Flawed methodology used for testing CPU gaming performance.
We have seen that gaming performance for Ryzen 1700, 1800 are very inconsistent from reviewer to reviewer. And it all comes down the methodology used to measure the "gaming" performance.
In order to get the "full gaming" performance of the CPU they lower the resolution, graphical settings to make sure that the GPU is not bottlenecking (99% usage) but rather it would be the other way around and force the CPU to bottleneck. This way of testing gives us results where Ryzen 1700, 1800 perform significantly worse than high-end i7 CPU's and equal to i5 CPU's in some scenarios. I personally think that this has its own purpose and place. It helps us to see which CPU can handle more powerful GPU's better but at the same time it is also flawed.
For example a person who buys a GTX 1080 wants to crank up resolution and graphical settings to get best visual quality and also try to balance them so they get 60+ fps. If they see that their GPU usage is 99% then that is a good thing because they know that their GPU is taken to its limit and not bottlenecked by the CPU. If they experience stuttering or even have their system freeze and see that their CPU is hitting 99-100% usage then that is a bad sign because CPU is your PC's brain and now it is bottlenecking and ruining your gaming experience. This means you have to lower settings or close background applications that use CPU to free up some room to get smoother gaming experience. Not ideal.
This is where Ryzen 1700, 1800 come in handy compared to its similarly priced intel i7 counterparts.
If you play at 1080p/1440p, max settings with GTX 1080 and the GPU usage is 99%, only then we can see the true real world gaming performance. If with i7 7700K you get average of 70fps then that is good and with Ryzen 1700, 1800 you get 60fps then that is still pretty good but obviously one CPU is weaker in this task than the other. But if you also look how much CPU is being used then we might see that i7 7700K is being used more than 70% while Ryzen 1700 only 40%. This makes it pretty clear that if you like to multitask and have applications open in the background that use a lot of CPU then Ryzen 1700, 1800 in overall offers better experience even if you sacrifice 5-15% fps.
Reviewers should of made this very clear and instead focuse more on real world gaming performance with current high end GPU's like GTX 1080 and GTX Titan XP because average gamer might buy one of these in 2-3 years which is a long enough period where the Ryzen 1700, 1800 are not really going to be a significant limiting factor and get replaced with better and more powerful models.
Posted Mar 3, 2017, 9:54 AM UTC
Some reviewers have stated that gaming is smoother, there is no hitch or stutter, as you would find even on the best i7s
There's less framerate variance, but if minimums, averages and maximums are higher all around on the i5/i7 there's no reason to choose the Ryzen chip over the i5/i7 simply because there's less variance in frame times. Would you rather have a framerate that fluctuates from 32-36 as compared to one that fluctuates from 50-60, for instance. That's what I'm getting at here.
Well, yeah. Both would be pretty bad imo. I either game at 60+ or just put the game back on the shelf. At maxed fps though, I've seen the i7 stutter where my 8350 fx didn't (battlefield 4), so I wouldn't be surprised if ryzen was actually better for gaming.
You don't understand, Ryzen is not that far under i7, And the Ryzen CPU can push easily over 60fps. The thing is look at this video at minute 7:08 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BXVIPo_qbc4 See how i7 tanks the framerates, this is what we're talking about, when there is a CPU bottleneck(100% CPU utilization) i7 7700k will fall behind.
Those are just scene variances. Let me put it this way - record 2 ingame videos following a path as similar as possible, put them side by side and see whether framerate and GPU/CPU utilization coincide at every point in time. Hint: they won't.
Yes but you miss the point, r1700 has more resources than 7700k therefor will not be limited in situations where i7700k would be at 100% i.e heavy cpu situations.
This, i7700k can tank games due to 100% utilization while Ryzen will not drop them at that point because it would still not bottle neck the GPU.