anyGould•

For years, there have been no parking requirements for downtown residential towers. “But to my knowledge, every single building has been built with parking … They’re still providing it because the market wants it.”

Yeah... and because they upcharge the renter/owners for the spaces. Not like they're just building these for free.

I'm all for allowing businesses to rent their stalls to other businesses (without the rezoning bit - it's still a parking space, after all). But a business should still be able to show that they've acquired (either through building their own, or renting/trading with neighboring businesses) that they have enough parking for the expected use. Otherwise I can easily see a day where every parking spot is a pay-park. After all, why would a business eat the cost of putting in parking so all their neighbors can leech off it?

Oh, and as for this quote from Old Strathcona?

Is there a parking shortage? “Honestly, it’s mostly perception,” said Murray Davison, executive director of the Old Strathcona Business Association. People walk farther to get to a store in West Edmonton Mall and local parking lots are rarely more than half full.

Yeah, that's because the local lots charge an arm and a leg, so everyone just parks a block or two off Whyte in the residential area. And if people actually walk further in WEM, that's probably because it's indoors.

29
sidek•

If every stall becomes pay to park in an area, what's the problem? Businesses would only choose that route if it didn't affect their customer base -- say if most of their customers were walking or busing, or if so many people wanted to park there that the parking lot would fill nonetheless.

In any of these cases, forcing businesses to eat parking costs is nothing but a subsidy on driving. The real cost of driving needs to be reflected if we want our city to transition to a healthier mix of transportation options.

12
anyGould•

The problem would be that people (like on Whyte) will simply go park in the neighboring residential.

I'm all for getting more transit options - but this strikes me as just giving a subsidy to businesses and offloading the problems to the neighborhood.

16
peeflarAmblesidian•

Parking restrictions can fix that.

4
anyGould•

Unless you're planning to put parking restrictions on the entire city, that's just pushing the problem elsewhere.

7
Edmonturn•

Not that this has anything to do with your comment, but there's a business near my house that has no parking. You know where their customers park? In front of my house. It is quite annoying. Legal and annoying.

7
future_boundOP•

I would say the solution is restricting parking on your street to residents, not making businesses provide parking.

5
anyGould•

I shudder to think how much it would cost to enforce city-wide parking restrictions. Decals for every vehicle, plus guest decals, plus enforcement.

10
Jbeats•

A few cities in Ontario have online registration. Guests get 15 over nights per year and residents can buy monthly passes. All connected to the plate number.

3
future_boundOP•

Nothing. Decals can be sold to homeowners for the 15 dollars it takes to print them and pay a clerk to process the payment. Enforcement is largely self sustaining due to fines.

0
HimserRegional Citizen•

or get rid of subsidised street parking for everyone. why should everyone's taxes go to creating you a parking spot?

2
Edmonturn•

It has been an issue for years now, there's no real fix and the city can't or won't do anything about it. Local business is good, traffic is bad, there's too many cars, not enough street. You get the idea though, gotta take the good with the bad.

2
Planner_Hammish•

Otherwise I can easily see a day where every parking spot is a pay-park.

I don't see a problem with this. You're already paying for parking, even if you don't drive to the store, because it's baked into the prices for everything.

I don't mind paying for parking at all, as long as there is constrained supply. So if the block is full and it's $3.50/hr, I'm happy to pay. But if the block is empty and it's $3.50/hr, then I'm feeling like they're overcharging me.

At the end of the day, we treat food, shelter and warm clothing as a free market (you pay what the market will bear), but for some reason when it comes to parking, we're happy with a Soviet style command & control market where the government tells you how much you need. It makes no sense really IMO.

5
anyGould•

That's because Tragedy of the Commons is a thing. Why put parking in your store at all if you can just let your neighbors pay for your parking instead?

Besides, you could make the same argument for bathrooms in restaurants - we dictate how many they have to have, after all.

7
Planner_Hammish•

You bring up a good point about parking. There are three ways that you can think about it:

  1. as you said, parking is an ancillary service to all development, just like restrooms. The supply should be mandated by code and developed as an unfunded mandate from the government. There is no demand management - no such thing as too much parking or too many restrooms;

  2. parking is infrastructure, just like roads and bridges. The supply should be provided as part of an overall development strategy. The demand is managed by restrictions on time, place, user, and maybe some pricing.

  3. parking is real estate, a commodity that can be traded. The supply is managed by return on investment and the demand is managed by price.

Edmonton has all three models in operation, but I think it needs to move more towards the third paradigm.

1
CalbertaBound•

If you make it difficult for me to access parking or try to charge me to patronise your business, my wallet and I will go somewhere else.

7
future_boundOP•

That's exactly the point. Businesses should decide for themselves whether saving money on parking is worth it. Most businesses will still want parking. But perhaps something like a small business on 124 street, like referenced in the article, doesn't need parking to make money. Why should they have to provide it?

7
CalbertaBound•

Look to Kitsilano in Vancouver for a taste of what Edmonton is in for if we go down this route.

Shuttered businesses everywhere. Once lively streets now a ghost town.

3
future_boundOP•

You're blaming parking restrictions for business closures in Kitsilano?

The issue there is exorbitant property prices driven by a bubble. Simply put, it costs too much to operate a business there for what local residents actually spend.

Reducing parking requirements (read: not reducing parking, but the mandated requirement to have it) does the opposite. It increases flexibility for firms and allows for innovation.

5
CalbertaBound•

It increases flexibility for firms and allows for innovation.

It decreases flexibility by not allowing for parking when a business that previously didn't require it moves out, thus reducing the potential pool of businesses that can move in.

0†
Mug_of_coffee•

Once lively streets now a ghost town.

Gross exaggeration.

2
CalbertaBound•

You can see it clear as day with Google StreetView. If it were any more dead, we'd see a tumbleweed roll by in front of the 99 B Line.

1
shoefase•

I don't understand the current ideology at city hall. They use terms like "we're parking mad" and we need a "parking diet". Can someone explain to me how having enough is automatically a surplus?

I've looked it up in r/edmonton before and posted the links, but I'm too lazy to at the moment. Anyways, the short of it is this: vehicles per household are increasing. So is decreasing our residential parking really good planning, or is it a short term experiment?

And I'm really tired of all the comparisons of Edmonton vs a more crowded city. We don't build smaller houses because people live like sardines in Bangladesh. We don't need to model our long term planning on logistical problems!

3