Did one of us screw up Mariah Carey's lip sync playback?

She kept saying "we didn't sound check this" and seems more pissed than when I fucked up shakira's show at the UN.

Posted Jan 1, 2017, 4:45 AM UTC

254161
baineschile•

The whole show was a disaster. And yes, the lip synching was horrendous

90
Anti2633OP•

It looks like they played an instrumental when she expected a full mix/canned backup.

61
faye0518•

Yep. She thought she would be lip synching, so she took out her ear piece before the song (0:32 here); a dancer tugged it in her dress, then after that she had no idea where the earpiece was. So she couldn't even put it back on and try to sing.

Then she messed up the final song even though there was no misunderstanding on that one.

28
tnturnertaco truck•

Great analysis. She even keeps grasping at her collar like she's looking for it.

5
the_unusable•

Looks like the voice track didn't play and she was only willing to lip sync

19
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
m_y•

My analysis too.

Both the foh and mons didnt have her vocal track and she couldnt hear what she was supposed to be singing from her iem mix.

If it was a mixing error it seems mons or foh wouldve atleast had it going but neither did so it seems her playback track was wrong or fucked up.

2
wmoore72•

But FOH/Mons would only be playing the tracks given to them by her people. Surely someone from her staff would make sure the tracks were in the correct order, before being played out ?

2
RogerSmith123456•

OP, please tell us your Shakira story!

67
Anti2633OP•

I'll get back to you guys on that but it was basically the most stressful day of my career and the reason I don't give a shit anymore.

Edit: Full story,

So i had been working at the UN as a conference sound guy for a year or two and the 70th session of the UN is about to begin, lots of setup all over campus, heads of state, thick security, the whole nine yards. On the day in question the Pope is scheduled to arrive, make a speech in the lobby to UN staff (in english), go upstairs and meet with the SG Ban Ki-Moon and then swing back down and address the UN from the General Assembly. Big day.

Scheduled immediately after the Popes speech, IN THE GA CHAMBER, is some unicef or relief thing (I cant remember) that was gonna feature Shakira singing to an instrumental track of Imagine (they love that shit at the UN, Yoko comes by all the time) and then some other singer with some cool groovy west african track that she was gonna sing to.

So we're in the GA control room watching the feeds from elsewhere in the building, Pope's Fiat motorcade pulls up, he waltzs into the lobby, give a speech to staff, heads up the elevator to see the SG. Ten minute private meeting with the SG, back down the elevator, into a little golfcart to take him across the conference building to the GA building (indoors). Couple of camears on risers to capture this huge journey.

So, I don't know how many of you road guys have played with CMSI (Conference Mic, Simultaneous interpretation) systems before, but its basically a bunch of mics hooked up to a pc interface so you can mute and unmute individual mics and route audio to and from interpreters, little hard to learn but nothing fundamentally different from mixing a rock show. GA kicks in to session, SG makes a speach from the dais or podium and of course, right when it counts most, the mic thats always worked all year has decided to crackle and cut for what feels like goddamn forever. We make it through his speach with out much more noticeable issues, and the pope and his gang process in. He delivers a good 45 minutes in his native spanish, we follow along with interpretation, no issues for his bit, but we were on edge the whole time. He finishes, processes out, crowd (diplomats and such) goes wild, big hit this pope guy. standing ovation. Now as hes almost out, our girl Shakira is setting up stage left to sing "Imagine."

Now let me take a second to tell you how poorly we set this up. Standard setup in the GA is the Taiden CMSI rig sent to a yamaha CL3, with ins and outs coming and going to broadcast. none of us really know how to play with Dante yet, but the most we ever use it is with a Rio 1608 on the floor for stage inputs, nothing weird. Today, we've got a little more going on.

In addition to my CL3, we've got another CL3 in the room at a standard FOH position. Wireless mics are inputed there and then a mix is sent to my board to send back to the TV dudes to broadcast. However, and this is the pisser, playback is being sent offa two severs from TV, to two stereo channels on my board, direct out/ auxed to the FOH board, and then that mix sent back to me and to some spare line arrays for the performance, then back to TV. Like, we seriously did not do our homework. So basically im leaving those two channels open, and letting the front of house guy mute/mix em.

So back to the party, People are still going wild about the pope. He leaves outta the front door and fucking immediatly we get the cue for shakiras playback on server 1. Kid in the server room hits play, all is good, i got meter on my board and its getting sent to foh and shakiras ears, everything is gravy.

Then outta fucking nowhere, server 2's meter starts lighting up, keep in mind i left both channels up so that we wouldnt have any double mute scenarios between me and FOH. We start hearing it, over the somber cut of "Imagine," groovy upbeat afro-pop. Shakira is visably pissed but keeps singing cuz shes a goddamn pro. I slap the fader down on my board to minimize damage and get on the comm line and say somthing along the lines of "What the fuck server kid?" "Oh i wanted to make sure it would play" "You didnt think to ask if the channel was muted or let us fucking know? shit shit shit!"

As a sound guy, i can think of 3 shows that would be the biggest for us in general. The president, the superbowl, and the pope. I basically assumed i was both going to get fired and literally damned for our performance that day. in addition, there was some serious issues on the broadcast side distributing shakira's mix out to internal endpoints on the UN campus. Long story short i get grilled by the head of UN broadcasting service and a technical broadcast guy from my contractor, and i let em know what i know. I get out of it unscathed, but they said they wouldn't be bringing the FOH guy back.

If you manage to dig up the video of shakira, i can tell you its been edited with Iso recordings from that day so that it sounds fine: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8-3wIW1Rpiw

I cant find the second performance of the groovy african riff, but that went off with out a hitch after some speeches or playback or something.

Luckily, no in the room really noticed or gave a shit, as they were still going apeshit for the pope. So i guess, thanks pope.

106
Type_ya_name_here•

Now I need to know more.
Do many guitar 'based' bands do lip sync or is it more a solo vocalist thing?

24
faderjockeySqueek•

If it's a big nationally televised broadcast, it's almost always lip sync. (Although these days the term "playing to track" is preferred.

Super Bowl? Track. Macy's Parade? Track. SNL? Track track track (except for the house band)

38
Type_ya_name_here•

So when Chris from Coldplay was at the Super bowl he was likely singing to a track? What about other instruments ?
Is this mostly done to gain an optimal performance ? Is it fracked in a typical studio ?
I feel like I'm peeping behind a curtain of a world I sort of want to know about?

12
Haperzi•

always thought SNL didn't use tracks, just cause i remember lorne michaels tsk tsking ashlee simpson and saying they didn't know she was doing it and they didn't allow it. that was a while ago now though

11
Grumpy_JakeTheatre//HoW•

Then how come the mix for SNL is always so shitty?

10
notacrook•

I don't think that SNL is as play-to-track as much anymore.

3
paulellertsen•

Allthough there are not much vocals in the mix, I have always thought that the band for David Lettermans show was mixed extremely well. I have a feeling it was all live also. So it seems it is at least possible to mix for TV. Granted, they had a gazillion tries to get it right

2
copperwatt•

I definitely remember a Jimmy Eat World SNL performance of the middle with ragged vocals and a wrong note in the solo. No way that was a track. I still loved it.

2
User_Not_RecognizedPro Turd Polisher•

Not everyone plays to track at SNL. A lot certainly do, but not all.

1
asshair•

Get back to us

1
Anti2633OP•

I did!

1
asshair•

Wow.

1
fohsupreme•

Mildly interesting and fun fact, the company I work for has two iTech 8000s that we bought used off of a company that often does sound for the pope. The boss refers to them as the pope amps.

1
St_Bernardus•

She made him want to speak spanish.

2
binkerfluid•

dorito...burrito!

1
FrietagSurvivor•

I took it that her IEMs failed. She had partial phrases in the backing tracks so I think she was supposed to sing at least most of the first song.

54
Anti2633OP•

I noticed she pulled one out. I'm sure the RF environment is a nightmare down there as well, but you'd assume coordination would have started months ago.

40
FrietagSurvivor•

You'd assume, but based on my (albeit limited at that level) experience, depending on the crew and who's got final production call, how much arrogance, laziness and seat of the pants work can come into play.

45
gwhooliganPro FOH / TD HoW - Denver, CO•

So, basically any show ever, ever ever ever. Every plan works great until you get to the venue and everything changes.

11
jacobchapmanSemi-Pro•

The old quote I've heard is "no plan survives first contact with implementation"

10
FrietagSurvivor•

Also RF wouldn't have wiped it out totally. Likely a stupid error like a dead battery, pack off (female artists often can't even reach their pack controls in costume), or a misroute.

23
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
wtf-m8Pro FOH & Monitor Guy - Earth•

I think since she was lip syncing the song before completely, they had the mic off in the monitor mix. They never turned it back on. She'd start a verse live, but stopped each time when the mon still wasn't there.

14
HiMyNameIsAri•

But for the second song there was a full vocal track, so was that put in at the last minute, or was the vocal track missing from the first song and she was never meant to fully sing at all to begin with?

8
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
soundguru•

Yup, thats what happened.

1
m_y•

If her iems failed then we shouldve still heard the recorded vocal tracks in the main mix.

Also there were backup monitor wedges onstage.

My guess-playback track fucked up and didnt play with correct vocals.

1
SkinnyMacPro - BUF/ROC NY•

With line arrays the isolation on stage is often so good that you can't get anything useful from FOH bleed.

2
Necsus•

Mistakes were made

28
Anti2633OP•

Which ones?

9
Necsus•

I recall her asking if someone would turn on her monitors. Seems things never resolved / got worse from there.

28
Anti2633OP•

I'm glad we as sound guys will even deny the monitor requests of even the a-listest of artists.

Edit because text doesn't carry the inflection I hear in my head :/s

84
binkerfluid•

moves hand in a spot near the knob but doesnt actually turn the knob

"better...?"

52
EWW3•

"Nah, it'll screw up my house mix!"

31
Jarmatus•

As a musician, I didn't know stubbornly denying monitor requests was an actual thing.

13
KzBoy•

Sorry, I misread that as "I'm glad we, as professionals, boast about not doing our job".

Last time I checked when it comes to IEM the talent gets whatever they want, in my capability to provide.

I ran monitors for a guy who wanted a TON of mid-highs in his ears. Sounded terrible to me (and anyone else listening to his mix), however we mixed two channels. One for his ears (with a +10db boost to 900-8k), and one for the rest of the band. His performance was great in the house and he was happy. I understand limitations of time and wedges or things that affect house mix. However if you can't give the tallent what they need to do their job, you can't expect them to DO a good job.

tl;dr: I'm hoping that comment was sarcastic. EDIT: confirmed to be /s, my faith in humanity is restored :-D

10
DarkStarPDX•

I call BS on the monitors not being up. Those dancers nailed every queue and mark like the professionals they are. Mariah didn't bother showing up for rehearsal and owns that failure completely.

30
RealPutin•

A simple 8-count and feeling the bass is enough for the dancers though. Much easier to dance sans monitor than sing. Plus no guarantee hers wasn't the only one out (dead battery or something)

Plus, there were wedges. Could easily be enough for the dancers and not her.

30
Millstone50•

They also nailed every cue!

21
branevomet•

I find this very likely. I once had to accommodate 3 crews with 3 different talents. 2 of the talents showed up to sound check and one did not. This was a small private room that we all know can be very dangerous if you don't cover your bases. Ringing out mains and monitors...etc. I was asked not to do this for any act that evening as they had their own FOH/MON.... So I sat back and watched a 240lb dude yell into a mic to tune the room for a 90 lb female singer who sings quieter than she talks. The other 2 acts showed up to check and nailed it, she sounded nothing like she should have and her TM/FOH blamed it on bad booking.... They were good engineers though. Knew their way around the house gear and had been on a successful tour for a while. I think they forgot the dangers of a small room (86 cap) with mains 3-5 ft away from vocals. Reputation of the venue was not on the line so I had to watch them sweat and end up blaming it on a bad booking.... it was weird... but she was second so the show ended with a great act performing well...

2
Sajl6320•

The producer that decided to let her be on the show

4
JustAQuestion512•

All of them

2
FalcopuntJust a Truck Driver•

As all of us can probably agree all acts on ears should have at least one monitor on stage in case of catastrophic failure.

27
Anti2633OP•

I did see some on stage

17
RetardedChimpanzee•

Wedges were probably intended for the dancers

15
borezPro FOH - London.•

There were monitors right across the front of that stage. If her IEM's failed her vox should have been instantly directed or pushed up in them.

Unless, of course, it was a lip sync job.

Who knows without all the info though.

8
master_dong•

I agree but I'd be surprised if one wedge would have been sufficient for her.

11
Jarmatus•

Over that crowd? Nah. One wedge wouldn't have been enough.

11
theantnestCleaned Toilets at a festival once•

There was at least a pair of 115XT's right in front of her.

8
luigiman2018•

And the wedges were for the dancers only. They would not be sufficient for a lead vocalist.

2†
St_Bernardus•

Front page thread linked to this. Happy new year everyone!

22
tubameister•

I knew I'd see this thread pop up. lol'd at the hosts basically saying "even though it's shit the crowd will love anything Mariah does" r/music is discussing it too https://www.reddit.com/r/Music/comments/5ldle4/mariah_carey_just_completely_bombed_live_at_times/

17
dr_blasto•

Dunno why Mariah Carey is still a thing in 2017.

8
copperwatt•

To be fair, we don't yet have any evidence or her being a thing in 2017.

5
Bigbeardedbastard•

It seems that she was having IEM issues with the first song, which had full vocal tracks but her lip sync was off in a lot of places like she couldnt hear her pick ups. In the second song either she was supposed to sing with partial tracks that have harmonies and her high notes or with full tracks but only the partial vocal track was loaded, but because she couldnt hear she would start a phrase and quit. I would guess that the wedges only had tracks for the dancers and their tracks may have only been rhythm section and with no pitch or vocal cues she couldnt get back on. The third song she had full tracks again, but because she still had no iem's her sync is again really really off.

17
xxhalfasianA1 | Boston•

She's out of sync for parts of "Auld Lang Syne". She seems to be struggling with the IEM in her left ear. At 1:13 of this video, it looks like the dancer/Mariah was checking that the receiver was functioning and the dancer was tucking that back into its pouch. I don't think she removed her IEM's because they hoped they fixed it.

Whatever happened there, it should be known that an artist fidgeting with their IEM is trying to say something about it. An engineer who saw or was told of this should have rerouted the IEM feed into the stage foldback for Mariah with no regard to what effect it'd have on the backup dancers because not doing so would be bad (lol). Now either this doesn't happen (?!?), or it does happen and unfortunately it's still not good enough for Mariah. The dancers remaining in sync leads me to believe the foldback was working in some fashion. Another possibility is the engineer thought the IEM problem was fixed and didn't reroute to the stage foldback because they didn't know there was a problem (again, ?!?!?). To be fair though, the bigger problem right now seems to be the missing vocal track Mariah points out onstage. It's highly likely she was expecting to continue lip-syncing "Emotions" and the live mic was only for her to address the crowd. Rather than singing live, she fumbled the whole piece. Awkward.

During the third song, we can see that both of her IEM earbuds have been removed but she still can't quite get the words sync'd. My guess is the stage foldback just isn't doing it for her or the engineer still isn't aware that she's having IEM issues and so she's simply resigned.

TL;DR - I think the IEM failed for the first song, she was missing the recorded vocals for the second song, and she gave up during the third song.

I will end by saying that I find it highly unlikely that it could be the engineer's fault. I do know that some high-profile artists don't do sound check so whoever was supposed to be the liaison of every single detail fucked up the hardest here...

14
theantnestCleaned Toilets at a festival once•

On this video, she performs the song before and after with little issue, which points to it not being a monitor problem. More likely she was expecting a full canned lead vocal and instead got a backing track.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZU1pGJW5aLs

12
mistakenotmy•

Watch at 1:14. Does it look like the dancer is doing something with a pack? Did something maybe happen when that feathered thing she was wearing got taken off?

11
binkerfluid•

good catch

maybe something happened when they took that coat off

10
Artrios•

Yup she says she can't hear right after that but.. The wide shot was a little suss- I'd say that they went to a wide shot so they could troublehsoot the problem invisibly, if the director knew about the sound problem.

5
KzBoy•

Ya, definitely looks like he is re-clipping a pack.

2
delayeduser•

i wouldn't say "little issue" the lip syncing was so bad for the third song!!!

4
theantnestCleaned Toilets at a festival once•

The whole performance was horrendous. I meant little technical issue

5
m_y•

I agree with you.

If it was a monitor issue why didnt we hear the vocals in the main mix--or why wasnt someone putting them in the wedges.

Not the first time an artist says "turn me up" out of confusion.

1
rigglethorn•

Anyone know who the sound company is running the event?

9
BigKahunaBgr•

Yes.

17
Sabored•

Probably PRG

4
the_samenessAudio/Video Engineer - London•

Pretty

Ropey

Gear

6
saxmaniac1987Pro Corporate - Philadelphia•

Looks like sound was MSI.

But of course someone on her crew could be at fault, not necessarily the provider.

6
BigKahunaBgr•

It is msi they do it every year. And the inauguration.

1
DILGEPro - DC•

I heard through the grapevine that the MSI guys reported no issues on their end.

2
luigiman2018•

It was announced as Dick Clark Productions

2
Bantertrack•

This whole thing is kinda like my worst nightmare coming to life, feel bad for the guy. Events going south are never fun, but then imagine having the whole world talk about your fuck up lol

7

Um.. Mariah is a girl.

-3
Bantertrack•

The sound guy... or girl

13
in_search_of_1988•

Just heard about this on Facebook (no tv here) and checked reddit for a story. Sounds like you had the same idea!

5
XanderSnave•

It seems to me it was more of a communication error. She thought she would be lip syncing, you guys didn't.

5†
meiso•

You guys?

26
CATHOLIC_EXTREMIST•

I didn't plan on her lip syncing, did you?

14

I reviewed my contract from the show I ran last night, it wasnt anywhere in my riders.

Of course a small bar in Delaware typically doesn't have much say in a Mariah Carey show.

15
NANO56•

Something something she should go to rehearsal something something

3
discopigeon•

I've got a question.

I'm a bit confused, with lip syncing is the singer just pretending to sing (or singing with their mike off) or are they singing on top of themselves singing?

5
ExLenne•

It depends. Sometimes it is there as a crutch should the artist stumble or need to catch their breath, etc. Sometimes it is just the backing vocals with the occasional high note that the artist can't/won't/shouldn't hit every performance. It varies from artist to artist, song to song and performance to performance.

For instance here it seems that either a) Mariah was expecting a full vocal track to lip sync to and they played a track with just backing and her high notes or b) the first and third songs were full vocal tracks but the second was meant to be sung live and she couldn't hear herself.

15
SynesthesiaBruh•

Sometimes it is there as a crutch should the artist stumble or need to catch their breath

Wot? How does it sync up? Do they have like a switch on their mic they can press real quick or something?

3
jared555•

Depending on the situation there are foot switches that switch between two xlr's. Could also be a subtle signal to a stage hand. Ducker on the tracks vocals plus a switched mic would be another option.

7
danielsound•

Wot

any sound pro can manage these really quick fade in and fade outs, especially if they have regularly worked with the artist. There are things like that when mixing Broadway that require the sound mixer to have nearly perfect musical tempo to know when to hit their sound cues.

2
discopigeon•

Interesting. Do you know if they lip sync for like the tonight show or like Colbert? Have any idea if that's the case with the instruments too?

3

99% of all broadcast shows and events are "play to track" ( lip sync).

Most of the time is mandatory to acquire the gig.

5
DodgeballrocksSemi-Pro•

It's TMZ so take with a grain of salt but potentially some new information:

http://www.tmz.com/2017/01/01/mariah-carey-new-years-eve-performance-sabotage-emotion/

5
eairy•

Always assume incompetence before malice

3
DodgeballrocksSemi-Pro•

Oh I agree. There are two many people with very important jobs to all agree to purposely screw up a live show.

1
binkerfluid•

no wonder the dancers had to help her down the stairs with all those inner ear problems she was having....

;)

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
DodgeballrocksSemi-Pro•

Lots of artists call them that.

2

Watching this video a few times from the very top is a very revealing thing to me. In my professional opinion, there wasn’t very much she could have done differently in this situation. The next few paragraphs are all speculation but hear me out:

If you watch closely at the top, she starts her set just fine - however as soon as she makes the costume change out of her white feather coat, you can see her dancer frantically trying to fix her IEM body pack. To me it looks as if her IEM cable gets snagged on the coat, which in turn pulled the pack out of the pouch on her back, and most likely caused the pack to hit the floor, or at least get jostled around significantly.

It is very possible the volume knob on her pack ended up getting turned down to an unusable volume either from it getting caught on the coat, or the frantic rush of her dancer trying to fix the problem. Her dancer is just that, a dancer - not a tech.. He did what he could to fix the problem but most likely didn’t know to check the settings on her pack to make sure she could actually hear. Also the pack seems to be in an awkward position on her back, so even if she wanted to it would have been difficult for her to reach/fix the problem herself.

The first instinct of most artists at that point is to pull their IEM’s completely out, and perform as best as they can to what little they can hear from the main PA - however in this situation the main PA doesn’t seem to be in the standard position you would see a PA in a pop show, thus her likely being virtually in silence on stage. Combine that with a lack of a sound check (which could very easily be a legit statement and one out of her control for this gig) and you now have the perfect storm that resulted in the fiasco that was her set.

Anyways, I’m just trying to give an alternative perspective, because every comment I keep reading on this performance has been coming from the negative, and that it is “obvious” that she could have fixed the issue - when, to me, there really is nothing obvious about this situation at all..

K thanks for reading. :)

5
aydiosmioMobile DJ•

Here's an account from her team on what happened.

http://ew.com/tv/2017/01/02/mariah-carey-nye-what-really-happened/

5
Anti2633OP•

"Choppy" sounds like an RF issue.

1
binkerfluid•

I was coming here to ask which one of you guys did this ;-)

3
frohardorfrohome•

Can someone explain to me why she didn't just sing over the music?

2
Riveted321•

Typically there is a track within what the singer listens to that will tell them when to start singing, which verse they are on, etc. If the initial cue is missed, or all of them, and they're just going off of a generic beat with no vocals, then it's pretty hard to determine exactly where in the song they are. If it's off by a bit, then it's really ugly to listen to, any more than a bit and you may as well not even bother.

Apparently her equipment wasn't working for one reason or another, and she couldn't hear the cues, or much of anything else for that matter.

4
Petros99•

She probably could not hear herself over the crowd.

2