Let's talk email providers...

NSFWSecurity & Tools Discussion

I noticed grams have switched to cock.li as their email provider now sigaint is down.

I did a little digging and the dude (cockman) seems to be transparent and competent despite playing the role of being a cock. He kinda reminds me of myself 10 years ago.

He has full disclosure of all subpoenas and also publishes his replies. He has a warrant canary up.

He is also refreshingly honest about the fact your emails could be read by the server admin or intercepted by LE along the way so you need to PGP everything. This was true of sigaint/lelantos too although they weren't explicit about it.

He has had his servers seized in the past and LE knows where to find him so that could happen again. He apparently has a remote backup system in place which would preserve our data and allow him to continue the service if that happened. If we are PGPing everything that doesn't really matter though?

He has imap/pop/smtp open so you don't have to fuck with webmail.

The only alternatives (mail2tor and torbox) have issues with clearnet->tor emails at times. Although that's not a big issue if you're communicating with other people on the same service, it does limit their usability in services outside the darknet somewhat.

So what do people think? Yay or nay?

I'm thinking yay.

Oh and thoughts on lavabit reloaded? Riseup's new warrant canary? Protonmail? Or fuck it how about clearnet services in hard to subpoena countries like yandex? They are like the Russian google, allow tor connections to their imap servers, are extremely reliable and not blacklisted anywhere... I use yandex addresses where a tor address would look sketchy (exchanges etc).

Posted Feb 18, 2017, 11:51 AM UTC

1124
pinochetHA•

You should assume any email provider is spying on you and handing over everything they can to law enforcement, because unless you are your own mail provider you can't know otherwise. Too many people who contact me don't care about gpg and make noob mistakes. If Sigaint was leaking or corrupt (I do not think he was) their mail is no longer private.

Cock.li seems like a solid guy but is not anonymous. He will comply with warrants, which sigaint refused to do. If you aren't doing anything bad and use encryption that doesn't matter. Personally if I had to choose I would pick a mail provider who either wouldn't comply or would use a legal team to slow down compliance and not be intimidated.

Edit: Also some default encryption which makes it difficult to read your mail is nice, not because it will actually prevent them from reading your mail if they really want to, but because it gives them plausible deniability if questioned about the content. Protonmail I think offers this.

5
shillfaceOP•

So what do you use? :)

3
pinochetHA•

A service run by a friend. It's not open to the public but may be in the future.

1
entrippy11•

Run your own mail server. Using hosted email is like using Coinbase for your main wallet.

-1
NetscapeNavGold[Fresh Account]•

Definitely assume they are, I was working for an internet security company/ISP and your jaw would drop on the amount of info that they spy on you with. I had access to clients complete e-mails (a popular virus scanner is collecting your e-mail via outlook when it scanned etc). Had complete list of all the users hardware in real-time (possibly even more information on what they did online and services running on their PC's in one place then they would have on their own in front of them).

What I can tell you is NEVER use Windows 10 and be very careful of your virus scanner, cause that free scanner is making tons of money on your data. If you're careful enough I would refrain from running a virus scanner at all and just install it once in a while to make sure you're clean (if your on Win7).

You are best off using OSX and Linux, anyone running those OS's were exempt from our tracking software and we could only monitor traffic transferring from the ISP.

3
lordredvampire•

indeed... there's a stripped down version of Windows 10 from Blackbox or DWT himself - that's ideal for entertainment purpose only. You could use PS4/XBOX for that matter.. either way.

1
NetscapeNavGold[Fresh Account]•

The faster everyone gets off of windows the better off we will be as a whole. But unfortunately I sense that with Google's new Fushia OS around the corner there is going to be a fight till the death for the king of desktop OS's. Sad thing is no matter who wins they are going to spy on you so hard and no one is going to fight for their rights and just say "I don't care, I have nothing to hide".

The user agreement you agree to when you install Windows 10 [Privacy Agreement]. This gives Microsoft full access to the following which they state in the document they share with LE:

"your name, email address, preferences and interests; location, browsing, search and file history; phone call and SMS data; device configuration and sensor data; voice, text and writing input; and application usage"

They record your voice to text and phone call audio. Also which documents/applications you currently have open and for how long.

"when you input text, handwrite notes, or ink comments, we may collect samples of your input " -This basically means they are running a keylogger and can record everything you type, even if it's not posted online anywhere. Which means what you type on your keyboard even on tor is accessible by Microsoft.

"your computing environment such as IP address, network status, operating conditions and information about devices and software used with the Program software and services. "

"include information about performance and reliability, such as how quickly the software and services respond when you click a button or how many problems you experience with a given software or service. Experience Data may also include information about your use of software and services, such as the features used most often or how frequently you launch programs... Including 3rd party applications"

Yep they can monitor that you launched TOR, for how long, what you typed in with your keyboard and where on your screen you are clicking with your mouse... all while on TOR.

"We may share or disclose information about you with other Microsoft controlled subsidiaries and affiliates, and with vendors or agents working on our behalf. "

That is how my former company was receiving a portion of their data, via Microsoft Windows 10 users.

*"We may also access, disclose and preserve information about you when we have a good faith belief that doing so is necessary to:

comply with applicable law or respond to valid legal process from competent authorities, including from law enforcement or other government agencies; "*

Yep, get off Win10 ASAP, it makes me sick to my stomach that I could read everyone's e-mails and they were none the wiser.

2
lordredvampire•

As I have previously stated.. blackbird (not blackbox, sorry) and DWT took care of it. They have their own stripped version of Windows 10 disabling telemetry and other tracking features.

Looks ok to me. I only use Win 10 for gaming.

1
alt_DNM_helpful•

yandex works with icedove and is based out of Russia

protonmail is OK, however, I wouldn't really trust the location of their servers as much.

There are other Russian options as well if you do some digging.

3
lordredvampire•

Protonmail offer their service via TOR.

2
shillfaceOP•

Is your other alt so unhelpful you had to explicitly make this one? haha

1
alt_DNM_helpful•

No, my other one is reviews.

1
username3522 •

The owner is quite a funny guy:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pbJ5So_liOE

1
lordredvampire•

Protonmail will do nicely, they also offer service via TOR.

1
apoefjmqdsfls•

Protonmail requires javascript..

1
lordredvampire•

Yeah, so does reddit.

1
apoefjmqdsfls•

You can use reddit without javascript.

1
lordredvampire•

Sure, but it impairs your user experience. Secondly, in order to see the post, you must enable Javascript otherwise you will only see the title.

1
lordredvampire•

Any definite speculation on what happened to sigaint?

1
Azztoomouth •

A man who tried to use the honeytrap "Besa Mafia Hitman" website just got arrested for murdering his wife and staging her suicide. Man arrested for killing his wife: http://www.startribune.com/cottage-grove-man-charged-in-wife-s-murder/411079495/ besa@sigaint was this supposed hitman email.

I just posted this on another thread new theory on Sigaint:

<----- Begin Conspiracy -----> Goes back to 70 bad exit nodes. Positively LE funding to pull something like that off or even have a reason to.

Also goes Besa mafia. This "fake hitman website" that sounded corny and suspiciously "leaked" customer lists & just happened to use Sigaint for it. Did they REALLY get hacked? Or was that just more evidence to further warrants?

Quite possible unknown LE could have set up Besa Mafia website as way of a honeytrap. All may have started as a plan to go after sigaint for the cruel front page msg about "Making 3 letter agencies cry."

What "scam artist" would use arson on a vehicle just to prove the legitamacy of a fake hitman website? Would it not make more sense for LE to just use a car from forfeiture in order to further such a deep cover "criminal" case? It starts to make a lot of sense.

A honeypot so great in trapping it was able to gather warrants for sigaint and conveniently accounts just by design alone. Using [email protected] as their email was part of the plan. The twist is this honeypot may illegally never be revealed in court. Target was sigaint. The mission accomplished :'( R.I.P Sigaint

</-----End of conspiracy---->

Besa Mafia website oddly posts dedication pictures multiple times of a fire burning 2 cars as "proof" there are hitmen while identifying the validity of being a "besa gangmember"; oddly customer hit proposals/information was "hacked" then publicly "leaked" (how convenient, honeypot likely): https://allthingsvice.com/2016/05/14/the-curious-case-of-besa-mafia/

1
AutoModerator•

Please always verify e-mails via Grams InfoDesk and also always encrypt your info with the vendors PGP-key.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1
AutoModeratorMOD•

Please always verify e-mails via Grams InfoDesk and also always encrypt your info with the vendors PGP-key.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1
lordredvampire•

Noted. Again, this is only just a conspiracy unless other facts are presented to support your conspiracy. Unless if you feel strong with great omniscience of yours then I understand :p.

Again, like everyone said, USE PGP! If besa used PGP.. (unless if he/she was communicating to LE operative via sigaint using PGP then this scenario is pretty much useless).

It's hard to determine if that person is LE or not. In this case, TRUST NO ONE!

EDIT: I read the link via allthingsvice and it didn't mention of possibility of LE involvement, just scams.

1