r/Twitch•
mentul

Any way to reproduce Shadowplay quality through OBS?

Question

Hi all,

I'm trying to get the quality right for my stream. I can't seem to get x264 working right. OBS would bug out and stop the stream yet report that the stream is running, get terrible performance, etc. OBS does cooperate more using nvidia codec except that it stutters the stream a bit. Using shadowplay, I get none of these issues.

Has anyone successfully replicated Shadowplay quality through OBS?

These two streams are examples of what I'm talking about:

nvenc
shadowplay

I'd appreciate any help! Thanks!

Posted Dec 12, 2016, 12:46 AM UTC

38
jamacanbacnStreamlabs Support•

Nvenc is designed for higher bitrates(which is why it looks so good for local recordings) so when you are running at a lower bitrate it is not going to come out as clean. That is why most people use x264 because it works much more efficiently for lower bitrate users.

I am not sure what the shadowplay app would be doing to make it look better though because it would still be using NVENC. Maybe someone else more familiar might know. Just figured I would explain the NVENC thing though.

1
Mitsumatwitch.tv/mitsuma•

Your explanation is the reason why OPs shadowplay version looks better. It simply streamed with a higher bitrate (~8.7mbit vs 3.5mbit in the OBS example).

1
jamacanbacnStreamlabs Support•

Shadowplay wouldn't be able to stream at a higher bitrate since Twitch has a cap. (Unless the cap is not there for Shadowplay traffic?)

1
Mitsumatwitch.tv/mitsuma•

There is no actual cap, it does not get automatically enforced. Shadowplay is no special traffic. Only if a streamer has more viewers and streams with a very high bitrate an admin will either tell you to change the bitrate or ban you for ToS breaking.

Quite a few people stream slightly above the "limit" to get a little bit more quality.

1
jamacanbacnStreamlabs Support•

Does Shadowplay have some kind of setting? Just think it would be weird for them to have it uncapped when it is known that Twitch typically wants it to be under a certain amount.

1
Mitsumatwitch.tv/mitsuma•

You got better quality in the shadowplay version because it streamed with 8.7mbit. More than double what twitch allows and what you used in the NVENC example.
Shadowplay and NVENC are the same thing, there is no quality difference at the same bitrate.

Shadowplay does not care for for the limit on Twitch. Neither would OBS if you tell it to stream at 8.7mbit. You won't be able to get a decent quality on NVENC with 1080p60. Switch to 720p60 and you can have a still clear and fluid stream at 3.5mbit.

Also your problem with x264 is probably a weak CPU. Overwatch is a nasty CPU hog and x264 is all done on your CPU. Even an i7 can have problems if you don't choose is faster x264 preset for Overwatch streaming.

1
UnlikelyPotatotwitch.tv/unlikelypotato•

As others have mentioned, shadowplay is encoding at over 8Mbps. That's way too freaking high. You're also streaming 1920x1080 @ 60fps. Which many people have problems watching. Use OBS and stream at 1280x720 @ 60fps. You'll halve your CPU usage for OBS and should no longer have issues. People should only do 1080P @ 60 fps if they're insane, and have either an insanely powerful 6+ core i7 rig or a streaming computer.

1
mentulOP•

I believe I downscaled the res in more recent video's if you check the stream. I still had shit performance at 720p. OBS won't stream consistently using x264 (meaning it'll just stop streaming) and nvenc still stutters horribly.

I do run SLI, if that means anything. Has anyone encountered any issues running an SLI setup with OBS? Any settings I would need to configure to optimize?

1