresponds to the level of irresponsible environmental stewardship. This is the whole idea behind the devolution of land management and the strengthening of protections on the state/local level. And if the Cascadian region can't implement stronger protections for its own forests/lands on the state level, then the idea of Cascadia (whether as an identity or an entity) is a joke.
Why are you assuming that the current states will even be a thing if Cascadia happens? I don't think understand the situation as it curretly stands. The current states are trying very hard to take control of federal lands largely to hand them to private interests. In the current system of things the federal government ironically is protecting them better. We can't trust the states themselves because they are dominated by the same corporate interests that dominate the federal government. They dominate states even more so in many cases. If you think we want the current states to be a part of a future Cascadia government you are sorely mistaken.
If you think we want the current states to be a part of a future Cascadia government you are sorely mistaken.
Who's we? There are organizations that advocate a particular revolutionary stance (and tend to speak on behalf of everyone), but this subreddit shares different points of view and different ways of conceiving Cascadia. Realistically, in my view, if the people who reside in Cascadia can't effectively reform their own state governments and laws through peaceful and legal means and elect the right people, they're not likely to have any success forming a new country (much less mobilizing people to support a movement toward it). The same inertia which is behind a Cascadian identity and regional solidarity can be leveraged to change the states we currently live in, much more successfully (again, in my view) than the pipedream of an independent country. And, in any case, one isn't to the exclusion of the other -- if anything, one just makes the other more possible, more realistic. If the United States becomes profoundly destabilized as the most powerful political entity that has ever existed on this planet -- threatening the relative peace and stability of the country and world -- we can talk realistically of an independent Cascadia as the natural outgrowth of a weakening sovereign or a total vacuum or power. In the meantime, it's a fantasy. There are regions torn apart by conflict, or regions where there's profound political instability, or regions where there has been irredentism for centuries with sporadic rebellions and conflicts, and yet they are still in the grip of the sovereign state that the region resides in.
It's including Native American reservations as federal land. Nope. That's sovereign.
Yeah that's important to point out. But tribes have limited juridical sovereignty ("tribal sovereignty"), which is the authority to govern themselves. The federal government exercises (or has the right) to exercise power over reservations in a number of ways. As the very name implies, these are federal lands reserved (i.e., effectively protected) for tribes through the Bureau of Indian Affairs, so it's still federal land.
It could all be decentralized to tribal government and community management.
whoah! look at all that checkerboard from the railroad days. cool map!
:)
We need to be careful about how the Cascadian movement handles this issue because it can easily blow up in our faces. The truth is, under the current governing constructs, devolving ownership and management of federal land in the west would be a disaster. As it stands right now, state lands must be managed for profit and if they are not turning a profit they must be sold. This means that either resource extraction needs to be kicked up tremendously, or you will get charged a whole hell of a lot to use the land (for recreation, hunting, fishing etc). Federal lands do not have these stipulations. Add to that, the enormous budget that the Feds have to handle natural disasters. Many states management budgets would be decimated by a single large forest fire. If the state cannot maintain management, it gets sold, which means we all lose access. Yes, the Federal budget for land management is meager compared to the total budget, but it is tremendous compared to what the states alone can handle.
It is important to know and understand these issues because Federal Land Transfers are likely to become more prevalent in the coming years. Politicians and corporations are already using this under the guise of states rights and local management to have lands transferred to the states, knowing full well that those lands will soon end up on the auction floor. Do not let them fool you with that message. It will result in losing those lands for the public forever.
Here are a few websites that cover the issue, and notably they are all organizations geared primarily towards hunters and anglers. Despite common myths about the conservative nature of this community, Federal Land Transfers are taken extremely seriously because they use far more of those public lands than your average hiker or backpacker.
trcp.org
backcountryhunters.org
sportsmensaccess.org
This all isn't to say that someday those lands cannot be transferred to Cascadia. But until those portions of California, Oregon, Washington, BC and Alaska form at least a Cascadian coalition, with a co-managed management plan and common budget, transferring those lands to the individual states is a surefire way to lose them forever. Be mindful of anyone wishing for Federal Land Transfers before a complete over-hall of the way state lands are managed is completed.
Thanks for the info. I think it's an unfortunate and strange irony that keeping it federal is in the best interest of a Cascadian ideal.
I'm really happy that the government owns the land. I don't need some asshole, mega-rich businessman like Trump owning Mt. Rainier. I don't need to go to "Crater Lake National Park, Presented by Coca-Cola." Fuck, I don't need to look out my windows at the mountains and the water only to be reminded that they are the private property of some recluse cowboy. By having the government own the land, the land effectively and simultaneously belongs to no one and everyone. The wild is the essence of Cascadia, and the wild doesn't stay wild if some asshat owns it.
Devolution is about the de-centralization of ownership/management from a national level to state or (in some cases) local level management. In this case it would be a devolution from federal to state-level control. It's not about privatizing anything.
And if you're for Cascadian independence, how could you be for federal control of Cascadia's natural resources? Do you not understand that the state -- or hypothetical region -- could manage these same resources in the same manner as federally protected land (except much better)?
I'm not for Cascadian independence. I've been following the development for 15 years, since 2001 or 2002 when the movement was essentially asleep, and decided long ago as an underclassman in college that secession is not the way to go. Since then I've learned that most of the others who have been with the movement for a mature period of time are anti-secession, too.
But I hear you on de-evolution vs. privatization. Even if my own posting wasn't a response to yours.
What I'm saying is that devolution of federally managed land to the state level should be how the Cascadian movement is framed, rather than secession. There are all sorts of reasons why the federal government mishandles national parks/forests, not just because of DC budgetary politics that leave parks/forests in the dust whenever the federal gov't is strapped for cash, but in terms of how federal management leaves natural resources up for grabs by commercial concubines. Think of how a Trump administration could effectively reverse much of the federal protections that already do exist, especially since some federally protected lands come from executive actions and not acts of Congress.
Upvoted. Not a bad idea, however I prefer to frame Cascadia as international rather than local. I'd prefer to have the Cascadian wild declared a world heritage site, or something of the like, by the United Nations.