ELI5: Why is doing the paperwork for income called "paying taxes" when the taxes are already taken from our paychecks?

Economics

Are people meaning to say "filing taxes" instead?

Posted Feb 16, 2017, 3:23 PM UTC

3018
apawst8•

It's not called "paying taxes." It's called "filing a tax return." People are just sloppy when discussing some subject because you know what they mean.

43

and, to the extent it is called paying taxes accurately, it's because when withholding is insufficient to cover your tax bill (or inapplicable, as with capital gains) you do have to pay.

3
apawst8•

Also, some people don't get money taken out of their paychecks, so they do have to pay taxes on a regular (usually quarterly) basis.

7
s0v3r1gn•

You can do it yearly. It's just dangerous to wait that long due to how much you'll owe and making sure you've saved enough up to pay.

1
suugakusha•

Moreover, not everyone has taxes taken out immediately and do have to pay their taxes in April.

1
ThePrevailer•

It's not. I've never heard anyone call the process of competing their taxes "paying taxes." You file your taxes or you do your taxes.

13
Gnonthgol•

Your taxes are not taken away from your paycheck. The money from your paycheck to the IRS is only prepaid taxes. The amount you pay is an estimate on how much you will have to pay in taxes at the end of the year. The forms you are filling out is to find out how much you actually have to pay in taxes. Sometimes you have paid too little and sometimes you have paid too much. It is theoretically possible to not pay any tax from your paycheck and then get a giant bill from the IRS in the spring. Also if you get some giant investment return that would result in your taxes being much higher then normal you can pay the IRS while you have the money on hand instead of getting the bill at the end of the year.

12
Yancy_Farnesworth•

It is theoretically possible to not pay any tax from your paycheck and then get a giant bill from the IRS in the spring

Don't do this, you will get fined. Despite what people think, your taxes are actually due quarterly. Your tax return is due annually. If you constantly owe too much money every tax return you are assessed a fine for underpaying your quarterly taxes.

0
fubo•

Different activities. If someone says, "I object to paying taxes," they're probably a libertarian who believes in defunding the government. If someone says, "I object to filing taxes," they're probably a person with moderately complicated finances who doesn't understand how, in these days when employers and banks already have to report everydangthing to the government, the government can't just use that information to calculate my tax for me?

5
53bvo•

the government can't just use that information to calculate my tax for me?

This is what the government actually does in the Netherlands. They have an app where I can check all the information they have of me and where I can press next 10 times with my taxes calculated and done.

You can edit the information for additional stuff they don't know about, but for someone working salaried and paying rent (owning a house is a bit more complicated I think) it is just a matter of pressing next a few times.

2
TheNobleRobot•

People don't really say "paying my taxes" when referring to that, they usually say "doing my taxes."

5
cdb03b•

It is not called paying taxes. At least not commonly by anyone in the US. It is called filing taxes, filing your tax return, or doing taxes.

4

There are many people who have to write checks to the gov't for unreported income and non-tax-withheld income.

If you make a certain amount of money, it needs to be done quarterly in the US. Otherwise it can be done yearly.

3
Houston_Here•

Actually, you ideally want to end up paying taxes rather than receiving a return. Your tax isn't due until April the following year. Why would you want to loan the government money at 0% interest? You can make money with that cash before you have to fork it over to the government.

1
Yancy_Farnesworth•

Ideally you want to sit at 0. If you underpay too much and too frequently they asses a fine. Taxes are due quarterly, not annually.

1
J_Rock_TheShocker•

The people you may have heard say that probably know that they underpay their taxes, and will have to write a check after they file their taxes by the mid-April deadline.

3
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1