Democratic "Unity" During Trump's Speech

SameSongDiffDay

What do you guys think of the way Democrats in congress chose to show "unity" during the speech? From what I can tell their dissent was conveyed in the following:

  • Congresswomen wearing white suits, as Hillary did when she accepted the Party's nomination at the Democratic Convention last July

  • Remaining seated throughout, even during talking points they may have personally agreed with

  • Coordinated walkout as soon as the speech ended

The consensus I've been seeing was that the speech was well received by the public and the Democrats behavior turned a lot of people off.

What I noticed which I found troubling, was Keith Ellison next to Debbie Wasserman Shultz looking very "buddy buddy". There's a saying that politics makes strange bedfellows, but he looked every bit a part of the establishment dems.

Another thing, once again Bernie had a good video response to Trump but he's ignored in favor of the establishment Dems elevating someone else to speak for them. It seems they're ok with him being a mouth piece but not wielding true power within their out of touch clique.

Anyway, thoughts?

Posted Mar 1, 2017, 2:25 PM UTC

1848
SA311NY Bernie Delegate•

Ellison is establishment. He was the best we could get from the establishment. Like, progressives were already compromising with the DNC by backing Ellison in the first place. Which is why it's a real smack in the face that they threw in Perez last minute. Couldnt even throw us the smallest of bones...It's insane

24
OneTwoWee000OP•

Couldnt even throw us the smallest of bones...It's insane

True! It's insulting how little the party elites care for Progressives.

Then after shoehorning Perez in, they say "this doesn't matter anyway! Perez and Ellison agree on 99% of the same policies!" -- Well, if who won chair didn't matter then why did Biden and Obama personally select Perez to "inherit" this role? Why not give it Keith?

They are such liars and it's more and more apparent. Nothing they did last night was noble. They acted like children.

13
penelopepnortneyPurity Unicorn•

"this doesn't matter anyway! Perez and Ellison agree on 99% of the same policies!"

Sounds amazingly like "this doesn't matter anyway! Clinton and Sanders agree on 99% of the same policies!"

Which is to say that BS has become the lingua franca of the Democratic Party.

11
OneTwoWee000OP•

Sad, but so true.. It's gaslighting, through and through.

4
IKissThisGuyMy purity pony name is SparkleMotionCensor•

BS has become the lingua franca of the Democratic Party

thoroughly dishonest, just like their owners, the Clintons

3
[deleted]•

It's insulting how little the party elites care for Progressives.

They are TRYING to insult us.

11
AnarchyInATX•

Because Perez is DWS II. He is obedient.

7
BlackhaloPurity pony!•

He is obedient.

So is Ellison. But Sanders had endorsed him. A message was sent. Perhaps they fear #DemEnter more than they let on, and WANT Sanders to break off? That way they can use the institutional bias in the many states vs. 3rd parties to keep the progressives marginalized?

3
BlackhaloPurity pony!•
2
RuffianGhostHorseOur Beating Heart 💜•

Let me get back here. edit: looks like it's not us.

edit: back, again. found this interesting.

2
RuffianGhostHorseOur Beating Heart 💜•

This got caught. Released. hmmmmm

2
BlackhaloPurity pony!•

Reported? I see that quite a few ess folks are on this thread. As well as S4P. They tend to be rather sensitive about criticism of the DNC.

3
RuffianGhostHorseOur Beating Heart 💜•

No. Not.

1
SuzyQ93•

I thought the Democrats looked incredibly petulant.

23
SA311NY Bernie Delegate•

That's their new shtick the past few years.

10
OneTwoWee000OP•

Yeah. I noticed Tulsi Gabbard wore a very light lilac blouse. Made me chuckle, thinking this was her small bit of rebellion from the party line.

I'm sure there's some establishment dems bitching about it.

5
BlackhaloPurity pony!•

But not so upset that they would consider a change to progressive policy...

5
LoneStarMike59•

They are being petulant. They just can't get over the fact that Hillary lost the election, but she won the popular vote!!

I watched a lot of news coverage leading up to the election, and there were hundreds of segments labeled "The Path to 270." I don't recall seeing even one news segment "The Path to the Popular Vote."

And yet they continue with their dismal cries about the popular vote, despite the fact that the system of electoral college votes has been in effect since 1787! If Hillary was too dumb to know that's how you win the presidency, then she had no business running in the first place.

She and her supporters are acting like two-year olds throwing a tantrum in the grocery store because mommie won't buy them candy.

5
gawbles•

Winning the popular vote is meaningless victory.

2
chakokatCupid Lollipop is my Purity Pony •

The very fact that the women wore white to stand in unity with Hillary turns my stomach. She's a two time loser for Christ's sake! Give it up already, people rejected her twice!

17
Rubyjane123•

White also signals surrender..

13
OneTwoWee000OP•

Haha! I doubt they appreciated the irony!

6
bluezenspurity pony name ~ rainbow jellybean•

this is what's wrong with the dp, in general. it's still listening to the failed ideas of the same "consultants" who advised them while the party lost over a thousand seats in state legislatures & governorships during the last decade, as well as the most recent general election, too--& no, winning the popular vote doesn't count as "winning"--just ask al gore.

funny, how quickly the d's changed their mind about the optics of wearing white:

CNN’s chief political correspondent Dana Bash told viewers that many Democrat women would be wearing white tonight -- “white [is] the color of the suffragette movement.”...[while] Just a few months ago, Philadelphia Inquirer fashion critic Elizabeth Wellington said just the opposite about white. She attacked Melania Trump for [wearing white at the inauguration and send]ing the terrifying message, “that in the G.O.P. white is always right.”

4
chakokatCupid Lollipop is my Purity Pony •

Philadelphia Inquirer fashion critic Elizabeth Wellington said just the opposite about white. She attacked Melania Trump for [wearing white at the inauguration and send]ing the terrifying message, “that in the G.O.P. white is always right.”

Do they think that people are so stupid as not to see the double standard and mean-spirited pettiness? People saw it when Republicans behaved in a mean-spirited way towards Obama and I believe that's one reason for his high "personal" favorability ratings even though they rejected Hillary running for a continuation of his policies.

3
bluezenspurity pony name ~ rainbow jellybean•

agree. only the most zealous of the party faithful believe nonsense like this. the anti-trump-media, tho, hopes that by repeating it ad nauseum, the truth will be forgotten.

3
DessaB•

Now now, it wouldn't be appropriate to have your "Chairman of Outreach" actually do any reaching out.

7
[deleted]•

What I noticed which I found troubling, was Keith Ellison next to Debbie Wasserman Shultz looking very "buddy buddy". There's a saying that politics makes strange bedfellows, but he looked every bit a part of the establishment dems.

I'm far more troubled by the perception among people here that Ellison and Perez were so different that the choice of one or the other was significant enough to determine whether the future lies with taking over the Democratic Party or creating a third party. Ellison was ALWAYS establishment and I've said so repeatedly.

6
655322•

The establishment thought there was enough difference or they would not have recruited Perez. But to be fair, Ellison is no Jill Stein, that's for sure.

11
quill65quill - AKA Sapphire Cherry •

Perez was mostly symbolic: "Fuck you Berniecrats, we won't even give you this meaningless chairmanship. Go away and die."

11
BlackhaloPurity pony!•

A message to the donors. "See, the progressives are not in charge." Send more money.

8
quill65quill - AKA Sapphire Cherry •

Ellison was ALWAYS establishment and I've said so repeatedly.

I agree, and I've also said so. But the sad fact is that even here where everyone knows viscerally how corrupt and toxic and unyieldingly hateful of progressivism the Democratic establishment is, there is still that abused spouse co-dependency thing that keeps lefties crawling back for more, vigorously denying that any other option (3rd party, etc) is possible. Frankly, it's looking more and more like the entire American left is suffering from a personality disorder and is in need of an intervention.

7
[deleted]•

there is still that abused spouse co-dependency thing that keeps lefties crawling back for more

See, you're framing it totally different than I would. If we were crawling back, it would entail sucking up to the establishment and begging, not raising an army and trampling them. And if you look at what happened in California, and to a lesser extent in a dozen other states, that's a trampling. We're not asking - we're taking ground.

You don't seem to be able to conceive of any way of acting inside the party that isn't bending the knee and begging for attention - nor do you seem to understand any way of gaining electoral power within the party that isn't granted to us by the establishment. Which frankly I find sad, gutless, and disgusting; don't you know how to fight, boy? Ain't you ever busted someone's lip?

vigorously denying that any other option (3rd party, etc) is possible

Just acknowledging the facts.

Suppose EVERYONE who voted for Bernie voted for a third party - and not just any third party, but the same third party.

You'd get about 10% of the votes.

That's not a winning strategy!

Not to mention that all those people wouldn't vote for a third party. The spoiler effect is VERY real in many people's minds, and they're all not as anti-Dem as most of us are. Who was it that tried to quote Gallup polls at me showing that 60% of Americans thought we needed a third party - yet last year, one of the worst election years in living memory, the Greens got what, 1% of the votes? With a candidate who ran four years ago!

People don't vote third party. They just don't.

No one has ever established a successful national third party in the past 150 years - and the last time anybody did, the existing parties were arguably even weaker than the Dems are now, and the barriers to entry were much lower.

We need votes to win. We need people to actually vote for us. We can get that if we take over the Dems. We can't get that if we go third party. It doesn't matter how hard it is to take over the Dems because that's how we win - not the other way.

Believe me, if I thought a third party had a real chance, a real chance, I would be all over that shit. (And then we could all fight over which third party... and boy howdy, if you think you're gonna say goodbye to the Dems and then it'll be brotherhood and smooth sailing, get ready for a vicious civil war over which party to back.) But we NEED voters, and 98% of the voters in this country will only vote for the duopoly.

8
BillToddTooPuttery Pony•

The fact that millions of normally Democratic voters chose to sit out the presidential election last November rather than vote for Stein (who with under 1% of the vote only slightly improved her 2012 showing) is a pretty good indication of just how thoroughly ingrained the 'spoiler' meme is even with Democrats and independent leaners who aren't fond of the party establishment.

6
[deleted]•

Can't upvote this enough. As if more evidence that people won't vote third party was needed - but here it is, anyway.

2
PeaceFeathers•

Frankly, it's looking more and more like the entire American left is suffering from a personality disorder and is in need of an intervention.

The primaries are going to be brutal on the "invasion" camp. They'll win pyrrhic victories only to be assimilated into the establishment's plans. Many will power through the cognitive dissonance and continue to rail against third parties and the opposition. Others may be so disheartened that they leave politics all together. A minority will exit the party and join the opposition. I guess you could say I'm pessimistic about the situation. I just don't have much faith in those who believe its reasonable to align with corporatists in order to combat corporatism. That being said, I will vote in the democratic primary even though I favor third parties. But I have a sneaking suspicion that they'll blame us if they loose. Bleh, I've digressed.

4
flickmontana42A Refugee From A Disconcerted Affair•

For me, it wasn't about Ellison himself. It was about whether they would let us have him. It's like how they wouldn't let us put anything of substance in the non-binding platform.

I agree, this shouldn't affect the Invade/Exit decision. Either way, we need to fight them. The decision is about how we take that fight to them. So far, I've seen some success in taking over the state Dem parties, and no success going through third parties. If I'm wrong about that, or if that changes, then I'm willing to jump on board with a third party. I just don't see it yet.

1
[deleted]•

I think the local orgs are fertile grounds for movement building: we get people into a formalized structure so that there's some real direction and coordination and not just "someone should do something, where do we start?" And from there we can do the door-to-door outreach that left orgs/movements so often fail to do when movement building. We establish our message and agenda and get the people behind us like they got behind Bernie, and also start making connections to the existing political structure which a lot of people just don't know that much about. We don't have civics classes anymore, but even if we did they wouldn't tell you who all the local power players are; in politics you need to know that. At the same time there's not much the party establishment can do about it; we can literally use the Party for our own purposes and all they can do is cry because we outnumber them and outwork them.

mysteriosa said once "I smell blood in the water" and I smell it too and it's thick. The Dems are wounded after Hillary's loss, the loss of all those other seats, and the recordbreaking success of Bernie's campaign. If anything, picking Perez makes them more wounded because it shows their incompetence and contempt. They're vulnerable to populism. This is the time to move in close and start cutting and ripping, doing real damage to the establishment, not just turn our backs and hope they bleed out on their own.

At the state level, of course, we can affect far more actual change. State governments are extremely important; they control almost all of the election laws, they administrate a lot of the "federal" programs like Medicaid that are actually state programs with federal funding, and they can pass things like minimum wage hikes, single-payer, pot legalization, anti-corruption laws etc. that the federal government might not. Getting control of state governments would be a huge coup in itself. And there we're going to see more pushback from the establishment, obviously, especially if they're rigging how the state parties work to keep us out. But if we're bringing a whole movement of people that we built by doing the hard face-to-face work and trust-building and inspiration at the local level, then the establishment rigging is going to be on full display for those people, and those people are going to have policy and personnel demands that are in stark contrast to do-nothing status quo neoliberalism and they're going to see that the elite are actually acting against them. And from there you get the angry town halls, the public callouts, some of which we're already seeing (which is great) and all those establishment people become super vulnerable to primaries and maybe even recalls.

That's the first major win here: build that movement and use it to get control at state level by creating that extreme public pressure. Everything before that is just field maneuvers.

After that comes the fight against the national establishment and that might go one of two ways: either they can't take the pressure anymore and surrender, or they hang on with every ounce of strength, and then hopefully we can get the whole reformed Democratic Party we've built - the voting/donor base, the bench of elected public officials, the party officials - to say "fuck this, we're splitting off" and cut the whole progressive bottom half of the party off at the neck and walk away with it. And then we'll have a third party that people will actually vote for in large numbers while the head of the old Democratic Party rots.

There's a strategy to all this, really. I'm painting it in rosy terms but it's there. There's a loose plan and what we're seeing in California and other states is what I hoped and expected to see. It's still early days, but so far, it's working. We need more people to pile on, more pressure, more state party takeovers, build a bigger movement.

Those of us who want to see Bernie run again in 2020, or enable someone like Nina or Tulsi - we can start working early. Get people informed on issues and candidates, get them registered well in advance in places like NY, keep a sharp eye on the rigging now that we all know what to look for. Bernie wanted millions to get involved and we can help deliver that if we're smart. He got 12 million votes with an insurgent campaign and little name recognition until the end; let's push for 20 million or better. Let's blow the establishment the fuck OUT - and if it fails, it'll be because they'll have to lie and cheat so hard to make it fail that we'll wake up more people. And then we'll add those people to our movement.

I don't know why people can't see all that and act like I'm talking about going back to the Clinton Dems like an abused spouse or a person begging for their old job back.

3
flickmontana42A Refugee From A Disconcerted Affair•

I think they picked Perez just to deny us a win, because a win would embolden us. Same with the platform. They gave us a few crumbs, but not even a single loaf, nothing substantial that we could celebrate.

Dave Ramsey has an idea called the debt snowball. If you have several debts, the most efficient way to pay them off is to start with the highest interest debt, pay that one off entirely, then move on to the next highest, and so on. With the debt snowball, you pay off the debt with the smallest amount first. It's not necessarily efficient, but you get a win under your belt that much faster, which gives you the confidence to keep going.

The party seems deathly afraid of letting us win even once, which gives me hope that even a single win would be the beginning of the end.

EDIT: If all the sane people move to Canada, that leaves the crazies in control of the nukes. Same with the party.

2
[deleted]•

I think they picked Perez just to deny us a win, because a win would embolden us. Same with the platform. They gave us a few crumbs, but not even a single loaf, nothing substantial that we could celebrate.

I really think they're trying to piss us off until we get frustrated and leave. They DON'T want us around. The Hillbots think we're a bunch of deluded radical nutcases who want to ruin the party by making it unelectable, and traitors because we won't fall in line. The establishment doesn't want us making demands, calling attention to their faults, and mucking up their elections. Look at Claire McCaskill, whining about how she might get primaried.

If that was the goal of picking Perez, or even a useful side effect, it worked: a whole bunch of lefties who thought the chair election meant anything flounced. At this point I'm hoping they throw a little tantrum, get over it, and then realize that taking over the Dems is where they need to be.

With the platform, I think they were trying to create a flimsy facade of reasonableness and compromise, a sort of figleaf, so they could claim they "gave" us something and we're just being unreasonable. Or maybe they found it genuinely difficult to say no to every one of Bernie's planks because you'd have to be a complete shitbag for that, and being exposed as a complete shitbag by your own actions could be embarrassing.

I really don't know. You know, the thing about guessing people's motivations is it's hard to guess people's motivations. Also, people are usually not as sinister and brilliantly manipulative as we give them credit for. It's possible the Dems are just incredibly out of touch, stupid, and up their own asses.

2
helpercat•

Nothing new. Trump delivers classic GOP speech. Could have been written by Ted Cruz. Democrats sit in opposition. Just like if Hillary had won and the GOP would have had their tantrum like they did during Obama's speeches. Honestly pretty boring all around.

4
BlackhaloPurity pony!•

if Hillary had won

Oh. Dear god, no! I don't even want to imagine that. Trump is bad enough.

2
bout_that_actionBernie made me Russian•

What I noticed which I found troubling, was Keith Ellison next to Debbie Wasserman Shultz looking very "buddy buddy". There's a saying that politics makes strange bedfellows, but he looked every bit a part of the establishment dems.

They may very well be buddies but this may also have something to do with the anti-semetic charges he was smeared with. Groveling signal to Haim Saban/Dershowitz/etc. who still may not be comfortable with him being deputy chair? I remember Obama supposedly tried to fire DWS and she threatened to call him anti-semetic.

4
OneTwoWee000OP•

Groveling signal to Haim Saban/Dershowitz/etc. who still may not be comfortable with him being deputy chair?

This is so sad.. He's clearly not anti-semetic but feels like he has to do through these indignities.. Awful.

3
BillToddTooPuttery Pony•

anti-semetic

anti-semitic

1
penelopepnortneyPurity Unicorn•

Or anti-emetic.

2
BillToddTooPuttery Pony•

Ah, but anti-emetic would have had a grain of validity to it in Ellison's case - not their style to admit anything like that about their establishment.

3
BlackhaloPurity pony!•

Nice assessment. Did you watch the (D) response? What are your thoughts on it compared to Sanders'?

2