Why Iowa's Citadel Shows What's Wrong with Warships - iChaseGaming

Media

Posted Mar 16, 2017, 12:35 PM UTC

11499
Fluffy_Pillowszz•

I think iChase has a valid point. We can argue for ever about longest range hits and maximum ranges etc. I think the valid point is that the later us battleships were designed for engagement at long range but their role changed into shore bombardment and AA protection. The big battles with battleships vs battleships the admirals had dreamed of never happened in WW2. To make the game work somewhat there will be necessary to make large compromises or it would have to change totally.

With the map size and time constraints we have at the moment the German battleships will rule the BB role as aggressive BB play. This will mean that IJN and USN BB captains will sit at long-range bow in and lob shells is a very static game style. If the new planned BB lines will be different and more in line with the german style ships is left to be seen, and if they are it means that the IJN and USN BB lines will be rusting away in most captain’s harbors.

47
Caucasian_FuryRoyal Canadian Navy•

Eh, I've pointed this out before but German BBs are probably the most played BBs in the game right now, on NA at least, and you know what, I almost never see them do anything more then camp in the back and sniping from max range same as IJN and USN BBs.

I highly doubt "fixing" the IJN and USN BB armour schemes so that they can take hits and brawl better is going to fix the snipe meta.

24
Crown_Breaker•

Comes down to support. The cruisers want the battleships to go first to draw fire. The battleships want the cruisers to go first to kill the destroyers. The Destroyers already went first and just wish someone would fucking push with them.

Such is life.

92
PHSSAMUEL•

This. In mid tier, I'm happy to go in pushing with german BB, but I do need some help to survive. In low tier, I'm happy almost also going in first, because though a YOLO scram by a DD is near unstoppable in t3-5 without also dying, the low tier DDs are generally not as good at doing so. In T7+, being the leading edge in a BB is a good way to get an early water-filled hull from torpedoes and concentrated fire.

15
NoZoupForYouyoutube.com/user/zoupgaming•

I love pushing in the Kurfurst. I love it until I make it to the cap, and the DD 5 KM next to me who hasn't been spotted decides to pop his smoke and sit in it leaving me to roast when I could be concealed blasting away. Sigh.

And then it makes me not want to push. But I don't want to be THAT guy, sitting in the back sniping because it just isn't fun. So I continue to push. Thus the vicious cycle continues of some very good games, with some very bad games in between.

9
fireinthesky7Come a little closer•

I've had two Krakens in the last week playing psychotic YOLO Clemson, but that's probably the only T3-5 DD remotely capable of doing so.

2
SeaRaptor00Acolyte of the Church of Hindenburg•

The cruisers want the battleships to go first to draw fire. The battleships want the cruisers to go first to kill the destroyers. The Destroyers already went first and just wish someone would fucking push with them.

This needs to go on some kind of World of Warships quote hall of fame.

6
iku_1950 DKP MINUS (IKU19@NA)•

I highly doubt "fixing" the IJN and USN BB armour schemes so that they can take hits and brawl better is going to fix the snipe meta.

It won't, I was arguing with someone over "lemming trains" - something that's fundamentally rare in warships due to how ships move and the high TTK, and "economy" - where they still thought repair is proportional to HP, so in other words: they sat in the corner of the map complaining about lemming trains. If they fix the armor scheme, the play style won't change because people don't know why they're using that playstyle, they're just getting fed words from the forums, subreddit, or youtube.

^(In Warships the equivalent to lemming trains is a match turning into coagulated letter soup - Blobbing, a thing that's far less lethal in WoT is extremely fatal in WoWs due to torpedoes and inaccuracy, ergo lemming trains actually being a decent tactic for spreading out torpedoes)

11
Caucasian_FuryRoyal Canadian Navy•

That's the thing, there's a disparity in the player base. The average player, that makes up the majority of the population, rare if ever frequents the WoWS forums or the sub reddit. The forum and sub pop constitutes a minority portion of the total player base, and I would even argue only a small fraction of it.

The forum and sub pop players are generally more aware of the game mechanics that your average player obviously has little clue about. You notice and see this in game all the time whether you are playing T3, or T10 because I probably see about equal amounts of players who sail broadside without every WASD'ing whether it's low or high tiers, and the same goes for CV players who don't know what alt-attack is.

Your economy thing is also a good point because even though the economy has changed for a long time, almost every other game I still witness the last 1, 2 or 3 ships on the losing team making a mad dash for the far corner trying to run out the timer or point counter because they want to keep their repair bill down.

8
The_Brofisticus•

I think a lot of the blame for that falls on the community creators and the complete lack of functional in-game tutorials. Humans are naturally cowardly, as long as they get some sort of validation (no matter the quality), they will feel justified.

3
wha2les•

It will improve it. It forces ships to go to corresponding immunity zones otherwise they eat side pen or deck pens. So German bb will need to get close to be effective and if they are an ineffective sniping potato, they will eat citadel damage more frequently. Same with ships like Yamato and Montana. If you snipe at 20km, I will get deck pens. If you go too close I will pen you from the side. If you are 12-15 km, you will have immunity zones and be more effective.

Those numbers are just examples btw

5
Caucasian_FuryRoyal Canadian Navy•

To be honest, I highly doubt the average player will be aware of their ship's zone of immunity or even effective operating range. Goes back to my observation where most of the Tirpitz or Scharnhorst I see in game are spamming HE from 19 km because reasons.

3
wha2les•

Well people are smart enough to realize at this range I take practically no damage and at this range I get deleted.. so they will adapt. These changes means that if I have deck hits on a tirpitz at range, guaranteed heavy damage of some kind. Right now they are still able to not feel it at that range.

5
abacs21Balls of Steel•

The armor penetration example at 10:20 is wrong. The chart at 7:50 already shows penetration corrected for the angle of impact, hence the fact it shows both belt AND deck penetration. What that means is that the shell can penetrate 169mm of deck armor at 27.5km, it will easily go through 152mm even if it shows 324mm of effective armor through the armor viewer, because again, the chart already has it corrected for angle of impact. That shell would be able to penetrate 360mm of armor from a 90 degree angle at that distance.

11
Referat-•

But youtubers are never wrong! /s

4
fnord_disc•

This entire argument is problematic.

The longest-range gunfire hit in WW2 was about 24,000 yards, significantly lower than the 27,000+ he assumes as viable combat ranges for this video. Most gunfire in WW2 occured well below 20,000 yards.

It is a historical fact that navies were trying to push combat ranges before and during WW2 and the US Navy designed their armor with longer ranges in mind, but there is no reason to assume that effective gunfire would have been possible at those ranges during WW2.

10
NovuakeDouble Overpen [2OP]•

But all of this doesnt change the fact that the armor was designed to function within those parameters. Which means for game balance scaling penetration to range makes so much sense.

9
WuJenThe only true paradises are those lost to us.•

This entire argument is problematic.

The longest-range gunfire hit in WW2 was about 24,000 yards, significantly lower than the 27,000+ he assumes as viable combat ranges for this video. Most gunfire in WW2 occured well below 20,000 yards.

It is a historical fact that navies were trying to push combat ranges before and during WW2 and the US Navy designed their armor with longer ranges in mind, but there is no reason to assume that effective gunfire would have been possible at those ranges during WW2.

http://www.navweaps.com/index_tech/tech-006.htm

Longest was Warspite vs Cesare at 26,000 yds and the Scharnhorst vs Glorious at about the same range.

7
fnord_disc•

Okay, 26k then. Still, that's the longest-range hit, not the viable range. Just a fluke.

Nobody ever hit anything at 27k.

7
Crown_Breaker•

You... would not want to play this game with historic accuracy. On any ship. At any level imaginable.

19
marcocom•

There's hugely popular pirate-era naval combat games that have you timing your roll in the waves while your balls whistle off foul in different directions and it's fun. But reality is opposite of wows as it's been said. Your bigger weapons tend to be slower so you armor and push them forward with a battle group to get them close enough to take out the other guy's groupings. We have it all a bit cocked up in wows really

3
FourteenFour•

and my dead horse is...

and if you hit one in a hundred shots you were doing good. accuracy as a whole in this game is wrong. strategies employed with shooting in WW1 and WW2 would be instant deletes in this game. The age old idea that worked was you wanted to have as many guns on target as you could versus your enemy, look up crossing the T. It means what you think, you are the top line and your opponent is the vertical line. You get all guns, he gets fronts only.

Citadel hits are modeled wrong. At most they should guarantee modules being knocked out, disabled for a long time, or such. They should be the ONLY way for a detonation to occur. they should not be bonus damage.

Then there is this whole idiocy with secondaries being effective area of denial zones. AI controlled weapons should be wholly inaccurate. I do not mind stealth firing being lost but damn, secondary accuracy needs to drop as so should its range.

5
wha2les•

Secondaries without manual is inaccurate...

8
wha2les•

The argument is armor is historically accurate but the penetration is not for the range. Since the range has been decreased, the design for guns are not correct. Usn was counting on over deck penetration, but that rarely happens so all of this change would improve the effectiveness of armor, help make certain guns accurate in performance and promote brawling.

And if you wanna cite historical accuracy, fix usn CV loadouts and ijn torps

2
jonasneelet's be fair, i won't be happy before no ship has AA•

the USN loadouts makes sense from a historical PoV, the US heavily focused on DB, SB and fighters and had relatively few torpedo bombers.

2
wha2les•

But it wasn't pure offense or pure defense...

And still fix the ijn DD Torps please ..

3
ardraeissWoWS Gameplay Scripter•

The ranges were not "decreased", only the elevation angles were limited. The penetration in game is correct.

1
wha2les•

You are missing the point. Go rewatch the video..m

1
ardraeissWoWS Gameplay Scripter•

You are missing the point.

Sorry, but you have, completely. The penetration values in game are what they were IRL or close to that with the similar margin or error to the "USN Empirical Formula".

As for video... you should rewatch it again. The iChase states that the penetration values are high - as they were IRL. This is true. The actual ranges on the other hand were not as big as he assumed. This is the historical fact. The USN admirals just have made the wrong assumption on how well will work long range fire. Don't worry - every other big navy made same(or some other big wrong assumtpions) as well. It just didn't worked "as designed".

The another of iChase big mistakes was assumption that the "deck armor penetration" values in the NavWeaps table exclude the angle of impact... that is completely wrong! There is no "additional angle" to add for belt's inclination/deck thickness! The penetration values were calculated with the angle of impact in mind. Belt is inclined so you have to include the belt angle first to calculate the 0 degrees thickness(as he did in video == 329mms) but for the deck you just have to look at the flat deck thickness - 152mm < 169mms of deck penetration. Whoops, the 152mm deck will be most likely penetrated at 27.5kms, unlike what he has said in the video. Same goes for the belt - 329 < 380. Surprise, the Iowa has nearly no immunity zone IRL! Except for the ship angling which was considered to be about 30-35 degrees for IZ calculations if I remember correctly. Yet another historical fact. The Iowa class battleships armor just was not designed to hold the 16"/50 Mk8 AP shells - it was designed against the 14" shells(of the Kongo class battlecruisers).

He also ignored the fact that he can shoot at about 27kms in game - you just have to fit your ship for long range shooting(module + spotter plane).

0
PrivateSnuffyOPCynical douche•

You said it yourself though, as did Chase. Design =/= application, which is the overall point in both cases

1
fnord_disc•

No, he tries to argue that combat ranges are too short in the game and therefore American armor designs seem bad when supposedly in reality combat ranges were longer and such designs more viable.

But they weren't. The combat ranges we see in the game of 15-16km at higher tiers are a little on the short side, but by no means unrealistically short.

So what reason is there to compress penetration performance like he suggests?

8
PrivateSnuffyOPCynical douche•

But that's still shorting it.

To preface this discussion, I don't really care because I'm not a BB player*. He's saying ships will underperform relative to distance, and that of course the closer to another ship you fire the less effective the armor will be. They aren't meant for that

Meant, as you said, doesn't necessarily mean used as such

*to remove any assumed bias of me arguing for a BB buff so to speak

4
fnord_disc•

He's comparing apples with oranges, that's the point. You can't use 27,000 yards as a combat range and talk about compression. If you want to compress penetration relative to the actual compression of combat ranges, then you'd have to compress from maybe 18k to 15k, not 27k to 15k. Consequently the actual compression of the penetration would be minor and would have very little effect on gameplay or armor performance.

You can't argue that ingame combat ranges make armor useless and then proceed to contrast combat ranges as an example where nobody ever hit a single ship.

3
LegatusDivinae"Kaz, I'm already a submarine"•

Exactly-if he wants compressed penetration he can play KM CAs anytime

2
PyroIite•

Well, if they change their basic system they have to change A LOT of factors.

For example if the change citadels or how armor works they have to compensate for by changing speed, accuracy or change deck armor or something.

For example Iowa vs Friedrich der Große:

Iowa is faster, has more and more powerful guns, better range, better concealment, is overall a smaller target and has better maneuverability, better torpedo protection and better AAA. If they change the armor/penetration mechanics they have to rebalance all those factors.

10
IratusTaurus•

I agree with you, but that's why its such a big issue for the developers to sort out.

If they are ever going to change something so fundamental as this, it has to be done right now. Every balance decision made before this change would have to be remade, up to the point where as you say whole ships would stop being viable at their tiers.

I think its probably best to continue as-is, and hope it keeps 'working as intended' for as long as possible.

5
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
TommiHPunkt•

Iowa has 27% torpedo protection and a smaller turning circle

3
wsollersSeal to be clubbed•

Which is shit because the Iowa triple bottom and side armor is identical to the Alabama which can get to 50% reduction. Because reasons.

9
Caucasian_FuryRoyal Canadian Navy•

Eh, that is Bama's premium "factor", like how MO has radar as it's premium "factor" and Iowa does not.

6
PyroIite•

I am talking about maneuverability, which is only partially rudder shift. Iowa still has higher speed and lower turning circle radius then FdG - so overall I would give maneuverability to Iowa.

1
wha2les•

And removing stealth fire isn't going to change a lot of factors? This is at least a positive change while the other is Nora positive change...

1
PyroIite•

Which one is a positive change? I think it depends at lot on whom you ask.

1
wha2les•

The changes Chase is proposing.

Stealth fire removal isn't a positive change as it prevents ijn dds from being effective.. especially since stealth is most important to them and they can't fire guns without being spotted at 11 km...

1
kruis•

IJN DDS HAVE TORPS, AND GREAT STEALTH!

I know the torps aren't great, but fuck it's not like they are completely unusable.

0
horsememesBASED [380 mm/45 Model 1936 naval gun]•

Iowa was kind of a bad example when talking about immunity zones, given she wasn't even protected against her own guns from any realistic combat range - and this was admitted to by the USN, even. She was more or less a modern battlecruiser.

While I agree with the concept of some sort of range crunch, bending the game over for Iowa gives us the exact opposite problem. That 27km->14km value is especially bad - 27km hits literally never happened, as people have pointed out with Warspite taking the longest range hit, while 14km is just midrange ingame. Something akin to 20km->14km would make more sense.

9
wha2les•

Think immunity zones as in in certain areas it will bounce shells even broadside not it can protect themselves from itself.

If I am in Iowa and in my immunity zone, broadside or not if you hit me in a nc, I would take little to some not WTF 40k off kind of thing. It promotes brawling and closer engagement, fix the stake bow on Snipes, removes he need of stealth fire without nerfing crap due to closer engagement ranges

Overall it would be beneficial

3
horsememesBASED [380 mm/45 Model 1936 naval gun]•

...um. I think you misunderstood my comment. I'm saying Iowa would have a tiny immunity zone compared to other BBs even with a pen crunch, because she had one of the thinnest belts of all 1930s+ battleships.

Even if we did a pen crunch, Iowa would still have a puny immunity zone - Bismarck can punch through her belt until around 25-26km out, Richelieu until over 27km out, Littorio until anywhere between 26-29km out, Nocal until 27km out, even Dunkek could pen her until about the same range as Bismarck. It's only really enough to protect from Scharnhorst, KGV, and some 1920s/WW1 guns. Yamato, FDG/Kurfurst, Izumo, and Iowa/Montana would obliterate her from basically any conceivable range.

This change wouldn't really be a buff to Iowa, it'd be a nerf - she could defend from lower tier BBs better, but contemporary BBs could actually leverage their thicker armor over her when they can't really do that now.

4
wha2les•

Are you including he sloped angles? It's not just 307mm... And you also have to include citadel armor and the belt.

And angling is still a thing.. this isn't a you can just sail broadside pass... It's a at certain ranges you are more durable.

And that is why it is beneficial not just bb durability, but match fluidity

4
horsememesBASED [380 mm/45 Model 1936 naval gun]•

Yes, I'm including the sloped angle, there.

2
ByronicAsianTori Kaji Ippai•

If AoF and time to target is scaled to in game ranges, wouldn't it seriously effect the lobbier shells even more?

Like if USN SHS was arc-y now, then it'll be even harder to lead when 20km is actually "30km".

5
AOSPrevails400lbHacker_TheCybers•

Like if USN SHS was arc-y now, then it'll be even harder to lead when 20km is actually "30km".

Given that IRL those are fired with Fire control systems that computes leads for you(i.e AIM BOT), to do it in game without one would make accuracy even lower than real life hit%

5
SuperObviousShill•

The game already gives you considerable aim assistance. The shells do pretty cheaty shit.

2
wha2les•

But if you hit you will actually do stuff. Instead of bounce

2
BoxOfDustI like Ocean || Dust_ @NA•

Ah, yes. World of Warships, the place where I picked up the concept that for games like this, reality is its own balance.

Regardless of historical precedent, I think iChase is right here, shell penetration and range interaction should be looked at. We're fighting with ships as they were physically engineered, but we're not fighting with them as they were tactically designed. It does create a slew of un-historical balance problems because some ships simply don't have a place because that place doesn't exist.

I suppose the argument here is whether 'reality-derived' gameplay (game flow is derived from reality's intended performances) or 'emergent' gameplay (evolved from game mechanics) is preferable.

3
mastergenera1Kriegsmarine•

I agree with iChase wholeheatedly, and on a similar yet diff. note i was talking to my clan( whom rejected this idea) of balancing belfasts HE shell fire chance based upon the only other UK 152 gun/shell ingame, the warspites. where as the warspite shell has 60% more explosive, but the end result ended up with the belfast getting a 7.2% fire chance with capt fire % buff(based on ingame warspite fire chance is 14% with skill for secondaries). but the rage happened cuz realism doesnt matter. used HE shell bursting charge weight to compare.

navweps for both guns http://www.navweaps.com/Weapons/WNBR_6-50_mk16.htm -ingame warspite secondaries

http://www.navweaps.com/Weapons/WNBR_6-50_mk23.php -leander/belfast/edinburgh guns

some of us like cold hard facts compared to WGs imaginary numbers.

2
Yasenpoi•

I don't think there is a simple solution. Would fighting at 20-40km be good gameplay? Accuracy in single digits and Battles spanning hours?

1
wha2les•

Not the point being made. Right now the max range is not accurate, but shell penetration is. So if a gun has a max range of 40km and a pen of 300 inches, and the max range of the guns in game is 20km, at 20 km it is still 300 inches... What Chase is proposing is to adjust the penetration to compensate for the way game is compressing range. That will allow armor to be more effective, and in theory being broadside at certain ranges would be okay as your armor would shatter shells.

This change is supposed to help with game fluidity and bring parity to certain guns that rely on deck pens which is wonky at best and ineffective at worse.

2
ThEGr33kXIIRoyal Navy •

I've thought about this a lot. Compressing the range and so increasing the arc is the best bet. Don't know if it will help some ships though...

1
[deleted]•

I gave up on US BB gameplay entirely, just too much fucking bullshit and WG's invisible "hate nerfing" of US ships in general has basically made me not play a single US ship in months.

-2†
horsememesBASED [380 mm/45 Model 1936 naval gun]•

I can't remember a single USN nerf since Midway, and at least four or five buffs to USN lines since then. What game are you playing?

7
[deleted]•

Then you haven't been playing the game long

-8
horsememesBASED [380 mm/45 Model 1936 naval gun]•

I've been playing this game since around august-september 2015.

Again, far more buffs than nerfs for the USN in that time period.

3
SpotOnTheRug•

Yes, they've been buffed more, but they seriously needed it.

Once upon a time even US DDs were subpar compared to IJN DDs.

US CAs have always been considered weaker compared to IJN CAs.

And of course, we have the oh so historical Yamato pre-nerf, with a retarded repair and whatnot.

US received buffs because they needed them.

0
ByronicAsianTori Kaji Ippai•

The only noticeable change to USN ships was the change from CBT placeholder arcs to ones that mirrored IRL angle of fall.

All subsequent changes were pretty much minor to large buffs to make up for said disparity in aiming difficulty.

1