r/Amd•
renebulous

Where's the data that shows GPU bottlenecks CPU in 4K gaming?

This should be pretty to prove right? Just show GPU usage and GPU memory usage, then show CPU usage for each core/thread, and compare between the different resolutions/settings.

Has anyone actually done this? Or is the whole "1080p is the only reliable indicator of CPU gaming performance" mantra just a myth?

Edit: Add-on question, wouldn't Titan XP's be pushed to their max, rendering as many frames as they can, even at 1080p? Or if there's some cap that exists for some reason (because of memory speed? idk) how would CPU performance come into play then? And if we're going to go into theoretical territory, we'd have to understand what roles the CPU and the GPU play in rendering each frame, which I suppose differs from game to game as well. Short of figuring out all that, I think only what we really need is some hard data.

Posted Mar 7, 2017, 3:52 PM UTC · edited

018
SillentStrikerFX 8350 | STRIX 1060 | 8GB RAM•

Can your processor run x game at 80 fps in this scene? Congratulations, your processor can run the game at 80 fps on that scene at any resolution. The only reason people run cpu benchmarks at 1080p or 720p is because well, its hard for even Titan XP's to get high frame rates at 4k.

2
renebulousOP•

I'm sorry, I don't follow. I suppose you're saying that the CPU does the same amount of work regardless of resolution, so a 1p and a 4k would require the CPU to run the exact same instructions. I'm not sure about this, but okay, let's assume that.

So next you're saying that high frame rates are necessary so that we can discern minute differences in relative performance more clearly. I totally agree with that. But why do some benchmarks show relative performance being different between 1080p and 4k? I.e. R7 1800x may be only 1% worse in 4k but 10% worse in 1080p. What would explain that? And wouldn't that disprove the notion that the CPU runs the exact same instructions?

0
Paracelcus•

cpu does the same amount of work at 4k as it does 1080p

That's pretty much it, yeah. So long as the number of objects on screen doesn't change, the cpu load doesn't either. Increasing resolution doesn't increase the game logic or physics calculations, just the load on the gpu.

A 480p test of a cpu is indicative of its 4k performance, so long as field of view is held constant.

1
Darius510•

What explains it is that the GPU is a bottleneck at 4K.

It does the same amount of work per frame regardless of resolution. If the GPU is a bottleneck, the CPU is sitting idle more of the time and doing less work overall.

1
meganachosRyzen 1700 3.9Ghz | Asus Crosshair VI Hero | Fury X•

Ryzen will handle anything at 4K

Source me w/ fury x

2
renebulousOP•

True dat, but I'm still wondering about the whole GPU bottlenecking theory...

1
RhombusAcheron•

It isn't a theory. The higher you scale your resolution the more load you put on the gpu and the more likely your fps is to be limited by the gpu.

Think about it like this. You're playing a game and there's two different things happening in parallel. One is that your GPU is rendering video and spitting it out to your monitor, and the other is that your CPU is processing what the game world and everything else is doing. Those two things need to be synchronized so that the game world and what you're seeing are actually linked.

If you're game-world takes more power from the GPU than the CPU (because you're at a higher resolution) then your CPU is going to 'slow down' to keep pace with it. Vice versa if the CPU is doing the heavy lifting the GPU is only going to push frames as fast as the cpu can keep up.

Thats a bottleneck in games. Basically no matter what you're doing one of those two is limiting your FPS. You may be pushing 250FPS and it doesn't matter or you may be chugging along at like 45.

Will Ryzen game @ 4k? Sure. The GPU is whats having to do the brunt of the work. The CPU doesn't get to help out with rendering. You may see better minimums as several benchmarks did indicate the spread from min-avg-max was much tighter on Ryzen, but realistically any modern CPU should provide a similar 4k experience.

The reason they do benches @ 720p or lower is to try and strain the CPU. Taking all the load off the GPU and letting it render potato makes the CPU the limiting factor for FPS so they can show how its relative maximum performance would be. You may or may not find value in that just as others may or may not find value in a 4k bench.

6
AjBlue7•

It was pretty bad that they tried to call 1440p and 4k bad for testing. I'm all for testing and the most common res but ideally reviewers should test multiple resolutions.

When you go too low in res and graphical quality all you end up testing is the cpu's throughput for drawcalls which is insane because no one will ever need a cpu that can handle that many drawcalls, it has no indication of how the cpu would handle more complex games in the future. The ideal setting if there ever was one, is where both the gpu and cpu are being pushed to their limits. Only problem with that is it becomes hard to compare with other hardware.

It was a weird thing to have drama about because people have always said that the cpu doesn't really matter for games. All you need is good enough, as the gpu is responsible for the large majority of performance.

Was really surprised that reviewers didn't focus more on multitasking, streaming and multimonitor setups. In my opinion Ryzen focused on all the things that matter for a cpu and knocked them out of the park while providing a clockfrequency that was good enough for games.

That being said AMD has had a lot of issues in the way they marketed and lack of control on the hype as well as all of the bios issues. They definitely deserve criticism but not in regards to the gaming performance on a 8 core chip that primarily competes against chips that are bad at playing games. Hate on the R5 and R3 all you want if need be.

1
RhombusAcheron•

So I actually agree with the contention that it "bad" for testing precisely because so many people don't understand why its not really that useful of a benchmark. Something would have to be like...massively wrong for a significant divergence in FPS @ 4k due to the cpu.

Definitely if you're including lowres you should include highres but I think that it needs to be made super clear to readers what those mean since a lot of consumers are just going to buy the thing with the best graphs regardless of what that actually means.

RE: the other stuff, I mean most reviewers do include some easy to tick productivity benchmarks. I think that the people doing those types of tasks can be generally trusted to do research and launch benchmarks are aimed mostly at the lolgamer crowd who just wants to know what has the best numbers.

That being said AMD has had a lot of issues in the way they marketed and lack of control on the hype

Don't know that I agree wholly...AMD really can't control the reddit hype machine.

1
_yipman•

I went from 6600K to 1700 with Fury X and I dropped 10-20 FPS in all my games at 1440P. Source me

4
SillentStrikerFX 8350 | STRIX 1060 | 8GB RAM•

Really? Did you perform some tests before swapping the cpu and then do the same for your new processor? I'd really like to see them, since this sub loves statements like "i just upgraded to ryzen cpu and no stutter" with no ammount of data given. I'm still waiting for Digital Foundry's view on these processors for the frame time data anyway.

1
meganachosRyzen 1700 3.9Ghz | Asus Crosshair VI Hero | Fury X•

What theory?

3
Paracelcus•

The one in the op

1
RhombusAcheron•

There is no theory its just more r/amd logic.

1
Snydenthur•

The game bottlenecks the gpu which means you can't go any higher than x fps, no matter what you do.

Think of cars, for example. Cpu is the driver and car is the gpu. That car has maximum velocity of 200km/h. No matter who is driving the car, it just simply doesn't go faster than that.

As long as you have somewhat decent cpu, you aren't bottlenecked by your cpu at 4k, since gpus just aren't handling that resolution well enough currently.

1
Koreenium[ RX 480 Nitro+ | 1300mhz @ 1056mv ] --- [ i5 3570K ]•

And FX 8350 isn't too bad either at 4K but that doesn't mean FX 8350 is good.

1
meganachosRyzen 1700 3.9Ghz | Asus Crosshair VI Hero | Fury X•

Ok Ryzen is good at 4K and won't bottleneck any decent gpu for that res

I came from an fx6300 overclocked to 4.5Ghz

Blows it out of the water entirely

1
KainXS•

Well the load on a CPU is highest at lower resolutions, as you increase in resolution the framerate drops and the load is reduced as the CPU is pushing less frames to the GPU so there's no CPU bottleneck at 4K for the same scene.

1