Roth vs. Traditional 401k - City/State Taxes?

Retirement

I don't intend to start-up the standard Roth/Traditional, 401k/IRA discussion, but I had a specific question regarding Non-Federal income taxes.

Typically, the line you often hear is "If you expect to be taxes at a higher income bracket when you retire, a Roth makes more sense." My question is, to what degree do state and local taxes impact this equation? For example, if I expect my income to increase, but potentially to not be subject to NY state, or at least New York City taxes (2.9%-3.6%), when I retire.

Can this consideration actually impact the math? Is this an ignorant question? If yes to the latter question, LMK why, and I'll remove the post!

Posted Jan 24, 2017, 6:09 PM UTC

12
traken•

State and local taxes should factor into the discussion but they make a difficult topic even more complex. Not only do you have to consider where you live now but where you might live later. That's a lot of combinations to consider.

It's also of somewhat limited use since taxes will usually be collected one way or another. A lot of people move to Florida to have no income tax but fail to realize that property and other taxes are higher to compensate.

With the low amount of state and local taxes and the complexity they add to the discussion, I think it's relatively okay to just forget about them. If you live in NYC and plan to retire in rural Kansas, then you might think about them.

6
RTchokeOP•

Thanks for your response! My main take-away, given my current situation (currently taxed in Manhattan), is that yes, it will impact the calculation, but likely in a fairly insignificant manner.

It's also possible that it's all a wash, since the current high local taxes could/would be equally avoided in a pre-tax allocation as it would after moving and pulling from a post-tax allocation

1