Classic DMing jokes - or - a savvy PC who just keeps getting tricked
Hey guys! Just wanted to share a good story from last night, inspired by what I've read here previously (though the search function fails me).
DMing 5e classic fantasy in Faerun for a party of six
Human ranger, paladin and barbarian, halfling rogue, dwarf druid and a black dragonborn sorcerer.
They arrive at a Tavern after a long while on the road.
Describe the tavern to be like "The Common Inn", only common allowed, non-humans serviced not-with-a-smile, everything absolutely basic and cliché.
Describe patrons to mostly include apparent locals, shit-smelling farmers like you would expect in a 90 % human countryside.
Also note a dark stranger sitting alone at the bar, clad in dark robes and hood up, with a few strands of white hair barely visible. Also a few halflings doing some business at the side table.
Most of the party is perfectly content to get drunk on Suzale and settle for the night.
Antagonistic bartender, constantly riled up by his angry wife who is the cook tells the party to behave and warns them to simply enjoy their beers and not do anything that's not commonplace - because funny business doesn't fit their brand.
Again most of the party just chuckles at this, but black dragonborn sorcerer has authority issues of a kind, she needs to be the top dog and make sure others are around know they are inferior.
Bartender evades the sorcerer's glares, so she turns her gaze at the dark stranger at the bar.
She's not having this mystery business, cue Intelligence (Arcana) and Intelligence (Investigation) checks.
Nothing magical apparently, slender features, rather immobile? White hair - maybe a drow?
Digging the brooding though, my sorcerer goes to sit with the stranger, mimicking its pose and everything.
Describe an untouched drink.
Curiosity eventually takes over, my sorcerer glances under the hood.
Reveal the stranger to be an elaborate setup consisting of a long dark coat, a floor mop, a broom and some twigs.
With the bartenders hearty chuckle the tavern erupts in laughter, cries of "Works every time!" and "Oh, Adventurers!" are heard.
Dragonborn sorcerer uses magic to bash the broom and mop to the opposite wall, cursing loudly at this "insult".
The tavern quiets to more inaudible giggling and the party rushes to gently restrain their sorcerer.
She's actually really a he, but has yet to manage to remove a previously found Girdle of Masculinity / Femininity that he greedily equipped without too much studying and attuning.
My next session is probably going to be consumed by the sorcerer setting up an elaborate revenge on this tavern that tries to ensure nothing unusual ever happens - everything from arson to a haunting is on the table.
Thanks to this sub and others like it. Even though some of my players are redditors I've managed to surprise them with things mentioned here if I just make sure they come up months and months later. One of my players even started to suspect it, but he and his character gladly played along and I'm thankful, because we all enjoy seeing our most resourceful arcanist getting messed with.
If you guys have any similar cliches or examples of other ways to trick your players or stories of how you've been tricked, please share!
Posted Nov 28, 2016, 11:35 AM UTC · edited
[Top third post all time in r/dnd](https://www.reddit.com/r/DnD/comments/4m4tp3/theres_a_dark_cloaked_figure_hunched_over_at_the/).
I mention this not because of "oh fuck reposts", but because you may find more humor to apply to your PCs in the comments.
Of course - sweet! Thanks!