More Hardware Speculation!

Speculation

Edit: Redoing the numbers ... thanks everybody who caught the Nintendo JP numbers.

Since Nintendo didn't really release any technical specifications, I thought it might be fun to try to figure some things out given what we DO know. One of the key new pieces of information we have is that battery life will be 2.5 to 6 hours. From there, we can back out power consumption numbers. The following is of course pretty rough, any suggestions for improvements are improved assumptions are welcome:

  • 5197 mAh, 3.8V chemistry (19.75 Whr) battery 4310 MAh / 16.38 Whr (assuming 3.8V chemistry)
  • Screen uses ~ 500ma (really rough guess - for argument's sake we'll say this includes everything non-SoC related)

So if the battery lasts 2.5 to 6 hours, that means it will consume 1250mAh to 3000mAh, which leaves 3947 to 2197 3060 to 1310 mAh for the rest of the Switch. This works out to ~ 15Whr to 8.35 Whr 11.63 to 5 Whr.

So when going full-bore, the Switch should consume (not including the screen) ~ 6W to 1.39W 4.65W to 0.83W in handheld mode.

So the big question is now, what SoCs fit into that power range? Is this consistent w/ Nintendo using the X1?

X1's TDP is 15W, with a typical max consumption of 10W. That's with the CPU cluster running @ 1.9ghz, and the GPU @ 1ghz.

Using power numers from Anandtech.com (which again, isn't perfect because this is a different SoC on a different although hopefully equivalent manufacturing process), 4x A57 @ 1ghz will consume 1.83W. Assuming Nintendo's worst-case scenario of 2.5 hours, that's ~ 4.6 Whr.

Backing this all out, that means the GPU, undocked, will be consuming 4.16W 2.8W yikes!.

This is actually really interesting, because it means:

  1. Some of my assumptions are wrong (possible!)

  2. This is not an X1, or similar.

  3. Utilization magic.

Anandtech (again, awesome source of power consumption info) saw controlled tests where the X1 was underclocked to be about as fast (gpu-wise) as the ipad air 2. The pad GPU is about half as powerful as the X1, and stock X1 clockspeed is 1ghz - so that means it is underclocked to about 500mhz. At that speed, the GPU consumed on average 1.5W. See the issue here? Why would the Switch consume more than almost double that at a lower clockspeed?

So what does this mean? Well first, any mistakes I've made regarding battery capacity, platform/screen consumption, and maths will of course throw this off. Secondly, if there is either software or hardware magic that increases utilization it could still be an X1, except will use more power (and hopefully have more performance). Finally, and what I am going to run with, is that it isn't the X1.

A few more assumptions: I am going to assume it is based off of the X1, and fabbed @ 20nm at TSMC.

So: I think the switch is actually closer to X1*2, with a core config of 512:32:32. That would give it ~ 314/629 gfops (fp32/16) as a portable, and 786/1573 gflops docked.

This means that undocked, it has about the performance of the Wii U, which makes a lot of sense. The games look a lot like Wii U games, graphically.

TL;DR: Silicon is double the X1, @ leaked clockspeeds that works out to 314/629 gflops (Wii U level) undocked, 786/1573 docked.

Other thoughts:

*I still am worried that the CPU is underpowered. This is true of all the modern consoles, but as usual Nintendo takes it to another level.

*For the purposes of large, open-world games, I think the Switch might actually have a better architecture than the other consoles, given its (hopefully) fast cartridge-based IO. I remember reading about this in an article about BOTW, where the devs said it was easier to stream in data, thanks to the cards.

*Thoughts on whether gamecards will be able to contain hardware? It would be neat if Nintendo decided to keep this functionality, does the 3DS have this ability? I realize this is not the greatest way to go, but would be a nice option to have if the NSW becomes a runaway hit and someone wants to get fancy.

Edit: I've reworked the numbers, I still think this is correct, as my calculations show that the GPU could consume about 2.8W, and according to AT's numbers 2*X1 would consume about 3W. Given the rough nature of these calculations, I think the conclusion is reasonable, and would mean Nintendo made the technically smart decision to go wide and slow (which makes sense for a handheld).

All of that being said, if my platform estimate of 500ma is way off in the wrong direction, this stops making sense.

Posted Jan 14, 2017, 4:23 PM UTC · edited

917
ignition386•

5197 mAh, 3.8V chemistry (19.75 Whr) battery

Nintendo's Japanese site lists a 4310mAh battery: https://www.nintendo.co.jp/hardware/switch/specs/index.html#1 <-- Click "「Nintendo Switch本体」の主な仕様 "

5
SwiftJustice007•

Time for OP to recalculate lol

2
PodspiOP•

Ugh... still works though! My initial calculations left about 1.1W unaccounted for so... that's gone now.

2
rusenikolovski•

its far from tegra x1. if you look at the calculation, the 4310mah is even beyon the case.

https://www.nintendo.co.jp/hardware/switch/specs/index.html#1

i would argue that it has Denver in the CPU + around 512cuda (if Maxwell).

1
PodspiOP•

I am hoping, yea. Denver actually makes a ton of sense in the handheld space, because as I've noted earlier, it is wide (which means it can run slowly and still deliver decent performance).

The downside to all of this talk of going wide and slow is it is expensive to manufacture. If it is true that nvidia sales reps were told to get a console or go home, I could imagine nvidia was prepared to accept low margins for the win, which would follow a large SoC.

Given that Nintendo refuses to lower their prices on consoles, one could imagine nvidia has promised a shrink that would improve perf/battery life, be cheaper for them to produce, and still get paid the same amount. It would be a win/win for everybody (except those of us hoping for a discounted switch)

1
rusenikolovski•

if its pascal dont expect 512. more like 384 or somethig weard

1
PodspiOP•

I think if it's fabbed @ 20nm it'll end up being Maxwell.

Like the Wii U, I bet it'll be years (if ever) before we truly know what's going on, though I hope I'm wrong. I think the biggest disappointment is the battery, too be honest. Why so small?! Perhaps to open the door for battery cases? Hmm

1
rusenikolovski•

im hoping fall to bring spec reveal. even the sales predictions after year over 10mil. The first direct comparison will fall over Skyrim. It will outperform the expectations :) and the sales will skyrocket over 10mil in December. After Skyrim reveal, the specs will fall in to place. consider:

  • 1080

  • crisp frame rate

  • Impressive Draw distance

  • NO loading time

  • HD Rumble (speculation*)

1
IShowUBasics•

Its a downclocked Tegra X1 and nothing else. 700 MHz while docked and 300MHz while undocked.

-3
dnav11•

Oh come on. That was just a rumor. How do we know that the final specs haven't changed?

3
PodspiOP•
  1. I really don't think so. The X1 is just too slow, in my opinion. Especially underclocked!
3