miscsubsOPwhy nations meme•

RI:

To summarize the article, Paul Ryan and his mini-mes introduced a bill to fine House members who engage in live-streaming or who disrupt the session on the House floor. The fine is $500 for a first offense, and $2500 for consequent offenses. This was a reaction to the "sit-in" by some Democrats to protest not being able to bring a gun bill to the House floor after the Orlando shooting.

Will this fine work?

Gneezy (no relation to Yeezy) and Rustichini tested the deterrence hypothesis in a widely cited paper. They found that when an Israeli day-care center introduced fines for the parents who are late to pick up their kids, the late pick up rate in fact increased. They explain this by saying that while the previous behavior was governed by social norms, the new behavior is governed by market norms, aka putting a price on being late.

So just introducing fines for this behavior might cause Democrats to price the sit-ins and disruptions and do it more often. In fact, I can see the Democrats carrying their fines as a badge of honor -- the more you've paid in fines, the more you "worked for the people."

In their conclusions, Gneezy et al. say that a large-enough fee could possibly make the market forces more powerful than the existing social norms. Is that so with these fines?

While $500 is a lot for a commoner like most of us, the average net worth of House members was about $8M in 2011, increasing almost every year. I doubt a $500 or a $2500 fine would hurt them.

To add insult to the injury, the original study also found that once the penalty is introduced, removing it did not bring the social contract back in action. It seems once you take the social contract out of a relationship, it is very difficult to bring it back.

So if and when Ryan's little plan doesn't work, his only option will be to increase the fines considerably for unwanted behavior on the House floor.

Disclaimers:

I am not a trained economist, I just play one at home. I also understand that Ryan's bill is not really an (macro)economic bill but I think it fits neatly with what a lot of economists study, which can be summarized as "pretty much everything."

88
themcattackerAn original Libertarian•

with what a lot of economists study, which can be summarized as "pretty much everything".

Damn economic imperialism.

71
throwawaypopartagainShilling for big social democracy•

"I know how to solve philosophy: we'll create a prediction market for solutions to the externalism vs internalism debate"

59
Kai_DaigojiDanke Bernanke•

Jesus Christ that hurt.

25
throwawaypopartagainShilling for big social democracy•

"The aesthetic future of great literary fiction is easily determined with a brief eye towards revealed preferences, just see Amazon books for the perfect example"

19
AyeGill•

"The value of pi is set fairly by the free market"

10
OediumEichmann was a wonk•

the prediction conditions are just whether or not Robin Hason can beat Bernard Williams in a knife fight

2
JufftYellen is not a Felon•

Hmm. I don't know if that is a fair criticism of his plan. The difference between the Ryan's plan and the daycare is that leaving your child at a daycare for too long puts an externality on the daycare staff whereas to a democrat making the republicans lives worse is almost certainly the point. You are probably right to say that the fee will do little to stop the dems but it isn't because it puts a cost a phenomenon that previously had immense social costs to it. The social/political externality was the point to begin with.

27
besttrousers•

externality

You're thinking too much like an economist.

It's not about whether there's an externality; it's what domain the interaction is in. Is this in the "Wealth of Nations" realm, in which case you will respond to incentives, or the "Moral Sentiments" realm, where you don't want to violate social norms?

Disrupting house activities is currently costly because you are violating a social norm, and people don't like violating a social norm. But by assigning a fine, Ryan is taking the activity out of norm word, and into cost-benefit analysis world. People who may have been dissuaded by the norm violation will not be dissuaded by the price.

It's important to think of this in the context of a dual-process model, where the effective of a disincentive isn't just changing the cost of the behavior, but changing the schema by which we evaluate which realm we are in.

45
JufftYellen is not a Felon•

My response is definitely caked in the assumption that politicians participating in the sit ins are doing so because of some consequential end. It certainly could be true that it encourages more of this behavior because it changes the schema but my priors tell me that we are already in the "Wealth of nations" realm.

On a separate note I agree with the conclusion that this won't change much I just see little reason to believe it is because of behavioral factors. I'll stress again that my belief is entirely based on randomly assuming things however.

10
KarlPolanyi•

Allow me to illustrate to you why you're wrong on this one and they will welcome the fines:

To: 2 Million MoveOn.org Members
From: Congressman Joe Bluestate
Subject: Paul Ryan Fined Us $1,200 PER DAY for Speaking the Truth!

Republicans think our Democracy is for sale. They think that legislators should have to pay for freedom of speech on the House floor. This is an outrage that only serves the billionaire class and wealthy and prevents everyday Americans from having their voices heard.

Will you help us keep up the fight? Will you help us cover the cost of these outrageous, undemocratic, and unconstitutional fines?

Donate NOW to tell Speaker Ryan and the Republican House Leadership that Democracy Can't be Bought!

Click an amount to quick donate!

  • $50
  • $100
  • $250
  • $500
  • $1,000
3
funnyfiggy•

I think there's pretty good reason to think this wouldn't transgress into social domain. To my knowledge, the exact reasons and specifications are unclear for fostering an environment where pigouvian taxes are ineffective.

My guess would be that the reason representatives do not regularly take over the floor has less to do with social norms and more to do with media and constituent scrutiny. Even if it social norm, it's certainly plausible that the daycare fine is ineffective because people believe they are adequately compensating the daycare for the additional time. Obviously there are no stipulations that the fine would compensate anyone, so that psychological trigger may remain dormant in this case.

My only knowledge of behavioral economics comes from the various popular books around, including The Why Axis, but from what little I know this R1 seems to be overly confident.

3
gorbachev•

Aren't these all the wrong questions anyway? Contrasting them with questions like "would (politically relevant portions of) the electorate look more dimly on congressional sit-ins were they labeled a finable crime" or "will championing a symbolic get tough on dems bill improve Paul Ryan's standing with his voters or the Freedom Caucus"?

Also, re market vs other norm sets, is it clear that a token fine pushes people into market norm territory? For example, can a $1 fine be levied as a symbolic gesture to codify social norms, so to speak? I would assume the answer is yes.

3
besttrousers•

Aren't these all the wrong questions anyway? Contrasting them with questions like "would (politically relevant portions of) the electorate look more dimly on congressional sit-ins were they labeled a finable crime" or "will championing a symbolic get tough on dems bill improve Paul Ryan's standing with his voters or the Freedom Caucus"?

That's definitely the right question to be asking! If a large population of people appears to be making an error, your default assumption should be that you don't understand the function they are optimizing. You'll be right 9 out of 10 times.

It's harder to say at the individual level.

6
edprescott•

hisssssssss

3
wumbotarianhemispheric common market•

You're thinking too much like an economist.

How dare u

2
Ezzbrez•

I think it is only important if it changes the schema by which the other party evaluates which realm they are in. While it is certainly possible that the social cost of disruptions is that house members don't want to feel awkward around lunch time.

Instead I hypothesize their costs are more related towards knowing the other side will be less likely to work with them in the future, as well as the odds of doing so affecting their viability to get re-elected.

1
Holophonist•

Yeah I can see the daycare patrons just thinking of it as simply the cost of leaving your kid there late, which when viewed that way removes the personal guilt because you think "hey, I'm paying them for it."

It seems like quite a leap to assume there would be the same response here. As you say, democrats weren't deterred from doing so before because they thought it was rude to the republicans, so there's not really any social stigma or sense of personal guilt that can be removed.

8
JufftYellen is not a Felon•

It's more then that. Making life uncomfortable for the Republicans is the point.

3
miscsubsOPwhy nations meme•

I agree with u/besttrousers.

My thinking is not along the lines of social cost vs. market cost but social domain vs. market domain.

The parents in the day-care case care about the daycare staff staying longer not primarily because of the cost to the staff but due to this being in the social domain -- it's really more about what being late says about you rather than what it costs to them. But once market norms (penalties) are introduced, the domain changes.

In the Congress case, disrupting the session or broadcasting it from a personal device is considered disrespectful to the institution, and it says more about the member who engages in this behavior than the costs that are associated with it (which is usually minimal.)

Maybe Paul Ryan thinks the social contract has already been broken by the Democrats, thus would no longer be effective. We can't know that for sure. The ineffective size of the penalty makes me think he hasn't considered this issue in depth though.

5
Afro_Samurai•

It shouldn't be that hard to do either, the live stream which gets you fined is also a convenient fund raising platform. A representative could garner much more than $3000 by broadcasting a filibuster of the appropriate bill.

3
relevant_econ_memeGuardian of the Fed•

If this is the case, what good is a piguvian tax?

7
besttrousers•

It's very reasonable to be concerned that Pigouvian taxes will, at some margin, crowd out behavior that people were previously doing purely to be virtuous. That's what happens, for example, when people are paid to donate blood.

24
Kai_DaigojiDanke Bernanke•

This is why economics is hard. That and math.

15
relevant_econ_memeGuardian of the Fed•

What about cases like the cigarette tax and gas tax?

2
besttrousers•

Yeah, I'd be concerned in those cases as well.

3
Zarathustranx•

The monetization that the study postulates seems to require a direct connection between social forces and the fine. The person that the consumer has a social desire not to piss off, the daycare, is the same person levying the fine. Nobody sees an onerous tax on cigarettes and thinks it's now cool to smoke because you're paying for the cost of your sickness to society. It's much more indirect. Although in that case I don't think there are actual social considerations at play. Who is willing to overlook the personal cost of the threat of cancer when deciding to smoke but not willing to overlook the societal cost of them getting cancer. That would be a strange combination of hedonism and altruism.

7
Ezzbrez•

Pigouvian taxes aren't intended to dissuade a behavior necessarily though. I mean that is what they do, but they are meant to internalize the cost of the externality associated with the action. They should make it so that people affected are indifferent. In the baby sitter example, a 'pigouvian tax' would be setting the fine such that it will pay for the wage+overtime costs that are incurred on a per kid basis.

1
Petros557there is no such thing as a market failure•

okay. stupid out-of-context question. how do you know if a paper is widely cited. i've heard that after 150 citations it is regarded really good, but idk anything more.

5
miscsubsOPwhy nations meme•

Well that's a good question. When I wrote that the paper is widely cited, I either assumed it is because I've seen the study referenced a lot (note: availability bias), or I might have read that in a book, for example Airely's book which is one book that cites the paper.

There are lists on the Internet showing highest citation counts for different fields but I'm not sure how reliable each are. I just found one that shows the paper I quoted with 280 citations and in top 2000.

5
Petros557there is no such thing as a market failure•

thanks

3
KEM10R1 submitter•

As far as costs driving people out of grandstanding, you could easily spread the burden nowadays and never see it personally. I wonder where this extra cash is going.

4
gorbachev•

Presumably Paul Ryan cares about a) winning seats for Republicans, b) getting re elected, c) holding on to his status as speaker (ie, managing the freedom caucus), and d) moving up politically.

The relevant question isn't if fines discourage sit ins, but rather if championing a "fines for sit ins" bill serves one of those 4 goals.

A is an empirical question and depends on how marginal voters in marginal districts perceive the issue. Do they see brave dems paying fines for the good of the people? Or do they dems criminally violating the norms of the house, to the point of being forced to face a penalty? I don't know. It's an empirical question. Note: this Q also partially depends on how introducing the fines affects donating behavior in each party. Again, an empirical Q, by raising the stakes the fines bill arguably energizes both bases - by whose more, I can't say.

B, C, and D depend on how voters in his district, other congressmen, the gop base, and the voting public more broadly perceive him for championing the finest bill. The causes of B, C, and D may be well served by championing even a symbolic "get tough on unruly dems" bill.

All of which is to say, I think the objective function you assign to Paul Ryan is probably wrong (and thus so is your argument for why his strategy is stupid and ignorant of behavioral economics).

4
besttrousers•

All of which is to say, I think the objective function you assign to Paul Ryan is probably wrong (and thus so is your argument for why his strategy is stupid and ignorant of behavioral economics).

That's not unreasonable, but I think this is precisely the kind of mistake Paul Ryan (a person who literally became interested in economics by reading Ayn Rand) is likely to make.

2
yep45•

Is it really fair to criticize Ryan for not knowing about this study? It seems like the results would be counterintuitive to most people. The notion of "fine/tax something if you want it to go away" is deeply ingrained in government, but nobody accuses lawmakers of misunderstanding behavioral economics on a daily basis.

3
miscsubsOPwhy nations meme•

When you claim to be the policy wonk of the House, not to mention the Speaker, I think you don't quite get a pass that easily.

16
yep45•

He makes videos about the national debt with graphs. So we are going to say that he's now an idiot if he doesn't apply some random economic study to a (admittedly stunty) proposal

-3†
KelsigIt's Baaack: Ethno-Nationalism and the Return of Mercantilism•

He makes videos about the national debt with graphs

o shit

9
KEM10R1 submitter•

Is it really fair to criticize Ryan for not knowing about this study?

It was in Freakonomics, every layperson knows about it.

9
yep45•

Everybody who's read Freakonomics knows it*

7
Ryguy8954•

which should be everybody

1
vwermisso•

I think the difference is, is that before a sit-in wasn't understood as a faux paus by the public, but with a fine attached (and mentioned), it will be seen as "a dick move" colloquially speaking.

2
friedman24•

You are ignoring that this gives republicans ammunition for advertisements. "So and so politician has been fined 50 times for disrupting congress, elect people that don't disrupt congress so we can get work done!"

1
timaaaaaaay•

Mr. Ryan is trying to be cynical and hoping that people will in fact act in their personal interests.

What it sounds like to me is that monetary fines as a means of regulation have never and will never be a useful primary means of regulation. I am sure you can fold up some bank notes to eventually create a mechanism such as this by folding them enough. Without the rule of law and some deterrent there in there is no chance of economic regulation being a functioning thing.

1
cyclaran•

Just a small thing I thought of - I think the 8 million figure is not the most appropriate in this context. There are several wealthy outliers that heavily skew the average net worth. What should be cited is the median net worth, not the average (which is about 1 million dollars I believe).

5
KelsigIt's Baaack: Ethno-Nationalism and the Return of Mercantilism•

Not to mention that Senators can now be martyrs "I paid thousands to stick up for the middle class!"

4
SnapshillBotPaid for by The Free Market™•

Snapshots:

  1. This Post - archive.org, megalodon.jp, archive.is*

^(I am a bot.) ^(Info ^/ ^Contact)

1