r/wargame•
Toddsci

Why a WW2 WG title doesn't have to suck

  1. Time period, I think instead of just getting WW2 we're going to get something broader, possibly up to 1935-1955 time period. Maybe stuff that is prototyped in 1945 is regular avaliability in 1950.

  2. What makes WG great isn't the time period, the reason most people love WG isn't just that it's cold war, it's that there is a fundamental grounding in reality, stuff like armor penetration, ammo limits, the way LOS works. For me at the least the reason I fell in love with this game is that stuff that I logically expect to happen actually happens, vehicles have different armor at different angles, autocannons might not penetrate tank armor but they stun them up, accurecy works the way you would think it does (as opposed to a flat statistic), there's no cheesy "x unit gets a bonus against y unit", it occurs naturally via the game mechanics.'

  3. Diversity of unit, a lot of the current roster are slight variants of other units, especially in terms of linear upgrades (ie. the abrams series), I don't see why that wouldn't apply to a WW2 setting.

  4. Unit types, yes I admit we lose helicopters completely, but in all other tabs we should have similar stuff, plenty of infantry, admitedly a little less variety in transports, tanks existed, we could have a diverse range of artillery both self propelled and non self propelled, the vehicle tab should also have plenty of stuff in terms of AT and infantry support, air tab of course can easily be well stocked.

I think there's a lot of opportunity to make something newer and cooler. An expansion of infantry mechanics, perhaps with more infantry mortars, having MG as teams unto themselves (organisational it's true). We could see fortifications included in the game, that sort of deep planning of using well placed emplacements to prevent the enemy encircling you if they breakthrough the line.

Honestly the cold war setting can get a bit old sometimes, look at what CoD did recently (last 3 years or so) to change up the setting while still keeping the core gameplay mechanics.

Posted Mar 1, 2017, 9:30 AM UTC

1214
DannyJLloyd•
  1. It's called Invasion 1944 or something. Seriously doubt we'll get into the 1950s, there was a significant leap in technology and thinking after the nuclear bombs, so nah.
  2. Wargame really isn't realistic. Ammo is probably the only example you have there. The LOS is shockingly bad, And armour penetration is even worse represented too.
  3. The unit variation of 1930-1945 for a small number of nations will be significantly worse than 1950-1995 for however many nations RD has.
  4. No IFVs, ATGM, very few missiles of any kind. Towed and articulated stuff should be fun, as will the plane selection to be honest, I like the idea of rocket planes and dive bombers etc. However, infantry mechanics ought to be improved.
8
ArcticWinterZzZArtillery brings dignity to an otherwise ugly brawl•

Well, see, the thing is that it feels realistic. Stuff like the units being from real life and performing sort of like how they really do, and the excellent scale - how everything is fuckhueg.

7
DannyJLloyd•

Feels realistic just because it's a step above arcade. The scale is out of wack. Range for anything plane or ship related is far too small. ATGM ranges are generally too small. All the infantry ranges are far too high. It's like some weird logarithmic scale of range

7
changl09George's World /TO/ guy•

You are probably talking to some bum who has never played Blitzkrieg or Sudden Strike series.

3
changl09George's World /TO/ guy•

By everything you mean CoH and MoW, both btw are company level games?
That's like comparing T-34s and F-35s and trying to figure out which one is more efficient.

2
Jakerod_The_Wolf•

I find it to be the most realistic RTS I have ever played especially at this scale. Close Combat is the only other series that comes close which is part of the reason I'm not excited about WW2. I already have a good WW2 RTS.

6
liotierMahatma Gandhi•

Close Combat is the only other series that comes close

Then you need to try Combat Mission.

Too bad Combat Mission does not run on Linux... Or good thing actually - otherwise I would not have started playing Wargame with Airland Battle.

4
Foodstamp001ADATS Party•

CMBO, CMBB, and CMAK are by far the most realistic WW2 games I have played. It was also home to the only cancer free community I have ever seen in gaming.

3
liotierMahatma Gandhi•

I haven't had a chance to try multi-player - something I'm very frustrated about...

The small scale of CM battles would overjoy the "tactical" micro-managers who play low resources here... In Wargame I'm a very high resources player because I believe it to be more fitting to the nature of Wargame - but CM is perfect for what the Wargame "tactical" lobbies are trying to achieve.

1
Jakerod_The_Wolf•

oh thanks I forgot about that game

2
Einherjaren97•

Stell Division - Normandy 44 in fact, Just announced. Over 400 ww2 units and an improved wargame engine.

1
killincommies•

I would love infantry mortar teams

2
Kpenney•

It's about WW II. Knowing Eugen though- maybe it's the beginning of their Alternate history? Perhaps it's a prequel to EE. Or it's just a World War II game, picked because it's the one theatre of the genre that pulls non RTS players into RTS games to flop around with, Eugen knows this and wants to become a bigger company, Paradox helps them and identifies that theres a lot of Minor nations and minor additives during WW II- which justifies DLC's and therefor they picked said theatre and time frame. Again though with a name like Normandy '44 I suspect it's limited to specifically that area. I'd love to see Italian forces and a Sicilian theatre/campaign included, even as a DLC (yea, I'm not immune to pretty things), but that doesn't sound like it's going to happen. I feel though Eugen will create this product and it will be moderately successful, more so then the launch of Red Dragon. I feel it's going to bring more fans to the company that then ask and plead for Eugen to do more WWII stuff, and if Eugen grows well perhaps it can accommodate to both the Wargame community with another title and continue with this new Franchise. With the way they named it; Steel Division: Normandy '44 very much sounds like the first planned in a series. I don't see why we can't encourage Eugen to let us have our cake and eat it too, as in have two parallel franchises simply time lines apart. I almost feel that this community is just simply in fear that Eugen will never touch current weaponry or vehicles again in aims of developing a modern war RTS, which doesn't sound like a developer to me.

1
TheGoodTheBadTheRektGLORIOUS PEOPLE'S T-34-85, DESTROYER OF ABRAMS•

T28 Super Heavy Tank Eugen pls

1