Ubiquiti AP lite or Mikrotik hap lite?

I'm planning a bit of a home network re-build from the ground up and have almost everything planned out---I'm just down to the choice of APs now.

My plan is to build a server on the (relative) cheap, give it a lot of ram and two gbit nics, and run vms: freenas, pfsense, and some linux (probably ubuntu lts) for torrents, running cloud backups, and playing music from my speakers.

Since I'll be putting pfsense in front anyway, I don't need the AP to do anything other than be an AP---in fact, the less it does the better. Ideally it'll get security updates automatically and after setting it up I'll never have to think about it again. My apartment is also tiny (400sf), so power isn't a concern at all, and I certainly don't need more than one ap. For reference, I currently have this piece of crap running tomato and connected straight to my modem, which works /fine/, no problems that can't be fixed by a quick reboot once or twice a month and it just barely saturates my 50mbit connection. Since I'll be keeping many of my files and backups on the NAS in the future though, I want much faster speeds.

Downsides of the mikrotik I've read about seem to be mostly about how complicated the configuration is, although since it's a mostly for fun project anyway that's almost an advantage.

While everyone raves about the ubiquiti (mostly) it is more expensive, I don't like how they seem to be violating GPL, and I hate the idea of having to install some cloud bullshit to manage it. Thoughts?

Posted Dec 13, 2016, 5:01 PM UTC

47
washu_k•

Just make sure you are comparing the right things. Mikrotik doesn't have a product that directly matches the AC-LITE. The hAP lite and hAP are far lower end WiFi wise then even your current router. The hAP AC lite only has 100 Mbit ports so that wreaks the speeds. The hAP AC is 3 stream so is a match to the AC-PRO but thus more expensive.

 

You don't need any "cloud bullshit" to manage Ubiquiti APs. The cloud key is just one option that you don't have to use. You can run the management software on any PC and you don't need to leave it running unless you want to make configuration changes. Also for simple setups there are phone apps.

3
strikesbac•

Just to add to this v2 of the mobile app on iOS was released today and it's far more feature complete. If you don't need the guest portal then the app is plenty good enough.

2
keevieOP•

Okay, good to know--I'm pretty convinced I think. The management software sounded annoying but if I can just get rid of it after everything is set up that seems fine.

My impression from googling was that in general the mikrotik hardware was superior to. ubiquiti, but I guess their very lowest end stuff is super cheap for a reason.

Thanks!

edit: since you seem to know your stuff, do you think the AC-LITE is clearly the thing I should get? Or is there a different AP entirely I should be looking at?

2
washu_k•

For most devices the AC-LITE is a good choice. It has 2 stream AC and most client devices are 1 or 2 stream. The AC-PRO and the hAP AC are 3 stream, but only Apple laptops (not iDevices) and high end PC laptops normally come with 3 stream. In most cases the extra stream is not used.

1
jumpshipd3fiant•

Not to poke and prod.. but FreeNAS and PFSense virtualized? I'm curious..

2
keevieOP•

Yeah, it's going to be a bit of a project :)

From my reading it seems like freenas is fine virtualized as long as you use a supported HBA (I'm going to use one of these https://www.amazon.com/IBM-Serveraid-M1015-Controller-46M0831/dp/B0034DMSO6) and have pci passthrough.

PFsense is definitely also going to be work to set up, but lots of people seem to have done it so I'm excited for the challenge.

1
jumpshipd3fiant•

I was considering setting up a home server running something like vSphere to run both FreeNAS and pfSense as well, hence my questioning. Any chance you have any links you could PM me for the virtual set of pfSense that you'd recommend me reading?

1