[SPOILERS ALL] What's the deal with black magic?
(I'm gonna mention the Laws of Magic a lot, so just a quick refresher for those of you, like me, who don't have them memorized:
- No killing
- No shapeshifting others
- No mind violation
- No mind domination
- No necromancy
- No time travel
- No fucking with Outsiders)
So I'm curious as to what we know about how black magic corrupts people.
First off, we know it does. There are several WoJ to that effect (mostly roundabout by way of talking about how the Blackstaff protects Ebeneezer from said corruption). There is some kind of corruption inherent to black magic; it's not just an "absolute power corrupts absolutely" thing.
But what exactly counts as black magic? Breaking the Laws of Magic is the easy answer, but I don't think that's the full one. Does breaking any of the Laws of Magic corrupt you? Even the sixth or seventh? Dealing with Outsiders is dumb, but I don't really see how it's inherently corrupting.
Then, we have the exceptions to the laws: non-humans. You can pretty much do whatever you want to them without breaking a Law of Magic. Why is it bad to kill a human with magic, but not a Faerie? What's the difference between raising a human and a dinosaur?
Another exception: killing without magic. What about death magic is inherently bad. You can kill with a sword or a gun, but direct magical murder is bad juju. Why? Also, what about indirect murder? If I lock someone in a room, then set it on fire with my magic, is that breaking the First Law?
Finally, two things I'm not sure I'm remembering right:
-
I remember that Ebeneezer killed Paulo with a satellite, and Dresden was horrified (I forget if he thought that act counted as breaking the First Law or not). No Warden came after Ebeneezer, and Dresden didn't seem worried about Ebeneezer being corrupted.
-
I'm pretty sure the Gatekeeper can see the future. Why is this not considered breaking the Sixth Law?
Posted Jan 14, 2017, 3:05 AM UTC