r/boardgames•
Skybrush

Some quick thoughts about New Angeles and gamebalance..

So, one of my groups just recently picked up New Angeles. We've gotten a few playthroughs done, but the last one really started a discussion that made us kind of think through the entire game in terms of balance and layout.

During our first playthrough it became quite apparent that two out of the four of us were not federalists and we ended up playing off each other which in turn made it really difficult for the federalist to get anything done.

All games after that had kind of a similar feel. We figure out who's working with the team and shut out the others and control the board in that way.

However, during our last playthrough we thought we had it all figured out as one of our six players, let's call him X, made all the wrong decisions for the team and was labeled as the federalist after a couple of really odd moves. Nearing the end of the game, we were already in a tough spot, making some misplays but still having a decent shot at winning when all of a sudden it turns out that the supposed federalist was not the federalist. Instead, we had just voted through an action card for the real federalist leading to the federalist winning.

You see, X fell behind quite early and instead of fighting for a collective victory he decided to crash the game instead. This led to a fairly lengthy discussion about catch-up mechanics, victory conditions and overall how we were playing the game.

We considered that we might be playing the game a bit too above board, with us laying out a plan too clearly and then following exact steps to reach those goals. In the end, this might not exactly be fun for the federalist as they can't really mess anything up early on as they'll be shunned for not following the groups plan.

We've decided that we're going to try and not lay out a plan but instead only allow people presenting their offers to talk, explaining what they would do with their action card. It may add a bit of chaos to the game and hopefully make the game a bit more interesting for both sides.

All in all, I've enjoyed all of our playthroughs of the game, but this last one soured my taste a bit, but that might just be me.

Posted Feb 8, 2017, 2:39 AM UTC

1712
Loading comments…