[Ruling Question] Resonance and J-Rulers

Ruling Question

Pricia vs Gill Alhama'at resonance abilities. If the [[Magic Stone of Blasting Waves]] is called then Pricia give one resonator flying and another resonator swiftness. Correct?

But if the Magic Stone of Heavens Rift is played then Gill Alhama'at only gets 1 mana counter. I come to this because the wording on his card says Resonance Light or Darkness magic stone so whether it is light or darkness you get 1 mana counter the fact that it is both is of no consequence. Also, the fact that Pricia's is set out as 2 separate resonance effects, if the card were meant to call for either or then it could have a resonance Light and a second resonance for Dark but both of them would add mana counter. Correct?

Posted Mar 6, 2017, 5:17 PM UTC

25
Briars•

pricia: yes, because its 2 different resonance abilities
Alhama'at: yes. because its 1 ability looking for 1 of 2 stone types.

3
ScheheraBot•

Magic Stone of Blasting Waves - (DB Page)

^^Questions? ^^Message ^^/u/Mattaiyah ^^- ^^Call ^^cards ^^with ^^[[CARDNAME]] ^^- ^^Format: ^^Image ^^- ^^URL ^^to ^^db.fowtcg.us

^^Please ^^consider ^^donating ^^to ^^help ^^pay ^^for ^^server ^^costs.

1
Srlqulongtard•

Pricia gets both off of a dual stone because she has 2 separate abilities. Alhama'at only gets one because he only has 1. If they had printed the ability twice and made black and white stones 2 different abilties with the same effect, then he would get 2 counters.

1
[deleted]•

The force of will article on alhamat says it only triggers once. Its been wrong before though.

I believe its wrong this time as well. The resonance ability should trigger once for a light stone, and once again since its a dark stone as well.

Might of made it clearer if they did seperate the resonace effects with the same text.

Edit: They also should have made it clear in the CR that it would only trigger once.

-8
kestral287•

It is very clear in the effect that it only triggers once if you get a Heaven's Rift or Ancient Magic Stone. Pricia will trigger both abilities because they are separate. Alham'mat's has one ability and thus it will only trigger once. An ability only triggers once per object; that's in the CR.

3