r/flicks•
RTeezy

[SPOILERS] Let's talk about "La La Land"!

I just got out of a screening of "La La Land" and I gotta say, I don't think I've ever been this confused about how a movie made me feel. I wanted to throw together a bunch of my thoughts to try to understand them, so here they are.

In the opening scene, I realized that I always have a hard time digesting movies that begin with a musical number. Before I get a chance to try to understand who are these people, why they're feeling this way, or why I should care, I get put off by what is an inherently jarring scene - the cinematic equivalent of seeing a bright computer/cell phone screen when my eyes are adjusted to the dark. I understand that the opening highway traffic song isn't inherently unpleasant. I understand that the goal was to establish that there will be singing and dancing and vibrant color and music in this movie, but I don't think it did it very gracefully. This type of thing is common in stage musicals, but in my opinion it doesn't translate well at all to movies. Without a recognizable main character involved (ie "Heaven On Their Minds" from Jesus Christ Superstar), I really just don't see a reason to care for expository songs.

Anyway, on to the rest of the movie. Objectively speaking, Emma Stone and Ryan Gosling were both obscenely charming. The piano songs were catchy and emotionally charged. There were quite a few lovely scenes scattered throughout the movie, my favorite being the observatory scene where Seb and Mia share their first kiss. Damien Chazelle trusts the audience enough to make statements without explicitly spelling them out, such as the scene where Seb lies about where he parked. Chazelle also clearly cares for his characters, and you can feel his ambition oozing through every scene. For these reasons, I loved "La La Land".

However, the movie lacked a sense of purpose or greater direction, which I hated. We got many great things in this movie, but unfortunately a handful of great ingredients doesn't necessarily make for a great recipe. I came away thinking, "They must have had a lot of trouble deciding on three different endings to this movie, seeing as how they ended up just throwing them all in there."

The first logical ending was when Mia bombs her performance and goes home. There could have been some cathartic ending where she and Sebastian stay together through the difficulties that inherently come along with ambition. The second logical ending could have been when Mia nailed her (deus ex machina) audition and left Seb for Paris - this would have been a lovely bittersweet ending, if you ask me. But no, she comes 5 years later, after hitting it big as a movie star. She's married to some random guy and she has a kid now. She stumbles upon Seb's place by chance, and they have a touching final reminiscence of their relationship.

So what was the movie trying to do with all these endings? I felt like I kept getting slapped with a "but wait, there's more!" every time I expected it to wind down with a little denouement, and for what? I didn't sense an overarching theme here, which I think is entirely necessary for this type of romance movie. For instance, if I were to ask you what the point of "500 Days of Summer" was - assuming you've seen it - I don't think you'd have much trouble throwing together some kind of hypothesis about the movie's statement on Tom's and/or Summer's world view. That just wasn't there in "La La Land", for me.

Artistically speaking, I thought "La La Land" was more of a collage of snippets of great paintings, rather than a great painting itself. What did you guys think of it?

Posted Dec 16, 2016, 4:33 AM UTC · edited

2616
tonequality•

I just for out of a screening and I thought it was incredible. I was obscenely hyped for this movie which usually leads to me being disappointed, but this was one of the times where it met the hype for me. The production design, directing, musical numbers, score, everything just worked for me. It's just so joyous and charming.

I have no idea what you are talking about with the multiple endings. I don't think either of the two places you mentioned would make a logical ending at all. I thought the ending they did was perfect. It's an emotional gut punch. The final musical number is the perfect encapsulation of that tinge in your heart feeling of what could have been. Plus it works as an homage to classic musicals that have long wordless ballets that exist outside of the film.

As far as themes go, this is a film about passionate people following their dreams even if it has negative effects. It's similar to Whiplash in that way. They have to end the relationship in order for them to both get what they want. In that last conversation they have, they both know Mia has to take the chance alone or else she won't make it. If he goes with her then Sebastian won't ever open his club. Even in the final dream sequence, he doesn't own Seb's. That's what makes the ending bittersweet to me because even though they didn't end up together, they both achieved their dreams.

I did have a few minor issues. I thought in the Fall act they could have had at least one more song. It kind of feels like it starts running out of steam at that point. The other issue was the whole John Legend subplot. Something about it didn't really work for me. Not sure what exactly, but it felt like it was lacking some polish.

Anyways, I'm still processing this movie, but those are some of my thoughts. I can't wait to see it again.

25
RTeezyOP•

Thanks for the input! Despite the poo I'm flinging at it, I did enjoy this movie and I'd like to see it again as well.

Regarding the endings thing: I just felt like those were paths that the movie could potentially have taken to end up with a cohesive point. Naturally, if this particular movie just ended at those places without additional scenes then it would have felt abrupt. I was just trying to understand where we were going with it all, which I usually prefer to know prior to the final act of the movie.

My ending takeaway was "if you chase your dreams and never give up, you'll succeed, but it will require sacrifices," or something like that, which feels disingenuous given the subject matter.

Now, I recognize that not every movie needs to have a greater lesson. However, I didn't think the characters were interesting enough to warrant this being about them alone. All we knew about them was that they both loved each other and jazz/acting. The argument scene and the audition room climax felt contrived for this same reason; the argument didn't line up with the personalities that were demonstrated throughout the movie, and the audition scene was counting on us having some kind of interest in Mia's aunt's character. Neither of these scenes felt earned to me since the characters were so shallow.

4
tonequality•

I can't really disagree that Mia and Seb are kind of one note. You are right that we don't really get much nuance to their characters besides their creative passions and their love for each other. I also kind of agree that the big argument that happens isn't quite earned by their characters. That scene felt like something was not quite lining up. The argument boils down to basically just a misunderstanding. Seb's turn when he joins John Legend's band isn't really fleshed out that well so the way he acts during the argument feels out of place.

That being said, none of those narrative missteps took away from the film for me. The movie's earnestness in what it's trying to do and it's execution of emotional expression made these into minor issues.

6
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
con42scientist•

However, the movie lacked a sense of purpose or greater direction, which I hated.

I'm going to disagree with you here. It was a journey through the relationship between Seb and Mia while they also were struggling to follow their own artistic paths. They both had clear end goals (Seb's Jazz Club and Mia's big-break as an actress) while struggling to maintain their relationship and also play the balancing act of working to make a living in something you don't hate. Both character's had an intense sense of purpose and I never felt the film was aimless, I think the ending only served to emphasize this.

Also Mia's "big break" audition was not a Deus Ex Machina. It's entirely plausible that a casting director was at a one-woman show in LA. It would have been more Deus Ex Machina if they were like "Yeah a lady saw you in the coffee shop and wants to put you in the next Marvel movie".

Maybe it's because I could relate to the film so much but at the end the overarching theme felt incredibly clear to me. It was a human, realistic ending. They both ended up finding success in their respective arts but at the end of the day sometimes things don't work out, life isn't a musical and the people that maybe should end up together don't. It was a poignant, heartbreaking ending that everyone can relate to which I feel like was the key point here. The whole film was also a meta-comment on musicals and nostalgia and rose-tinted glasses, it was Chazelle's way of saying "Yes these things were great, but this isn't Singing in the Rain. The guy doesn't get the girl, we don't live in that era anymore and nostalgia can be dangerous despite how beautiful and exciting it is." At least that was my takeaway from it.

I could be biased because I work in the film industry and have had relationships crumble because of it so I was kind of the exact target audience, but those are my feelings on it. I adored the film to pieces.

14
true97•

Channing Tatum or Ryan Gosling? Lol

13
RTeezyOP•

Uhhhhhhh fixed. Thanks for pointing that out.

About 10 minutes into the movie I thought "wait a second.... That's not Bradley Cooper at all!!" Looks like I still didn't get his name right after all.

3
willianswalkerFreaks directed by Tod Browning•

I ultimately liked it but had a lot of problems with it as well. First, I could have used more songs, I felt like there were only three or four songs with singing in them, hardly enough to make a record. I thought the Mia character was a very thankless role for Emma Stone. She's good, and did a good job, even singing. But the role is so flat and such a stupid cliched version of struggling hollywood actress. The way she falls for Ryan Gosling is just blah, and so movie ish. I thought maybe the movie was trying comment on Hollywood cliche but then it never really did. Just got cornier and cornier. You say Chazelle clearly cares for his characters but I don't think he really does. At least not Mia, she was all just a catalyst for Gosling's character. Her own story was almost irrelevant and it really seemed like an afterthought to me. Overall I thought it was just fine but it's great parts were great. I'd watch it again but not over and over again.

9
murkler42•

I definitely agree with you. First off, I think the movie was wayyyy overhyped. Which only set me up for disappointment. Plus I think that Whiplash is one of the best movies of the last 5 years or so. High bar to have going in.

I also wasn't in love with the opening song, however, I did think the first 15-20 minutes of the movie were still strong. They set up a universe, asked me to enter it, and though I was reluctant it had some great songs and throwbacks to old school musicals.

But that's where it stopped. The middle act just did absolutely nothing for me. The movie no longer wanted to be a musical. It wanted to be a movie about Hollywood with music in it. The numbers become inconsistent, they didn't decide if they wanted to go big or to just have characters singing songs on their own. It really bugged me.

The ending, I will say, is absolutely incredible IMO though. I don't necessarily agree with you about the multiple endings issue but I could see where you might find that. I think it was a beautifully done ending and was more of what I wanted from the rest of the movie. If you're going to make a movie fantastical and transportive, don't just sprinkle it in. Throw that shit all over it! It's like a David Lynch movie. He's not going to make only little bits of it surreal. It's going to make a surreal movie front to back.

My two biggest issues: one is that the story was pretty boring and insanely predictable. And as a result their relationship just felt forced to me. Although both of their performances were great I just didn't ever care for their love story. Emma Stone's character I felt for her pain of trying to succeed but at no point did I believe their relationship had a point.

Two is that although Emma Stone and Ryan Gosling are great actors, the problem with musicals nowadays as compared to the Studio System is that you don't have actors/performers like Fred Astaire, Bing Crosby, Ginger Rogers, etc on the screen. The reason musicals were so big back then is because you had a rotating cast of actors/performers who trained their entire lives to perform and most of the enjoyability was just WATCHING them perform these amazing song and dance numbers. When Emma Stone and Ryan Gosling do their little dance at sunset by the park bench...there was NOTHING there. Unfortunately, the Hollywood musical is just a relic long forgotten by studio execs.

My friend put it very well I think. She said, back in the day if you went up to a Producer and said 'I have a great idea for a movie! It's a musical!!' The producer would then say 'Ok, great... so what's the story?'

Hollywood makes musicals nowadays as gimmicks because they aren't as popular as they used to be. They become gimmicks more than movies. I will say that La La Land was better than something like Into the Woods, but even so it was not at all what I wanted it to be. And I wanted to like it!

7
RTeezyOP•

I hadn't really thought about it before, but if I were solely looking at this movie as a musical, I'd say it was a pretty bad one. There weren't any memorable songs to take away from it, if you ask me (aside from the recurring piano themes) - none of the singing had any kind of emotional impact. Unfortunately, it seems like you have to make some concessions when it comes to casting for movies like this. I feel like their are two options:

  1. Cast some great actors, and then make the movie conform to their limited musical talents. I feel like that's what happened in "La La Land"
  2. Cast fantastic performers who leave something to be desired when it comes to being passable actors. These guys and girls really shine in full-on musicals, where I really have to suspend disbelief anyway since they're frolicking around and singing. Being a "believable" actor doesn't really matter in these scenarios.

People who are talented as actors AND performers really stand out. Personally, I think Samantha Barks did a pretty good job of this in Les Mis, but I confess that my opinion be skewed due to thinking she's exceptionally pretty. :)

1

The ending was kind of a mess, to flash forward 5 years like that, not giving us any hints if they tried to stay in touch at all during that time. Did Mia know he had a club that's why she told her husband to pull off at that exit? I was curious if Sebastian has a pic hanging of him and Mia somewhere in his club since she helped inspire him (The clubs name) to get to where he is. Felt like the ending was rushed.

3
arc52•

I loved it but I can totally see where it wouldn't work for some people. I think it has a lot on its mind even though it doesn't appear to be anything more than homage and spectacle for the first half. It wasn't until Mia and Sebastian sang their duet of "City of Stars" that the film really clicked for me.

It's about two people, and a city as a whole, finding inspiration and perseverance in each other. Someone or something to keep them going in the face of larger than life dreams and figures. In a city full of actual movie stars, each of us are a star and inspiration for the people we love. It's really sentimental and romantic but it worked for me.

3
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
GinsbergsPeacock•

https://letterboxd.com/courtjester/film/la-la-land/

I don't think any of those endings are as satisfying as the final cut. There is plenty in the film to setup the ending, where the resolution is in accepting that sometimes people's goals are irreconcilable, and that sometimes the best impact someone has on your life is recognizing that and letting you go. This doesn't obviate the good experiences you shared; it's just an expression of love that is more pragmatic and mature than holding a partner hostage to a fantasy.

I didn't care much for the music. The dancing and parkour shit in the first number felt cheaply choreographed and performed. Neither Stone nor Gosling are strong singers. I think cinematography was what made the better song and dance scenes great. I do agree with the collage analogy; the film does rely a lot on referentialism and feels somewhat soulless beyond that until the ending injects a point to it all.

I enjoyed it, though. Despite being underwhelmed by the music and being generally indifferent to Stone and Gosling. Definitely one of the better big budget romances to come out of recent decades.

EDIT: UGH. It's been barely 24 hours and the thing is already growing on me. I don't like that it equates Hollywood with dreams, but I can't deny that it does it so fucking well. The feels are real, man.

1
TheOneWhoKnocks97•

I agree with people's defense of the ending here, so I won't reiterate it besides to say at a Q&A with Chazelle, he said the film was about how following your dreams leads to other sacrifices, and I think the film does a great job of depicting that. I thought the film was really great, but it definitely had some flaws. I would say that right around when John Legend shows up the movie starts to lose me. As much as the ending feels real and refreshing to me, the path leading up to it felt too familiar, and was very predicable to me. Ultimately I still enjoyed those parts, but much less so, just because I could see where the film was going, not to mention the musical numbers were less frequent and less spectacular for a stretch there, and they really helped carry the film in the beginning.

1
hm03surf•

Could you link to that interview? I've been searching for an interview where he answers something about the ending.

1
TheOneWhoKnocks97•

Sorry for replying so late. I'd love to link to the Q&A, but it wasn't recorded, I just got lucky enough to see the film with him there doing a live interview afterwards. If it helps at all, I believe he said he deliberately made the ending emotionally complex, never veering too far in 1 specific direction in terms of how the audience is supposed to feel. He didn't say any more about the ending than that. The fact that success = sacrifice was apparent enough, but I think whether or not he was trying to say that their success was worth more than their relationship is up to interpretation from the audience.

1
hm03surf•

Ugh that's what I hate! I kind of want him to tell me how to feel.

2
TheOneWhoKnocks97•

Personally I've always been a fan of there being a little bit of wiggle room for personal interpretation in storytelling, but I understand the frustration.

1
True_Italiano•

i know this is a month late, but I figure what the hell? might as well share my two cents.

When you say the movie was a collage of great paintings, I couldn't agree with you more. However where you see that as a negative, I see that as a HUGE positive because to me those pieces tell the truest story possible.

There is very little fluff in this move. Even the dance numbers generally server narrative purpose. The way the movie is broken into seasons makes obvious the phases of their relationship. It showed that the day to day happenings of their lives were meaningless. Their relationship was not built by these smaller moments, but instead how they felt about each other and in turn their dreams.

So when I see the pieces of 2 lives presented in this way, I can't help but reflect on the moments in my life the last year that truly mattered. A handful come to mind that I think changed me. But over time these small moments define who Mia & Seb are, just as they do all of us.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-3†

Unlike your comment, which has no style or substance ;)

3