I just found something that miiiight just explain all these extremism rampant lately..
np.reddit.com/r/askreddit/comments/5hiv8i/_/d...Posted Dec 17, 2016, 2:38 AM UTC
Posted Dec 17, 2016, 2:38 AM UTC
The problem is that this means that when the common people become less racist a social justice warrior needs to become even more extreme in order to continue being seen as more anti-racist than regular people.
Well said, I feel like religion, culture, feminism and SJW-ing should be treated just like technology in a civilization. Stone was great and all, you can make a lot of tools that make your life easier, but once bronze/other metal is discovered, it's time to move on from the stone and embrace the new technology. If you are being stubborn and refuse to change from stone tools then your civilization will not make a progress.
It will be alright if those people keep using stones.
Problem is they start forcing other people to use stones like them.
Use the stone or you will be stoned
nuff said
Islamic conservatism or extremism is unique in that it shares many similar traits with SJWs in the West
it's like if SJWs and the alt-right had a baby, a horrible horrible super PC while at the same time super bigoted baby.
i think american evangelical christians form the 80s and 90s are a more fitting parallel though
Nah Conservatism is inherently dogmatic and moralistic, If anything its people here on Reddit that are the equivalent of western Tumblrites, Islamic extremism is more similar to fascism, which I found great tbh
I kinda see a common thread among all extremists, be it religious, feminists, political, sports, etc.. Why do they grab something so trivial, and make it something so big? Because that's the lowest hanging fruit (in their circumstances), to feel better about themselves.
I'm stupid and poor.. but at least I'm religious! I'm fat and nobody wants me... but at least I fight for women's right to not be catcalled! I'm better than all of them!!
I have a lot of thoughts about the recent events, but I'm not gonna write them all down here. I'm just gonna write the urgent ones I have in my mind.
IMO explaining the rise of extremism in Indonesia is really complicated. It's a mix of Islam vs. Christianity, anti-Chinese sentiment, and also the poor against the rich. Not gonna get into the political aspect here.
In addition, I start to see the term Islamophobia being used to refer to cases in Indonesia when people think Islam is under attack or Muslim people are being discriminated. I think Islamophobia is a real thing in Western societies (i.e. North America and Europe) where Christianity is the majority and the dominant people (white) get their knowledge about Muslim people from the news. So there is the power imbalance in big dominant countries in which Christianity gets the upper hand. And then the local people see that and they immediately translate it to explain what they see around them. They get a sense of fear that Islam is under attack from the news, and then they try to do what they can in daily life. It's important to note that when people discuss Islamophobia in the West (as I have seen so far), the discussion is rooted in academic theories on power imbalance and power structure. However, those theories are still not common in Indonesia, so people can yell Islamophobia and in the same sentence say, "the minority should follow the majority," which will not fly well in the West.
So IMO it is important to explain power play and structure, and how they are defined in Indonesia, in order to fight extremism. Do note that I'm coming from a very specific academic background though, and also this is a quick thought that's not perfect in any way.
It's actually not that complicated to understand the root of some, if not most, of the causes, if seen from certain perspectives. And politic is one of the biggest cause of all, it's been one of the biggest tool ever wielded against our own people.
To understand a lot of the problems that took roots in Indonesia, first we need to accept that almost all of it came from Indonesians' own inability to see their weaknesses & faults, since they're stemmed from sentiments and racism.
(Cina, Jawa, Batak, Padang, Sunda, Ambon, etc. are words majority of people in Indonesia associated with slurs, in any level).
Without it, there's not much actual significant progress we can gain in short term without casualities over the line, as shown in the last couple of decades.
Some people have realized this a long time ago, hence the idealism of Pancasila.
That's a good point. I should've said "might help explain" instead of implying this is the one and only explanation!
There's fear, yeah (and that scary tendency to assume "attacks" on people who happen to be Muslim are "attack on Islam" and therefore they should raise arms.. wtf). But there's also insecurity and the drive to be "good" at something, which make people more, well if not extreme than at least fundamental.
Nah I wasn't saying you're wrong, just putting my opinion out there after reading the comment. I'm sure there are people like you described too.
So.. hipster? For the sake of challenging the status quo? Really?
For the sake of feeling superior, is the way I interpreted it.
This explains Indonesia reddit more than anything tbh
might be unrelated but in my opinion r/indonesia is probably much more brogressive than it is progressive though, they support gay rights although being subtlely transphobic then suddenly started supporting trans rights when muslims and natives oppose them, r/indonesia also supported the death penalty on Bali 9, r/indonesia also belives in ethnoreligious divisions and that civil war between muslims and non muslims is imminent and that muslims are actively trying to hunt them down but hate it when muslims believe in that, r/indonesia supports UU ITE when it is being applied to Buni Yani(tbh he did try to invoke violence but both him and Ahok are entitled to their free speech imo) but are against it when it is being applied to Ahok.
Yes some Muslims are not the best people in the world and yes they're behaviour is related to their religion but that does not instantly makes all muslims bad people for god sakes. Also if you want to support progressive values at least be sincere about it, don't do it because reddit and the west does so.
Also i don't know how this is an unpopular opinion, but Islam, Democracy, and Secularism has worked here. 70 years and demands of Sharia law never came to fruitition, things might look it's going worse here but don't give up yet even Amercia had times of regressiveness several years back. Don't forget that we had homosexual relationships legal(bare in mind,legal not legalize) long before some western countries.
Also i don't know how this is an unpopular opinion, but Islam, Democracy, and Secularism has worked here.
Worked for whom?
Don't forget that we had homosexual relationships legal(bare in mind,legal not legalize)
That doesn't make any sense
well you cant get arrested just for having a relationship with the same gender here.
I'm questioning his arguments as his logic is shaky; there's no such thing as "legal not legalize", it's either legal or illegal.
Homosexual relationships were always legal here, so it technically was never legalized
It's not illegal since there's no law ruling that, which means being gay doesn't break any law, hence gays are not criminals. Homosexual being legal means it's legalized, the state rules the facets of that area, and people can be charged if they broke the legalities.
If this kind of logic treatment doesn't seem important for your argument (while it's something that you came up with as a proof to strengthen it) regarding much bigger topics, then it's not worth another effort to continue the discourse. It's a glaring hole in your logic, one poke and the whole collapse. And I'm a big fan of discourse.
I'll leave it to you as an exercise why this seems like a biggie in the context of Islam democracy & secularism.
I think you're just expecting people to have extremely black or white stances on everything.
I don't like dangdut, but I sure as hell think everyone should be able to listen to (or play) any music they want. But, again, I still might make fun of dangdut, or involve it in a joke in a condescending manner. I'm still for "dangdut rights."
Likewise with the phenomenon you're seeing. You might see people who aren't comfortable with trans people defending trans rights. IMHO that's what "toleransi" looks like in real life, it's where concept meets reality.
Whether or not that counts as "true progressive" might depend on where the True Scotsman draws the line (wink wink), but that sure doesn't look "brogressive" to me.
you're just expecting people to have extremely black or white stances on everything.
some r/Indonesia user sure did, including the one that against recent fundamentalist
Islam, Democracy, and Secularism has worked here. 70 years and demands of Sharia law never came to fruitition
Considering Soeharto did quite a lot of controlling on religious activities, I would be more surprised if Sharia law was implemented.
things might look it's going worse here but don't give up yet even Amercia had times of regressiveness several years back
we don't even need to take a look at the past, just look at US this year, and some Europeans countries
I am scared of you guys
That's honestly a really good read. Thanks mate.
I'm sorry, but can someone ELI5 for me?
I found it's like the rich one who want to be look rich, so "the defender" who want to be look defending their believe more.
The golden pen is a metaphor for "something that makes me feel superior to other people" (instead of something that's useful by itself). So when the golden pen becomes common, and they can no longer feel superior to other people using the same thing, they'll move on to another, more extreme (maybe extremely expensive, or extremely rare) thing.
Likewise with value systems. Most people are getting more moral these days, so in order to feel superior, those SJWs must be even more moral, to the point of being extreme.
Most people are getting more moral these days
I think people getting more extreme instead of morally conscious.
this is just how the system works, you input terrible things, and terrible things come out.
So what is your point? Is it A) Are you saying that recent increase in extremism was because people just wanna be different by being radical? Or B) All these extremism is just SJW overreacting by spreading false fear about extremism?
A. I don't know how anyone can think extremism is "false fear" anymore.
But it's not just about being different, it's about feeling superior.
well from what i see most people who's inside the circle of extremism/radicalism don't realize that what they are doing is extreme/radical. most of them just blindly follow the mainstream opinion in their circle. i think the problem is more about lack of critical thinking. And it is more about inferiority complex rather than desire to be superior.
The two I think are two sides of the same coin, but good point there :)
If you hate donald trump and capitalism, i label you as SJW, period.
You mean people of r/indonesia people are not "The last indonesian with common sense", "Intelectuals", or "The few smart person in Indonesia"?
Damn you xenophobic bigot!