Nuts/Air vs Bluffcatchers

High (420) strat yo

Please tell me I'm not going crazy. in equilibrium, EV of nuts/air is always pot and EV of bluffcatcher is 0 right? I understand this scenario doesn't often happen in poker unless you're really bad and somehow arrive on river with a completely capped range....but...for the sake of being thorough...

Some pro is telling me that my bet sizing in these scenarios needs to be balanced in proportion to my value/bluffs combos and I'm like nah bro, that's not true, and he insists that is. For example, if I have 3 value and 1 bluff, he says I need to bet 1/2 pot and his MDF is 2/3. I'm like but I can also bet 2x pot with all my combos and that's still gto yo. And he says but your bet size can't be sustainable since you don't have enough bluffing combos for that size. And i'm like bro,you're capped and I can bet whatever size i want since your GTO action is to fold 100% and he was like nah you retarded bro.

WTF? I'm also high as fuck right now so I might actually be retarded but wtf?!?

If I bet 2x pot, he has to defend 1-(2/(1+2)) or 1/3 of combos. obviously this is losing since this is <0EV (Because I don't have enough bluff combos) so his gto solution is obviously fold 100% which is 0EV If i bet 1/2 pot, he has to defend 1-(0.5/(1+0.5)) or 2/3 of combos to makemy bluffs 0EV. he thinks this is gto lol. BUT HE'S CAPPED.

I can easily exploit this with my own strat. I bet 2x pot with 1 combo of value and 1 combo of bluffs. I then bet my remaining 2 combos of value for 1/2 pot. all of a sudden my expectation is >pot!!! And his expectation is <0EV. So clearly if his EV is <0 in thisscenario he can unilaterallly increase his expectation to 0 by just folding everything. I thought this was common knowledge that in equilibrium the gto EV was:

EV(polar range) = pot (420) EV(Bluffcatcher) = 0

I really shouldn't press submit butfuck it

Posted Feb 23, 2017, 10:53 AM UTC · edited

4176
Franklol•

Sorry. Its too early to smoke. Cant get the same level as you.

22
DepolarizingOPLive 500NL/1KNL•

havent' slept yet lol

9
Nandonis•

Think your biggest mistake is to think that anyone on reddit can help you regarding anything GTO.

18
DepolarizingOPLive 500NL/1KNL•

i posted for the lulz and because I know i'm rightlol

EDIT: and cuz of 420

7
LolPhariseesPIO Solver reupholstered my pussy•

You're actually right (essentially) and everyone else is in this thread + your live poker location is wrong / a donk.

12
stephen1745100nl/200nl•

He knew he was right going in lawl

1
DepolarizingOPLive 500NL/1KNL•

it was a nice b8 m8

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Douger91•

dont care if i look like an idiot, this is driving me crazy....what does MDF stand for?

7
roscosBack to back bar poker champion•

minimum defense frequency

3
Douger91•

duh

3
CRAIBaby•

high how are you?

4
DepolarizingOPLive 500NL/1KNL•

coming down, but I'm still correct right?

4
CRAIBaby•

didnt finish whole read but till about half : nope

2
DepolarizingOPLive 500NL/1KNL•

What part is wrong?

3
CRAIBaby•

For example, if I have 3 value and 1 bluff, he says I need to bet 1/2 pot and his MDF is 2/3. I'm like but I can also bet 2x pot with all my combos and that's still gto yo. And he says but your bet size can't be sustainable since you don't have enough bluffing combos for that size. And i'm like bro,you're capped and I can bet whatever size i want since your GTO action is to fold 100% and he was like nah you retarded bro.

this for example

1
JOHANSENATOR68o Is Premium•

if I'm understanding correctly... the simplified problem here is, you want to bet 2x the pot on the river really often & you don't want to get shit about it

3
DepolarizingOPLive 500NL/1KNL•

ye all in shoves pls

1
Mikestar24•

If i bet 1/2 pot, he has to defend 1-(0.5/(1+0.5)) or 2/3 of combos to makemy bluffs 0EV. he thinks this is gto lol. BUT HE'S CAPPED.

His explanation of GTO is correct, but you are working under different assumptions. The mdf (67% of his range) needs to be able to achieve at least 25% equity in this scenario, or GTO doesn't apply. There is no way to avoid being exploited if you simply cannot achieve the required equity with your mdf. The solution is to tighten the preflop range until your mdf is strong enough to do so, so definitely not just a capped range that is losing to 75% of your range.

A more realistic scenario would be that villain has tightened up, and now has something like 50% value hands, 25% bluff catchers and 25% rags. Now he is defending with the top 33% of his range (strong value hands) and is playing GTO.

2
DepolarizingOPLive 500NL/1KNL•

Yes i realize my example doesn't directly correlate to actual poker but it was a common toy game example that I thought was common knowledge. It would be a disaster if you arrived on a river with 0 value combos.

My argument is that our ratio doesn't really apply in this situation. Our highest EV expectation with two players playing perfectly in this scenario is pot and 0. When we bet a size "sustainable" by our range, we make our opponent's bluff catcher's indifferent between calling or folding so it "doesn't matter". The EV(call) + EV(fold) = 0 in that case.

How this argument stemmed was that I was arguing that we are making an exploitative mistake in live poker by betting small when our opponent's ranges are insanely capped (which happensmore often that online poker). Because the expectation of 2x pot or jamming is still pot and 0, we are in fact not deviatin from GTO. Overbetting in these scenarios is still GTO. However, if Villain ever calls he's making a MASSIVE mistake and we earn more value than had we bet smaller.

1
iluri•

You want to bet as often as possible in nuts/air vs BC. (So all the value hands and as much bluffs as possible)

Say your range is 15 value hands and 10 air and opp has a bluff catcher. (edit: yes this math is off mb)

If u bet 1/2 pot u get to bet 15 value and 5 bluffs = EV of ur range is 20x pot.

If u bet pot u get to bet 15 value and 7,5 value = EV of range 22,5x pot

If u bet 2x pot u get to bet 15 value and all ur air (10) = EV of range = 25x pot

So GTO for you is to bet anything over 2x pot, and this is equilibrium. Neither of you can adjust to increase ur EV.

The way for you to increase your EV without adding more value hands(hard to do for obvious reasons) is to arrive in this spot with more bluffs. If you have 11 air instead of 10, u can bet a little bit bigger sizing and the EV of ur range becomes 26x pot instead. This is why having bluffs is +EV in theory even though your bluffs only seem to be 0EV.

You probably know all this, but i feel like its a really really underappreciated thing in poker. Even Dan Polk talked about it in a video recently.

So regarding this

How this argument stemmed was that I was arguing that we are making an exploitative mistake in live poker by betting small when our opponent's ranges are insanely capped

Yes, youre right, by betting bigger u get to bet more bluffs and win pot more often.

I can easily exploit this with my own strat. I bet 2x pot with 1 combo of value and 1 combo of bluffs. I then bet my remaining 2 combos of value for 1/2 pot. all of a sudden my expectation is >pot!!! And his expectation is <0EV.

If youre already betting all your bluffs, betting ur "excessive" value hands doesnt add EV since you already win the pot with those hands.

1
DepolarizingOPLive 500NL/1KNL•

I think your math and EV calculations are wrong, as well as your equilibrium, but I think what you are saying is correct. An important distinction though is that if we arrive on river with a lot of bluff combos, the actual bluffs themselves are not what makes betting large higher EV.

10 combos of value and 10 combos of bluffs for EZ numbers.

Case 1: We bet full pot. MDF says villain should call 50% to make our Bluffs 0EV. So with our nuts, we win the pot half the time and 2x pot the other half. Our bluffs net us exactly 0x pot. We aregiving him 2:1 so we should be bluffing with five combos ofbluffs to remain balanced. Because we are indifferent to bluffing or chefcking the EV of both =0, so we get the equation

EV = 0.5(0.5 * 1+0.5 * 2) +0 = 0.75pot.

Case2: We bet 2x pot. mdf says villan should call 1/3 of the time to make our bluffs 0ev. WIth our nuts we win the pot 2/3 of the time and 3x pot 1/3 of the time. Again, the EV of our bluffs has been reduced to 0. We are giving our villain 3:2 so we should bluff with 6.6 combos of bluffs. With the same equation of eV(bluff) = EV(check) we get

EV = 0.5(0.66 * 1 + 0.33 * 3) + 0 = 0.83 pot.

We bluffed more in scenario 2, but our EV of our bluffs is still 0. Being able to bluff more did not increase our EV, but villain has to put in more money on average in order to reduce our bluffs to 0.

I think we are saying the same thing, but I can't tell, so I just decided to post with the accurate math.

4
iluri•

I tried to make my math as simple as possible, guess i just explained it bad. I think its still right tho, since I get the same results as u by converting the numbers to yours. Anyway doesnt matter were on the same page

An important distinction though is that if we arrive on river with a lot of bluff combos, the actual bluffs themselves are not what makes betting large higher EV....Being able to bluff more did not increase our EV, but villain has to put in more money on average in order to reduce our bluffs to 0.

Doesnt matter how much villain calls.

Range with 100 nuts and 50 air is worth more than 100 nuts and 10 air. Do we agree on that?

So having enough air is +EV, even though the bluffs themselves are 0EV if opp is calling mdf.

1

3x pot - @MDF/SB Nash equilibrium 8x PSB

IF PTL has TPTK UTG your VPIP should 2% less than your PFR% when his 3BET range from EP is > 23.5%

My advice play ATC and B/C any river shove 2x pot

2
sabicoff•

seconded. Should be higher up.

1
blackburn009•

If you have 3 nuttish combos and 1 bluff combo why would you ever want him to fold all his hands? You lose all the possible value to protect the relatively small amounts of bluffs

If you bet 1/2 pot with the 2 value hands and 2x pot with the other 2 you break even with your 2x hands and you win money on 1/2 pot maybe unless they realise you have no bluffs.

Bet pot with all 4 of your hands and he calls off all 4 and now you've got some good +EV going on

2
Spreek•

Because in GTO, we assume that our opponent is playing with full knowledge of our strategy/range.

If you bet anything above half pot, your opponents best response is fold his whole range because he only has 25% equity.

In fact, with the assumptions of GTO, the best possible outcome is them folding 100% (or equivalently being indifferent to calling or folding) as you will never get a perfect opponent to make a -EV call.

Now, obviously this is probably not the maximally exploitative strategy vs real opponents, but that's not what we are discussing.

3
SillyROI•

Bravo.

1
DepolarizingOPLive 500NL/1KNL•

but what about the actual poker stuffs?!?!

1
TStTrader•

How do you get to this spot with that many value combos and still have a 2:1 SPR? With a polarized range you should be closer to one psb at the river assuming 100bb starting stack, and if his best play is to never call 2x psb, then you miss on value. conversely you get less when you bet the river for 1/2 pot.

1
troytorres•

fold pre

1
Merrycatch22Oh baby, a Trips!•

when you bet 2x I call with all catchers when you bet 1/2 I fold all catchers

your expectation is 0.5*(0.5* 3p-0.5*-2p)+0.5p=0.75p

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
Merrycatch22Oh baby, a Trips!•

I bet 2x pot with 1 combo of value and 1 combo of bluffs. I then bet my remaining 2 combos of value for 1/2 pot

He has 4 combos. When he bets 2x pot half of the time, I call with all of my catchers. He wins 3x pot 50% of time when I call and he has his 1 combo of value, and wins -2x pot 50% of the time when I call and he has is 1 combo of bluff.

When he bets 1/2 pot, which happens half the time, I fold everything, and he wins pot.

He expects to win 0.5(0.5 x 3p - 0.5 x -2p)+.5p=.75p

1
DepolarizingOPLive 500NL/1KNL•

I never said that strategy was GTO. I used that as an argument as to why simply defending MDF isnot gto vs 1/2 sizing.

Here's the rough proof:

  1. We can hopefully agree that in order for a strategy to be GTO, there is nothing your opponent can do to reduce your EV. In other words your villain can never exploit your strat.

  2. Your response to me betting 100% of my 3 combos of value and 1 combo of bluffs for 1/2 pot is to defend MDF or 66%. In this case, the EV is 0 for the Bluffcatcher and pot sized for me.

  3. Your response to me betting 2x pot with 100% ofmy combos is to fold everything, yielding the same EV for both sides.

  4. However, I can introduce a new strategy to exploit your 66% call (leavingme open to counterexploitation). By only betting the 2x pot size with 1 combo of value and 1combo of bluffs, and choosing the 1/2 pot sizing with my other 2 value combos, your EV becomes negative as you are always folding to my bluffs and my value gets paid part of the time. You point out a counterexploitation to thisnew strategy, and it is valid. However, that was never the point (sorry if I didn't explain this well enough in the post). My point with this new strategy is that if defending 66% was a GTO strategy to a 1/2 pot bet, my exploitation would not be possible.

As it stands, in pure polar vs bluffcatcher situations (which really rarely happen in actual poker unless you are bad), the only unexploitable play by the bluffcatcher is to fold 100% and this is mathematical fact. Further, since betting larger sizes when I can only have the nuts and you are capped is mathematically unexploitable (EVis still potand 0), betting large is definitely a GTO solution.

Exploitatively speaking betting smaller is also wrong because vs an optimal opponent, the EV is exactly the same as betting larger. However, vs a suboptimal opponent the EV cost of mistakes to a larger size is massive compared to the EV cost of mistakes to smaller sizings.

EDIT: some numbermistakes

EDIT2: I guess what alot of people fail to understand is that defending MDF only reduces the EV of my bluffs to 0, not my entire range.

2
Merrycatch22Oh baby, a Trips!•

why do we strive to defend MDF anyhow? If we play with someone enough shouldn't we exploit them by not playing MDF and maximally exploiting them the best we can?

1
LolPhariseesPIO Solver reupholstered my pussy•

oh yeah my bad I didn't see that. obviously betting 2 pot with 50% bluffs is awful.

1
DepolarizingOPLive 500NL/1KNL•

I was using that strategy to show why defending MDF vs half pot in this scenario is not GTO because I can use this strategy to make your previous strategy -EV and not neutral. Obviously this opens me up to counterexploitation, but because there exists a strategy that can exploit his MDF defense, it cannot be GTO. GTO is literally to just fold everything.

1
Mylos•

It depends how many combos of value and bluffs you have. If you have 1 billion bluffs and 1 value combo and bet 100x pot, he can still call you with his whole range. If you have 1 billion value combos and 1 bluff, the minimum bet still doesn't give him odds to call so he can fold his whole range.

You're thinking about this situation incorrectly because you're not taking into account the number of times you have value vs bluffs. All gto means is that neither player can deviate to increase their EV, meaning if you have 0 bluffs in a spot, he folds 100% regardless of bet sizing and that is gto because he can't increase the amount he wins and neither can you. A lot of people make calling mistakes here which is where we make our money

1
DatGrag•

It depends how many combos of value and bluffs you have. If you have 1 billion bluffs and 1 value combo and bet 100x pot, he can still call you with his whole range. If you have 1 billion value combos and 1 bluff, the minimum bet still doesn't give him odds to call so he can fold his whole range.

But OP is talking about GTO, which doesn't care how many combos of bluffs/value your opponent actually has in reality. You're talking about exploitative math-based play.

1
Mylos•

Incorrect gto definitely cares about how many combos you have in certain situations. Gto is a maximally exploitative strategy against an opponent's maximally exploitative strategy. Combos matter which is why gto play calls with backdoor flush draws and the like on the flop so that it has good board coverage on the river and a balanced frequency of bluffs to value

0
DatGrag•

Gto is a maximally exploitative strategy

wow this is completely contrary to everything I've ever learned about GTO.

I said GTO doesn't care about what your opponent is doing, it's all about focusing on your own ranges.

Nothing in your explanation involved GTO caring about your opponents strategy whatsoever. Thats the point of GTO, it doesnt change and can't be beaten by any strategy, it doesn't care what it's opponent is doing.

0
Mylos•

This is true assuming the game was solved and everyone got to the river with the same frequencies in the same spots. But we care about our opponents ranges because 6 max is an asymmetrical game. Our ranges are not exactly the same as our opponents and our distributions differ. For example say preflop our opponent gets dealt AA every hand and shoves. We don't just care about our own ranges here and gto play is 0bb/100 against this range because we just fold

1
roscosBack to back bar poker champion•

isnt the goal to be able to bet river as often as possible? If you are overbetting and villain always folds ev=pot. That does not mean that is the best size to go with as you may be able to bet a different size more often with ev=pot.

1
darkmage3632•

by definition 'gto' is just an equilibrium where neither player can adjust their strategy to increase their expectation

in a nuts/air vs bluffcatcher spot the bluffcatcher is indifferent to calling/folding (0ev). if the nuts/air range uses a larger sizing and doesn't have enough bluffs they could possibly have then the bluffcatcher isn't able to adjust his strategy to increase his expectation, as overfolding will still result in an expectation of 0. However, it gives him the opportunity to make a mistake by calling too frequently in a spot where nuts/air is weighted towards value. basically freerolling the bluffcatcher.

1
Palendrome•

Poker is dead.

1
iluri•

why is poker dead?

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
IncendiaryGames•

Bet based on the color of your cards - All reds? 1/2 pot. All black? 2x pot. Mixed? Fold that shit.

There you can't be exploited as it will be random what you do.

1
DepolarizingOPLive 500NL/1KNL•

lol, any bet size > 0.5 pot is unexploitable and GTO

1
IncendiaryGames•

I'd love to play in the games your playing then. I'll sit back set mining you in position and take your stacks when you bet over 0.5 pot. Making a pot sized bet means your opponent only needs 1/3 or greater pot + implied odds to continue. If you're in position and can close the action by calling then these are the number of raw outs you need before even thinking about implied odds bonuses for when your opponent makes a bet proportional to the pot:

pot raise - call with 8+ outs
2/3 pot raise - call with 7+ outs
1/2 pot raise - call with 6+ outs
1/3 pot raise - call with 5+ outs

That doesn't even need to take into account his or her range, fold equity, MDF, or anything else, so a 1/2 pot, 2/3 pot, and pot raise definitely is exploitable and not necessarily GTO.

1
DepolarizingOPLive 500NL/1KNL•

this is a river scenario where you have only bluff catchers and I am polarized...

1
IncendiaryGames•

river

Ah I missed that in the first post. It wasn't really clear to me at all. I thought you were needing help with flop turn and river play.

The math is simple then in that case. It boils down to the frequency your opponent is bluffing. If hes bluffing 50.0001% or more its always +EV to call, now whether you call or not depends how far past 50% hes bluffing and the volatility your bankroll can handle. Honestly it seems like its a pretty bad situation to let a bluffer go to the river in the first place.

1
shai251•

While you are right in theory, I would bet something a little bigger than 1/2 such as 2/3 pot in order to induce a call (since a call is losing against your range). Since all bets larger than 1/2 pot are the same GTO wise, you should bet one where he is likely to make a mistake and call.

0
DepolarizingOPLive 500NL/1KNL•

I agree, and this was my argument vs the pro. In equilibrium, the EV of betting larger vs betting smaller is completely the same. Exploitatively speaking, we are making a huge mistake betting smaller and not for the larger sizing as the EV cost of our opponent making a mistake and calling is massive.

2
darkmage3632•

yeah any large sizing is a dominant strategy (though a massive sizing isn't dominant to a slightly smaller size) to a balanced size and this thread is a shitshow gj

1