Tyler, all the good story games are PS4 Exclusives.

I'm sure you can invest into a PS4.

Heavy Rain (22 Endings)

Beyond: Two Souls (27 Endings)

Until Dawn (idk, can't find on internet)

All the story games you have played so far give you the illusion that your choices are relevant, when in reality they have a negligible (sometimes nonexistent) effect on the story (Ex. The Walking Dead, Life Is Strange). They're obviously still very good games and entertaining for the stream, but if you want a true experience that is your own, play any of the games listed above.