How many kilometers/miles/seasons do you get out of studded winter tires? How to fix cracked casing?

After two slow flats and real flat i took the time to find the hole in my tube, and it lines up with this crack in the casing behind a stud. None of the other studs appear to be wearing through. I've been riding on them for 3 seasons, less than 1000km/season. My previous pair of studded tires failed in a similar way and I mitigated the issue by adding a sacrificial tube to my wheel.

Is this normal wear?

How have you fixed similar issues? Sacrificial tube? Patch the casing?

Some other winter bilking trick?

Posted Feb 17, 2017, 7:22 PM UTC

79
LukeWarmCage•

You can use a proper rubber tire boot, which is thicker than a tube patch, behind the stud and over the hole, but I can imagine the stud concentrates enough force so even that won't last. If that pessimism proves true you can extract the stud to reduce the stress over the booted hole.

3
Hagenaar•

I think that's good advice and you could reverse the order of those actions for best results. One missing stud won't affect much.

3
flimbs•

Exactly the same thing happened to me a few weeks ago. Two slow flats, and I only bothered to look closer on the 2nd one, to find some bad punctures from the studs.

I was lucky enough that the store I bought it from allowed a refund, as I only had it for three months.

3
liquidfuryOP•

Interesting, looks like a very similar failure, my tires are Kenda Klondike, and that flat was on the rear. I installed a new tube with a sacrificial tube wrapped around it.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
anonanon1313•

10-15 years on my Nokians, no idea on the mileage, but 1,000's.

2
fclbr•

I have had the same issue with two pairs of nokian tyres. I find it strange because I have always used the correct pressure, and I don't think I put more than 5000 km on either pair. I still had much life left in both the rubber and the studs, so it was annoying that the studs wore through the casing... However, both pairs were second hand, so someone before me might have fucked with them. I have not yet seen the same issue with my schwalbe tyres.

2
tdreyer1•

I've had a couple pairs of Schwalbe Marathon Winters, so far they've lasted over 5 years, ~4000mi/6500km until the studs wear/rust enough that I feel like a getting a new pair. No issues with cracking or studs wearing through the casing yet.

2
Cmdr_Vortexian•

After around 3500-4500 km, Schwalbe Ice Spiker Pro (rear and front respectively) start to lose the studs at an enormous rate. The rear tire started developing a helical sidewall rip at around 4000 km.

 

The Nokian Hakka tires (folding version) I currently ride are still OK after 4300 km, though the central rows of studs on the rear one lost all their sharpness. The Stud retention and below-minus10-centigrade performance is definitely better with Nokians due to a better rubber compound and stud holes design, but Schwalbe studs remain sharp for a longer period of time.

 

BTW, I am a 250-pounder and the weight has a great impact on the tires' lifespan. A 140-pounder's tires would last 1.5-2 times longer. Nokians hold me at around 70/80% of the maximum inflation pressure front/rear and with Schawlbes I go as far as 80/100-105% respectively. With wider rims (I use narrow 19mm ones) you can shed another 10-15% of pressure for the same load.

 

Main causes of the damage: severe overinflation leads to the studs being forced into the tire (like in the liquidfury's post) and riding long distances with low pressure leads to a helilcal sidewall rip (the tire sidewall appears to be covered in regular diagonal stripes of a lighter color due to the rubber delamination and after some time the sidewall just rips along one of them).

2
liquidfuryOP•

Interesting about the pressure, I might have to try lowering the pressure, I am also 250lbs and running at max pressure.

1