[GC] Best overall starred players discussion and scouting report.

My friends and I have played a lot of 3 person round robin tournaments with all stars on and a couple strange house rules: no Hammerbro, and you can't pitch the same character against the same person two times (meaning you need two pitchers). Here is my scouting report on the best and most contested characters in the game.

  1. DK

Best pitcher in the game due to his 80 grade fastball, changeup, and no-charge ability to move the ball very far. His arm angle adds to his ability to be incredibly deceptive on the mound. He can slap-hit for singles, hit dingers on non 'nice' charge hits to right field, and reach very far to the insides and outsides of the plate. DK's only real but very detrimental concern when hitting is his small zone. He also can't hit homers to left without getting a Perfect.

He doesn't have the stuff to be a great infielder, but can easily play RF with his laser throw, 1B, or catcher.

Pitching: 80/80

Hitting: 65/80

Fielding: 60/80

Overall: 75/80

  1. Boo

Much of the same characteristics of DK as far as deceptive pitching ability & ball speed go. Great hitter with the ability to put the ball in the stands or in front of an outfielder because of his curving ball trajectory. Can reach both sides of the plate and hits singles on pitches where he's jammed regularly. Very awkward fielder - best at 3rd to catch screaming liners with his super-jump fielding special.

Pitching: 80/80

Hitting: 70/80

Fielding: 55/80

Overall: 75/80

  1. King Boo

Best hitter in the game. Power to all fields, ability to knock the ball out of the park on a non-nice charge swing. Covers the whole plate and well into the opposite batters box. There are really no downsides and a whole lot of upsides to KB's hitting.

Can't field very well. Has the same issue as Boo where he floats around and is generally awkward to handle in the field. Plays best in the corners of the infield where he doesn't need to move much and can make use of his super-jump. Does not see much time on the mound, but when he does, he's got one of the hardest fastballs in the game.

Pitching: 65/80

Hitting: 80/80

Fielding: 55/80

Overall: 75/80

  1. Bowser

Second best hitter behind KB. If you pull the ball on a charge swing, you can kiss it goodbye. Routinely gets hit by opposing pitcher if there is a base open to give him. Can reach far inside and out. Has a lot of friends (BJ, Dry Bones, both Koopas, Hammerbro if you play with him) giving him added stats in the box. Playable in right field with his laser throw, but also makes a great catcher or first baseman. Also has a lot of enemies (Mario, Peach, Toad, Daisy, lolBaby Mario), so be careful when creating your fielding structure so he doesn't end up sailing a ball or being thrown to by an enemy.

There are too many other good pitchers in the game to give Bowser a shot on the mound; his inability to curve the ball much on non-charge pitches is what makes him generally inviable.

Pitching: 50/80

Hitting: 80/80

Fielding: 55/80

Overall: 70/80

  1. Yoshi

Best fielder in the game. Yoshi and Birdo's fielding special ability are the best in the game, and Yoshi is the fastest player (maybe a tad behind Toadette). Can catch nearly any ball in the outfield - plays best in center. Can also be used as a ridiculous shortstop to stop most balls from getting into left field. If you have Yoshi and Birdo on the same team, whoever you are playing against is going to hate this game pretty quickly.

Hits above average, but has a hard time getting the ball out of the park without a friend on the basepaths. Can slaphit for singles and steal bases like a 13 year old shoplifting a 7/11. Can't pitch for shit, but his other characteristics make up for it easily.

Pitching: 45/80

Hitting: 60/80

Fielding: 80/80

Overall: 70/80

  1. Peach

Peach is an all around beast with a cannon arm on the mound, an amazing fielding special with her quick toss, and home run power. Peach is friends with the most characters in the game at 6 (Mario, Luigi, Daisy, Toad, Toadette, Daisy), so there is a good chance you'll have the chance to get someone on base for her when she comes up.

Peach and Daisy's quick throw make them arguably the best infielders in the game. The downfall that sticks out most to me is her lack of slap hitting prowess, but I'm usually looking for a gapper or a bomb when I'm hitting with Peach. Peach is also not a fast character, so keep her out of the outfield.

Pitching: 75/80

Hitting: 65/80

Fielding: 70/80

Overall: 70/80

Posted Mar 18, 2017, 9:59 PM UTC · edited

39
bkay17•

Why no Hammer Bro???

Just wanted to say that me and 2 of my friends play a lot and do draft-style team selection but the first five to go in no particular order are usually: Boo, DK, Bowser, Hammer Bro, and Yoshi. King Boo is probably next in line. Birdo also very popular as is Diddy.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
baby_come_onOP•

We initially made that a rule because we thought he was too good, but then we all got ridiculously good at the game and stopped caring. We kept the rule as tradition.

Another rule we have is no bunting. Too many glitched plays where it gives you the center fielder and you can't play the ball.

1
dhr0005•

The bunt is definitely prone to glitching, but with all superstars on, if you throw a fastball wild pitch and make the batter miss, and it totally screws you up if you're stealing (especially on a squeeze). For that reason, my friends and I leave the bunt in the game-- it's a risk either way

1
baby_come_onOP•

Wild pitch? No such thing in GC

1
dhr0005•

You can throw a ball that's so far outside it's unhittable, at least for someone that's trying to bunt. That's what I mean by WP

1
dhr0005•

Totally agree with these, and these are the most contested players when my friends and I draft as well. Might switch up the order, but it really just depends what you're looking for, hard to say "Bowser's hitting is better than Yoshi's fielding" or anything like that. One of my friends and I are currently in the middle of a "series of series of series," which is a 7 game series of 7 game series of 7 game series, so needless to say, we play a lot as well. Over a hundred games with documented results so far this semester, lol

There are so many other posts claiming random players as the best, like Dixie Kong, or saying that others are terrible (like Bowser !?!) so I used to think that maybe it was just about who you got used to using. This post makes me think twice-- maybe we've reached the saturation point and these are the true best players.

I would probably add Luigi to the mix as well, for his surprising power, and Mario for being well-rounded and for having a nasty ability to pitch again immediately after the ball gets back to the mound.

1