r/canada•
splooges

The F/A-18E/F Super Hornet was already Junk back in 2000

TLDR: The Super Hornet is expensive junk.

In light of the Liberal party's announcement to procure 18 interim Super Hornet fighters (and inevitably locking in the Super Hornet as the replacement for the current CF-188 Hornet in five years), I'd like to present how US Navy/Marine Aviators viewed the Super Hornet back in 2000.

Information can be found on Page 671 of the US Congressional Record, Jan 24 to Feb 23, 2000.

EDIT: Alternate link

Some excerpts:

"Still stinging from the A-12 debacle, the Navy tried to "put one over'' on Congress by passing off a completely redesigned aircraft--the Super Hornet--as simply a modification of the original Hornet. The obfuscation worked. Many in Congress were fooled into believing that the new aircraft was just what the Navy told them it was--a modified Hornet. In fact, the new airplane is much larger--built that way to carry more fuel and bombs--is much different aerodynamically, has new engines and engine intakes and a completely reworked internal structure. In short, the Super Hornet and the original Hornet are two completely different aircraft despite their similar appearance."

"Because it was never prototyped--at the Navy's insistence--its faults were not evident until production aircraft rolled out of the factory. Among the problems the aircraft experienced was the publicized phenomenon of "wing drop'"--a spurious, uncommanded roll, which occurred in the heart of the aircraft's performance envelope. After a great deal of negative press, the Super Hornet team devised a "band-aid'' fix that mitigated the problem at the expense of performance tradeoffs in other regimes of flight. Regardless, the redesigned wing is a mish-mash of aerodynamic compromises which does nothing well."

"In a dog fight, superior maneuverability allows a pilot to bring his weapons to bear against the enemy. With its heavy, aerodynamically compromised airframe, and inadequate engines, the Super Hornet won't win many dogfights. Indeed, it can be outmaneuvered by nearly every front-line fighter fielded today."

"The Super Hornet's shortcomings have been borne out anecdotally. There are numerous stories, but one episode sums it up nicely. Said one crew member who flew a standard Hornet alongside new Super Hornets: "We outran them, we out-flew them, and we ran them out of gas. I was embarrassed for those pilots.'' These shortcomings are tacitly acknowledged around the fleet where the aircraft is referred to as the "Super-Slow Hornet.''

"What about the rank-and-file Navy fliers? What are they told when they question the Super Hornet's shortcomings? The standard reply is, "Climb aboard, sit down, and shut up. This is our fighter, and you're going to make it work.'' '

"Madam President, that is the response of James Stevenson to the Navy's letter questioning Lt. Col. Jay Stout's comments. I offer these as evidence that we are about to embark on an F/A-18E and F airplane that, frankly, after having been looked at for several years, at best is not better than the current plane, and probably is worse, and is enormously more expensive than continuing with the FA-18C and D plane."

I would also like to note that the Kuwaitis are to buy 32 Super Hornets and associated parts for $10.1 billion, or over $300 million each. Tell me again how the Super Hornet is so much cheaper than the F-35.

EDIT: The Kuwaitis are buying 40 Super Hornets, at over $250 million each.

Posted Nov 23, 2016, 2:32 AM UTC · edited

77237
Loading comments…