r/pebble•
benfischer

In light of Todays news, My experience with apple watch

iOS

I got tired of the constant disconnects with iOS back with Pebble OS 4.x came out and got an Apple Watch S1. Since the future of Pebble looks iffy I thought I'd pass along the differences. For reference, I had an OG Pebble and a PTS. I could post a lot about what I think Pebble did wrong with 4.x, but that would do no good. Instead here are some things I learned from my experience with the Apple Watch.

  1. The screen is phenomenal. I'll forgive a lot because of the screen. It's clear and crisp and the colors are beautiful. Messages are displayed in full color and pictures look as good on the watch as on the iPhone, but smaller of course. I've had no issue with the raise-to-wake function and it hasn't been a problem to not have an always-on screen. If you ever use your watch off your wrist (like, you put it on a table and glance at it as you do something else), the Apple Watch won't work for you, but if you keep it on your wrist it will be fine.

The touch screen is good, but I do kind of miss the buttons. For some things it's a little easier to have a dedicated hardware button, but the touch screen is clearly more flexible and it's probably more user-friendly.

  1. Usage. Pebblers (including me) like to brag that the Pebble is a watch, not a smartphone strapped to their wrist. The Apple Watch is a watch. The main usage is a watchface with complications that add information, like weather or appointments or activity. In no way does it feel like a smart phone on your wrist. Older versions of Watch OS may have given that vibe, based on what I've read, but I personally never had a watch before Watch OS3 so I can't say.

  2. Battery Life. With the current version of Watch OS, battery life is comfortably 2 days. I frequently sleep with my watch on. The only nuisance there is that I turn off raise-to-wake before I go to sleep and that's a little cumbersome to turn off and turn back on in the morning.

  3. Customization. The Apple Watch is nowhere near as customizable as the Pebble. There are no third-party watchfaces at all. There are tons of complications available, but they don't affect the overall appearance of the watchface.

  4. Third party support. The Apple Watch has way more support from third party vendors. Not all the 3rd party apps are useful, and just like with the phone apps, there's a great disparity in developer skill among vendors, but companies are busy adding watch apps and complications to support the watch. You can get adaptors for watch bands. The 42mm Watch uses 24mm watch bands and the 38mm Watch uses 20mm watch bands, so if you have a 20mm PTR you can re-use your bands. I have some bands with quick-release pins that use the adapter and some with the native Watch strap connector. There are tons of straps available and you can spend as much or as little as you want.

  5. Of course, the Apple Watch works better with the iPhone. there are no problems with disconnect (some people on Reddit report disconnects, but there are not many and I've had no problems). Replying to text messages with Scribble is pretty cool. Using Apple Pay with the watch is cool. But most things work about the same. Siri is ... Siri. I don't find Siri all that helpful on the phone either, but it's useful sometimes to change playlists while I'm out on a run, for instance.

  6. Water resistance. My S1 is water resistant or splash resistant, not water proof. What that means in practice is that when I get back from a run I rinse it off under the faucet and it's fine, but I wouldn't wear it in the pool or shower (though some people do). I thought long and hard about that. One of the neat things I did with the Pebble was control my music from the pool, but the Bluetooth would cut out if I had my arm under water and would take a short amount of time to reconnect (10-20 sec) so it wasn't 100% useful anyway. In the end I decided the extra water proofing wasn't worth the extra $100.

  7. Health Tracking. I don't really have problems with the heart rate monitor. The three activity rings are simple and intuitive. The built-in activity monitoring is OK and there are many third party options for activity tracking. Apple doesn't currently do any sleep monitoring probably because until recently you couldn't really sleep with it on. They are rumored to be interested in it, but knowing Apple that will have to wait for the next model with a "M9" type motion processor. There are 3rd party sleep apps, but I haven't used any.

What I miss about my Pebble is the quirkiness of it. I genuinely miss the old pixely getpebble.com from a couple of years ago. The Apple Watch is polished and awesome, but it's not nearly as fun.

I got the 42mm Watch, which is about the same size as the PTS. I think the price is a OK, but maybe a little high. if you can get one for $30 or more off, that's a good deal.

With all that said, I'll be sad if Pebble goes away. They had good ideas, but ultimately couldn't get the scale they needed, I guess.

Posted Dec 1, 2016, 11:16 PM UTC

3410
mlshuler•

Appreciated.

9
ozdreamingpebble time steel black kickstarter•

Seconded. Unless I switch to iOS (unlikely), I'm not in the market for an Apple Watch, but this was a well-written, detailed report, and I appreciated OP's perspective. Be interested to know if he is still rocking the AW in a year.

1
pawel_z_wrocka•

Very much appreciated as well.

I am an iOS (and MacOS) user and was considering Apple Watch in the past, but decided on Pebble instead. In the current situation I may be considering Apple Watch again.

Your post is very interesting, @benfischer. I expected the biggest issue to be the screen that is not always-on, but as I can see maybe the biggest issue for me would be no third-party faces.

That and no sleep tracking.

1
f1ngl0ng3r•

Thanks for that, I had the original Apple Watch (series 0?) and the 'it's a tiny phone' issue is what drove me to pebble. That, and one other issue people switching might want to consider: build quality.

I had my space gray aluminium Apple Watch less than 6 months and the anodized coating had started flaking away. It also fell off of my bedside table once all of about 50cm onto the floor and got a noticeable dent. So if you want something even approaching as robust as a PTR, you need to skip the lowest level and go for the stainless steel case ones. Or, put it in a case.

1
49616eAndroid•

I was a former Apple Watch user (original, 38mm), my experience was kind of like "meh". The battery life of my watch was not acceptable, the watch dies within 24 hours, and WatchOS lags after upgrading to the latest one. My favorite watchface was the one allows maximum customization (the one with digital time display), but I still think it can't display enough info. Having apps is nice but because of the lag I didn't find myself using 3rd party apps that much. I do appreciate the nice integration though, and the HR & pedometer is pretty great too. I think Apple Watch would be the best bet for Apple users.

1
benfischerOPpebble time steel silver ios•

Your comments are fair. But before you write it off, the newer watches are MUCH faster than the original.

1
49616eAndroid•

I heard from my friends that the battery life was much better on the newer models. Would buy if I'm still using iOS, lol

1
ryuitxipebble steel stainless•

Really? Why is everyone with an apple watch coming back here just to justify their decision? You like to live under apple's closed garden, ok, let the rest of the world think by their own.

-24
toblu•

I don't see the problem. It's an insightful report from a former pebble user.

24
benfischerOPpebble time steel silver ios•

Well, I tagged my post iOS and specifically addressed the experience of my iPhone with my Apple Watch in case any other iOS users are worried about the future of Pebble. I suppose it's reasonable to assume I'm comfortable in apple's ecosystem. Or did you expect me to switch to Android because Fitbit is buying Pebble?

10