[SPOILERS] Let's talk about "La La Land"!
I just got out of a screening of "La La Land" and I gotta say, I don't think I've ever been this confused about how a movie made me feel. I wanted to throw together a bunch of my thoughts to try to understand them, so here they are.
In the opening scene, I realized that I always have a hard time digesting movies that begin with a musical number. Before I get a chance to try to understand who are these people, why they're feeling this way, or why I should care, I get put off by what is an inherently jarring scene - the cinematic equivalent of seeing a bright computer/cell phone screen when my eyes are adjusted to the dark. I understand that the opening highway traffic song isn't inherently unpleasant. I understand that the goal was to establish that there will be singing and dancing and vibrant color and music in this movie, but I don't think it did it very gracefully. This type of thing is common in stage musicals, but in my opinion it doesn't translate well at all to movies. Without a recognizable main character involved (ie "Heaven On Their Minds" from Jesus Christ Superstar), I really just don't see a reason to care for expository songs.
Anyway, on to the rest of the movie. Objectively speaking, Emma Stone and Ryan Gosling were both obscenely charming. The piano songs were catchy and emotionally charged. There were quite a few lovely scenes scattered throughout the movie, my favorite being the observatory scene where Seb and Mia share their first kiss. Damien Chazelle trusts the audience enough to make statements without explicitly spelling them out, such as the scene where Seb lies about where he parked. Chazelle also clearly cares for his characters, and you can feel his ambition oozing through every scene. For these reasons, I loved "La La Land".
However, the movie lacked a sense of purpose or greater direction, which I hated. We got many great things in this movie, but unfortunately a handful of great ingredients doesn't necessarily make for a great recipe. I came away thinking, "They must have had a lot of trouble deciding on three different endings to this movie, seeing as how they ended up just throwing them all in there."
The first logical ending was when Mia bombs her performance and goes home. There could have been some cathartic ending where she and Sebastian stay together through the difficulties that inherently come along with ambition. The second logical ending could have been when Mia nailed her (deus ex machina) audition and left Seb for Paris - this would have been a lovely bittersweet ending, if you ask me. But no, she comes 5 years later, after hitting it big as a movie star. She's married to some random guy and she has a kid now. She stumbles upon Seb's place by chance, and they have a touching final reminiscence of their relationship.
So what was the movie trying to do with all these endings? I felt like I kept getting slapped with a "but wait, there's more!" every time I expected it to wind down with a little denouement, and for what? I didn't sense an overarching theme here, which I think is entirely necessary for this type of romance movie. For instance, if I were to ask you what the point of "500 Days of Summer" was - assuming you've seen it - I don't think you'd have much trouble throwing together some kind of hypothesis about the movie's statement on Tom's and/or Summer's world view. That just wasn't there in "La La Land", for me.
Artistically speaking, I thought "La La Land" was more of a collage of snippets of great paintings, rather than a great painting itself. What did you guys think of it?
Posted Dec 16, 2016, 4:33 AM UTC · edited
I just for out of a screening and I thought it was incredible. I was obscenely hyped for this movie which usually leads to me being disappointed, but this was one of the times where it met the hype for me. The production design, directing, musical numbers, score, everything just worked for me. It's just so joyous and charming.
I have no idea what you are talking about with the multiple endings. I don't think either of the two places you mentioned would make a logical ending at all. I thought the ending they did was perfect. It's an emotional gut punch. The final musical number is the perfect encapsulation of that tinge in your heart feeling of what could have been. Plus it works as an homage to classic musicals that have long wordless ballets that exist outside of the film.
As far as themes go, this is a film about passionate people following their dreams even if it has negative effects. It's similar to Whiplash in that way. They have to end the relationship in order for them to both get what they want. In that last conversation they have, they both know Mia has to take the chance alone or else she won't make it. If he goes with her then Sebastian won't ever open his club. Even in the final dream sequence, he doesn't own Seb's. That's what makes the ending bittersweet to me because even though they didn't end up together, they both achieved their dreams.
I did have a few minor issues. I thought in the Fall act they could have had at least one more song. It kind of feels like it starts running out of steam at that point. The other issue was the whole John Legend subplot. Something about it didn't really work for me. Not sure what exactly, but it felt like it was lacking some polish.
Anyways, I'm still processing this movie, but those are some of my thoughts. I can't wait to see it again.
Thanks for the input! Despite the poo I'm flinging at it, I did enjoy this movie and I'd like to see it again as well.
Regarding the endings thing: I just felt like those were paths that the movie could potentially have taken to end up with a cohesive point. Naturally, if this particular movie just ended at those places without additional scenes then it would have felt abrupt. I was just trying to understand where we were going with it all, which I usually prefer to know prior to the final act of the movie.
My ending takeaway was "if you chase your dreams and never give up, you'll succeed, but it will require sacrifices," or something like that, which feels disingenuous given the subject matter.
Now, I recognize that not every movie needs to have a greater lesson. However, I didn't think the characters were interesting enough to warrant this being about them alone. All we knew about them was that they both loved each other and jazz/acting. The argument scene and the audition room climax felt contrived for this same reason; the argument didn't line up with the personalities that were demonstrated throughout the movie, and the audition scene was counting on us having some kind of interest in Mia's aunt's character. Neither of these scenes felt earned to me since the characters were so shallow.
I can't really disagree that Mia and Seb are kind of one note. You are right that we don't really get much nuance to their characters besides their creative passions and their love for each other. I also kind of agree that the big argument that happens isn't quite earned by their characters. That scene felt like something was not quite lining up. The argument boils down to basically just a misunderstanding. Seb's turn when he joins John Legend's band isn't really fleshed out that well so the way he acts during the argument feels out of place.
That being said, none of those narrative missteps took away from the film for me. The movie's earnestness in what it's trying to do and it's execution of emotional expression made these into minor issues.
[deleted]