JonquilXanthippe•

Probably not unless you do it right as they start to go for the north south. Because once they tighten up the choke you can't twist your neck like that.

4
drkaczur•

Depends on how strongly you feel about the structural integrity of your spine.

3
Mtranart•

There's the one match with Marcelo Garcia vs Kentaro Nakamura. Nakamura does a similar escape but turns to the other side, but then ends up getting guillotined.

3
Darce_Knight•

Came here to mention that. One of the coolest finishes ever: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bxhsX5Sb-AU#t=2m4s

The funny thing is that I could never tell if Marcelo just sort of let him run into the guillotine or if the guy genuinely got out of the north south choke.

I looked for another instance of Marcelo doing that on his website and was never able to find anything.

Also most north south chokers in my experience are decent guillotiners, so I'd think this escape could run you right into more trouble.

3
Markenheimer15•

One thing that sticks out to me is that in this escape the person applying to N/S doesn't move or anything. Realistically the top player would adjust. I also don't care for the choker's head position. I wonder how available it would be with his head tight on your chest. Also, is it a reliable escape if it puts you into another sub (regardless if Marcelo let him out).

3
RobertSetreeOPCriterion BJJ•

Marcello is hiding his head down and to the outside of the arm in this video: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Lhk4EZl4jjE

Is it not similar?

And do you think that MG wouldn't have an attack no matter where you went? He's a straight up killer. He touches people's necks and they tap. How can you not be impressed with a guy that escapes MG when he's that deep?

1
RobertSetreeOPCriterion BJJ•

Thank you for the link!

2
Mtranart•

That was my thought as well, not clear if he gave up on the choke to give Nakamura enough space for the follow up.

2
Darce_Knight•

If anyone knows, it's probably u/kying418

1
kying418Marcelo Garcia•

Haha thanks- but not really- I know how to teach it and do it...not so much how to defend it well :)

2
RobertSetreeOPCriterion BJJ•

Beautiful!

1
xilce•

I don't know a thing about NS chokes but Marcello talks about keeping their face looking away from you here. Seems like that might make this escape harder.

2
Tacklegrapple•

If you can turn your head 180 degrees, then you should have no problem hitting this escape.

2
brandon_mcBrandon Mccaghren - 10th Planet Decatur Alabama•

This is some really beautiful Jiu Jitsu.

2
crafall•

If it's fully locked in tight under the chin, it's going to be hard. But I hit this all the time before all their weight is down and fully locked in.

1
Darce_Knight•

I do a lot of north south chokes and the only way anyone is able to do anything like this is if they are able to get their hands under my neck/face and push my face up first. If someone is this low and this sprawled out, I think it would be hard to do that without hurting your neck/spine.

1
RobertSetreeOPCriterion BJJ•

What's really awesome to me is this: You shared a video of someone escaping Marcello "F'ing" Garcia with this move, but still can't believe that it works. Tell me that isn't mind bending!

Thanks for that video share, by the way! That really made my day!

3
Darce_Knight•

Damn....that is pretty mind bending. I sort of feel stupid. I guess I always sort of thought Marcelo "let him out" but you make a good point! The guy did get out. He escaped. It worked.

Touche.

2
calvinquisition•

define escaping - looks to me he jumped from a NS choke frying pan into a marcellotine fire.

1