r/Physics•
uzbyte

Does measuring momentum or position of a bound particle change energy expectation values?

Question

I'm having trouble understanding the relevance of expectation values in some contexts. Say you have a bound quantum mechanical particle and you measure its position or momentum, will the act of measurement alter the expectation value of the energy permanently?

When looking at energy expectation value I'd think that it would be altered during measurement (would increase because you're adding energy to measure say, the momentum)--but after you're finished measuring the energy expectation value would return to whatever it was originally. Is this correct?

Posted Feb 20, 2017, 1:42 AM UTC

23
rantonelsString theory•

If you perform a "normal" measurement of P you will change the energy. (It will not 'go back to normal' as you expect). That's ok, the energy is necessarily supplied/taken by the measurement apparatus as it measures P.

2
hachacha•

Before measurement, a quantum system will exist in a state of superposition across all allowable states, in accord with the wave function. Taking a classical "measurement" will destroy that superposition of states, and the so called 'expectation values' will be obtained according to the square of the wave function. Yes the measurement will "add energy to the system" but we're physics persons and we can quantify that and subtract out that effect, and if we're painstaking about it we will obtain a result which will approach the quantum mechanical expectation values.

There's an ideal measurement scheme created by Von Neumann which couples the quantum system to another quantum system, thereby removing all externalities, and the result will be the original probability density. This scheme is very much worthy of investigation, since a lot of people want to focus on the "answers" from quantum theory without ever asking how they obtain those answers. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Measurement_in_quantum_mechanics

1
HelperBot_•

Non-Mobile link: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Measurement_in_quantum_mechanics


^HelperBot ^v1.1 ^/r/HelperBot_ ^I ^am ^a ^bot. ^Please ^message ^/u/swim1929 ^with ^any ^feedback ^and/or ^hate. ^Counter: ^33815

2