ELI5: Why happened during the Space Shuttle Columbia Disaster?
Posted Feb 16, 2017, 5:34 AM UTC
Posted Feb 16, 2017, 5:34 AM UTC
[removed]
[removed]
[removed]
Brief explanation: the engineers pushed through a flaw with the o-rings that needed to expand in order to seal properly but since they were flawed,they couldn't do the job properly and once it hit a specific temperature,there was a gas leak from this specific spot and once it ignited is when the explosion happen. So ehticly, they should have shut down the mission but chose not to because of the amount of money that would be wasted.
a flaw with the o-rings
That's Challenger, not Columbia.
[removed]
Wrong Spaceship dude
IIRC they had had some problems with the heat shield tiles on previous flights and were wanting to pause the launches but NASA ultimately overruled due to politics and sent the Challenger up knowing it was not 100% trustworthy ultimately dooming the crew. I think this has been swept under the rug in the ensuing years. This incident made me lose a lot of respect for NASA. Someone please correct me if I am misremembering.
EDIT meant Columbia not Challenger obviously.
Well, the question was about Columbia, not Challenger, for one. You're describing the Challenger exploding in the 80s. Columbia was in 2003.
Challenger exploded going up, Columbia broke apart coming back into the atmosphere.
I was talking about Columbia. NASA sent it up knowing it was faulty and would not survive re-entry.
Well it wasn't so much political as fiscal. They had seen foam shed from the tank in previous launches without any issues, so they didn't want to spend the money on what the engineers wanted to do, which was using satellites to inspect the shuttles in orbit for damage.
Once they discovered the damage to Columbia after being in orbit, they realized there was nothing they could do about it, so they downplayed it and hoped it would work out.
You lost a lot of respect for Nasa yet don't seem to know any of the details or differences between two different disasters?
That was a typo. I meant Columbia. I know exactly the two disasters. I live near JSC in Houston and grew up with people that worked there. It was close to home. NASA sent Columbia up knowing they would not survive the re-entry.
No they didn't. The damage to Columbia happened during liftoff. You can't cancel liftoff at that point.
There's a good argument that Challenger should never have been sent up, but I can't believe you would have got the missions confused a second time having just been picked up on it.
The white side engines are big tubes full of stuff that burns. One morning when the launch was delayed, the seals between the segments of these engines got so cold that they squished a little and stayed that way. When the propellant inside was fired during the launch, a spray of burning gas came out the side of the engine where the seal was not filling the gap properly. Unfortunately, this hot jet was aimed at the big orange fuel tank, burned into it, and set off all the liquid fuel at once in a huge explosion, destroying the vehicle.
I believe that was Challenger, not Columbia
Drat. You're right.
[deleted]
[removed]
As Columbia was taking off, a large chunk of the insulating foam broke off the tank and hit the wing. This caused damage to the wing.
Chunks of foam had broken off during previous launches buy had never caused much damage, so they figured it would be alright.
On re-entry, the hot gasses of the atmosphere (from coming back into the atmosphere multiple times the speed of sound) entered the damaged point in the wing and basically caused the whole shuttle to break apart.