Mill Reporters Rogue

Discussion

The idea is basically to staple Daring Reporter(s) onto a Mill Rogue deck. I have had mixed results so far. The original list is here: http://imgur.com/a/E4D3l

I dropped a Conceal, Auctioneer, and Sprint for Thalnos, 1x Sap, and Brann.

The deck feels like it's close to working, but I'm basically learning how to play Rogue on the fly, because I've never had a viable Rogue deck before.

The idea is to basically run a Mill Rogue deck and staple Daring Reporter on to it as a secondary win condition. I don't have any copies of Preparation, and it's a very expensive craft for a deck and class I don't usually play. I'm considering also trying the idea in Druid and just using the reporters with the Coldlight Oracles and Naturalize instead.

Any suggestions would be welcome.

Posted Dec 4, 2016, 8:57 AM UTC

816
ASIMItheHERO•

Why all the small drops? I know that the meta I heavily dominated by pirate warrior but does taunts and heals not increase chance of survival more?

1
TacosAreJustice•

Milling pirate warrior is going to be a bad time...

1
ASIMItheHERO•

That still begs the question whether the small drops will improve the decks win% beyond 0 against pirate warrior, else you might just as well you the deckslots to improve the other matchups.

2
TacosAreJustice•

Good point... I think the win condition for pirate warrior would be surviving long enough to build a big minion, since most pirate decks have little to no removal.

1
ProzacElfOP•

You and u/TacosAreJustice make solid points. As I said, I've never really had a functional Rogue deck before so I basically just took the core idea and started putting cards around it. A lot of what I still have there was sort of designed to help fuel the Auctioneer, but now that I've taken it out I should probably change some more things.

I'm not sure what healing to put in, although taunts would probably help. Mistress of Mixtures and Refreshment Vendor are about the only neutral heals I can even think of in standard. Tournament Medic seems way too clunky to put in.

1
ASIMItheHERO•

My most successful mill list last expansion used farseers and refreshment vendors, but most importantly Reno Jackson.

The good thing about putting Reno in a mill deck is that you don't even need to worry about duplicates because of your insane draw, it limits when you can use gang up, but in my experience it is worth it.

2
ProzacElfOP•

Interesting. I hadn't thought of the possibility of Reno in a mill deck, particularly a Rogue one. I've made some fairly significant changes to the deck, the most important of which were swapping the Small-time Buccaneers for Mistresses of Mixtures, running 2x Sap and 1x Shiv instead of the other way around, and putting in 2x Vanish instead of 2x Defias Ringleader.

The deck still seems like it's one turn too slow to get stabilized and to start building the win condition(s). Ironically, it works best against Reno decks currently, since they tend to be pretty slow to develop and you can often mill some very important cards for them. By the time I have my big Reporter building turns I can often force them to play Reno just before I'm about to put them into fatiguee. Then of course I can pile on a bunch of fatigue damage before running big Reporters and/or Arcane Giants that I've Cold Blooded into their face.

1
TacosAreJustice•

I think it definitely adds a threat to mill Rogue. The problem is, you usually want to keep the board clear so they don't have a way to get rid of minion spells in hand.

Anyone running hard removal gets an advantage if you play a minion.

It might work, though... I'm a terrible deck builder.

1
ProzacElfOP•

Yeah, I may be better off just cramming more spells in there. I'm not entirely sure yet. At the end of the day this may end up being just a worse version of Questing Miracle, but it seemed like a fun idea that no one had really come up with yet. Sometimes I'd rather make my own deck than roll out Midrange Shaman #963 or go craft a bunch of cards to make a Pirate Warrior that I may not even enjoy that much.

1
TacosAreJustice•

Enjoy yourself! My gang up patches deck was terrible but fun.

1
Stickyw1cket•

Refreshment Vendor is very important. Mill rogue is a fatigue deck, you want to extend the game as long as possible. Actually milling pieces is secondary to that goal. Vendor has a decent body which allows you to fight for board control and maybe do a little chip damage.

1
Stickyw1cket•

Looks interesting but where is your Brann? He's absolutely essential to kill rogue.

I've played a little bit of mill rogue, but I play the fatigue version. I might give this a go, and also modify my version to including daring reporter. I'll report back (geddit) on my findings.

1
ProzacElfOP•

I do have Brann in there now. I've changed the deck a couple times since I posted originally. FYI, the Reporters don't gain stats on cards that get milled, so it's not as cool as I wanted it to be.

1