Fouled Mixed Bed Softener

Here is the story of water treatment in my home.

We are a family of 5 living off a 20' deep well. It's an old well but it has never even threatened to run dry.

The issue is the water in it is crap. It is full of iron and organic tannins.

Originally we were renting two Hicksgas units one Cation and one Anion unit to soften the water and remove the tannins.

Through a family friend who is a water treatment expert we were able to get a pair of mixed bed softeners.

This was much more ideal than the separate tank setup as you always had one tank online while the other regenerates.

However lately our cloths have been getting streaky grease like stains. We replaced the the washer, but that didn't help. I knew tannins could cause stains but assumed our softener was taking care of that issue.

I took a sample into Hicksgas and it was obvious there were tannins in the water. He said mixed bed softeners were no good as the anion resin inevitably migrates to the top and gets fouled.

I would ask the family friend who installed it but they have essentially washed their hands of the whole situation.

Is this the case?

I'm basically trying to get to the cheapest solution to my problem as ideally I don't want to have to buy new equipment.

The water sample was still soft so it is specificity an issue with the anion resin that's supposed to take care of the tannins.

I know that chlorination is also effective at removing some tannins and it is possible to clean softener resin. But I'm just not sure on the best possible route.

It's just so hard to find good advice on water treatment as the field is dominated by companies not necessarily looking to help you get clean water but to rent proprietary equipment to you. I'm comfortable with DIY I just don't know where to even start.

Posted Dec 12, 2016, 8:02 PM UTC

33
wallawalla22•

Do not chlorinate your resin. That will destroy it. Resin also only lasts 4-5 years and generally anion resin has a shorter life time than cation. I do not work in residential systems, so these are generalizations.

I have no idea what the cost would be, but full/ partial flow reverse osmosis would certainly mitigate your problem, but you'd send more water to waste this way.

2

Correct. Don't bleach anion resins at all and very sparingly for cation resins and only as a last resort.

1

My understanding is that water is normally softened to remove metals(and calcium!) before removal of tannins to prevent the metals from fouling the anion resin. Also anion tannin removal systems need more frequent backwashing to prevent fouling. Since you're using a mixed bed system I'd say you've lost the benefit of removing the metals first and should concentrate in the backwashing/cleaning aspect to keep your anion resin operating optimally. I've never encountered a mixed bed softener/tannin removal setup so I can't vouch for any definitive solution to this problem. Washing softener resin with bleach can be done sparingly but I would not use bleach in your case with a mixed bed containing anion resin. Stick with acid based cleaners like citric or phosphoric.

It concerns me that your family friend has walked away from this system after recommending it.

edit:

I found an old informative link in my water treatment bookmarks:

http://www.wqpmag.com/tannin-removal

They talk about cleaning with carbonate(soda ash). I've seen that done by a friend on a single resin tank and it worked well but your system is of course different so all I can say is good luck.

1