Some general feedback

Since next big expansion is getting close I wanted to give some feedback, suggestions and share some of my concerns. It's just general points not related to balance/current meta/current league.

  • Skill gems and leveling

There are tons of skill gems available at vendors, but most of them are never used when leveling. It's not much of a problem when you're experienced player, but it really hurts if you do not know the game well. In the recent months I helped 2 new players and both used terrible skills (and both experimented with different skills, they didn't just randomly pick skills). I feel like some skill gems should be just removed from normal vendors - niche skills that are rarely used (maybe even make them drop only?), skills that do not have much support from tree/available support gems for that class (for example firestorm for marauder - you get it at the end of first act, but there is almost nothing that can help you scale this skill until much later into the game unless you get lucky with drops). Maybe it would be better if you unlock some of the skills once you ascend? About half of the skills that you find in A1 for example are either never used or used as support skills much later on.

  • Chat

We need the ability to subscribe to multiple trade/global channels. For example /sub global 820 en, /unsub global 820 en. To send message to channel - "#820en Message", using "#" broadcasts message to all global channels you're subscribed to (with some cooldown if you're subscribed to multiple channels). Or even better solution - add ability to create unique named chats moderated by players and ability to make them private (invite-only) or public. Having the ability to only join 1 chat turned 820 from master sharing channel into abomination it is now (and there is no ability to even moderate it).

  • HUD

Information is all over the place. Buffs at top left corner. Minimap at top right corner. Flasks at bottom left corner. Abilities/cooldowns in bottom right corner. Certain things clutter already cluttered buff bar for absolutely no reason. Few examples: there is no reason to show flasks on buff bar, especially multiple buffs per flask - you can just indicate that flask is active and how long it will be active on flask bar; auras are now shown in the skill bar and skill selection, I see no reason to show them separately in the buff bar, just 1 square that shows number of auras and expands when you hover cursor over it is more than enough (and only because of friendly auras). Separate active skills, passive triggered skills and passive activated mana reservation skills in skill selection menu.

And the worst part about HUD - map (overlay and mini). That is like the one of the first complaints of every single person I ever tried to bring into the game. Even when you get used to it it's still extremely bad. It looks ugly. There is no clear indication of walkable ground, there is even no clear indication of edges of walkable ground, there is no consistent indication of entrances/exits (sometimes they are not even shown on map), color choice is extremely bad - in some zones you need to put transparency to 0 to see the map, in others you need to set it to almost 50 to be able to see anything through it, in some it's unusable regardless of transparency settings. D1/D2 had better overlay map and these games are 15-20 years old. Make map schematic and consistent. Walkable ground should look different (example of worst map - Graveyard or Arid Lake endgame map) and zone edges should be easy to distinguish from it (example of worst map - Marshes endgame map). Irrelevant things should not be on the map (Aqueduct-based tileset map is the worst offender).

  • Microtransactions

Now that GGG started to add one new type of stash tab after another I want to bring this up again. Thankfully Essence tab doesn't give you any advantage because it's just a more limited premium tab. But currency stash tab is something that I feel should be available to everyone. Game has much more things that clutter your stash that it had at release, but the amount of basic tabs is exactly the same. In one of the podcasts (it was after currency tab or public tab API release, I don't remember) Chris said that they don't want to sabotage their sales by giving players too much. But adding new types of tabs already hurts it. Why buy another tab if you can wait for them to add some new tab that replaces several tabs? I think you should just be able to select tab layout when tab is empty (so you can select regular 12x12 layout, currency layout, essence layout etc). I also think there should be some kind of starter pack for $15-$25 that you can purchase once per account and gives you several premium tabs, upgrades basic 4 tabs to premium that allows you to play comfortably and not wait for 100 different daily deals. Also it blows my mind how you can earn cosmetics just by playing the game when they have ridiculous prices in shop, but you can't earn even 1 stash tab per league. Would it really hurt them if you could earn 1 tab at like 20 challenges once every 3 months? They may also limit amount of tabs you can earn that way. I also think that having weekly sales (like the recent thanksgiving week sale) with more items on sale will be much better than having daily deals on single item. It's really depressing when you skip daily deal on something that you wanted and even more depressing when you see something that you wanted to go on sale, but you're only able to buy it next day when the sale is already ended.

Posted Nov 30, 2016, 2:50 PM UTC · edited

25
VoiceOfTroll•

But currency stash tab is something that I feel should be available to everyone.

All I had to read. Shit post. Shit comment.

1
mattc3303Necromancer•

I agree with every other point but...

If you want to be a completely free player GGG allows you to make as many mules as you want solving your lack of stash space problem. Its less convenient but that is what microtransactions gives you convenience and also cool capes.

1
DemonikEdgeOPOccultist•

I know that. I played more than half a year with mules. And I think rather than finding new ways to force people to buy stash space they should focus on making cosmetics purchases more attractive. They're giving away cosmetics left and right, while keeping ridiculous prices, of course people will mostly buy stash tabs under such conditions. And I feel that something like currency tab really should be available to everyone. You can also argue that giving instant level up to 70 for money is also just a convenience, it doesn't make it any better. A single currency tab replaces a whole mule account and a fuckload of time. And I don't want to be a completely free player. I even offered a suggestion to add starter pack that includes enough tabs for comfortable play and I have enough tabs for comfortable play myself. I just think that they make it way to much pain in the ass for free players recently.

Also one point that I also missed is how bad microtransaction stash is. I have few cosmetics (mostly free, but I bought some and got some from supporter packs) and I think it really doesn't help sales that it's EXTREMELY annoying to sort them without the ability to even move them inside the tab. But I heard on one of the recent podcasts that they want to change that, so I didn't mention it.

1
mattc3303Necromancer•

In the ideal world yeah they would give those out for free but tabs probably makes a huge bulk of their revenue. I rather have GGG make money and make content then satisfy free players. In my opinion GGG already does microtransaction is the fairest way I ever seen in any game.

Instead of the currency tab I think 1 premium tab should be given out for free since its so intertwined with the trade system. Having to download a third party app as an alternative is kinda strange thing for free/new players. Trade is a core part of the game.

1
DemonikEdgeOPOccultist•

tabs probably makes a huge bulk of their revenue

Did you read my post? I explained exactly why that happens. There is no incentive to buy cosmetics (you get a ton for free already and those that you can buy have absolutely ridiculous cost - why would I buy wings for a price of a full AAA game if you can just do 36 easy challenges?), but there is already tons of incentive to buy stash tabs (tons of currency items, divination cards, essences, store maps, trade, consistent timing on stash sales) and they just keep adding more things to clutter your space with each league and then tabs to store all that. I do not mind entry price for comfortable play, I just think they should just make different layouts an option for at least premium tabs as I suggested rather than separate tab type.

1