Which Ryzen for casual 4K Gaming? (~30-60fps)
I'm trying to price out a new living-room PC for once Vega lands. Ideally, it'd be able to play most new games acceptably at 4K.
I'm not a competitive multiplayer gamer, and so I don't need 120 FPS - just enough for it not to be super annoying when playing.
I see a ton of discussion about video card performance at 4K, but I don't know how beefy of a CPU you need to get there, and all of the review benchmarks at 4K seem to be with new i7's or the 1800x. I'd hope that an R5 would be enough, but I don't want to make a noob mistake here.
(Yes, I know, Bench for Waitmarks, but just a ballpark CPU is what I'm looking for.)
Posted Mar 22, 2017, 12:42 AM UTC
Some people more experienced than I am with gaming can chime in here, but if you're gaming at 4k then (from what I understand) the bottleneck is with the GPU, not the CPU. With that said, I would imagine the difference between an R5 or potentially even an R3 would be negligible based on your goals.
I'd be compelled to wait around for an R5 or even an R3 and just use the savings for the high-end Vega chip when it comes out.
Yep GPU's hit a wall this is why we need things like Vulkan Multi-GPU only some games that change the FOV (Very rare any more) use more CPU iirc Multi GPU's does as well some not a lot
but some of newer games are very CPU heavy as well and your FPS is what hit's your CPU very very hard Ryzen can hit 80%+ in newer games intels kebylake hits 100% on all cores in some games
I think the way you're phrasing it is a little confusing.
I could be wrong but I think it works like this (numbers are made up): 1080p Mid-High end Graphics card hits 60-100FPS max settings, 100% utilization. Mid-Highend CPU hits 60-80%
4K Mid-high end graphics card hits 35-75FPS max settings, still 100% utilization. Mid-highend CPU hits 70-90+%.
So it's not that your CPU can suddenly be worse if you up the resolution, its that if your CPU is high end it can handle 4k easily, but even high end GPUs won't be able to keep up and send the CPU instructions fast enough, causing a GPU bottleneck.
If your CPU is worse than your GPU your CPU will still bottleneck at any resolution.
So, the bottom line is you should get a CPU that keeps up with the GPU, and a GPU that can handle 4K well. Ie. R9 Fury, 1070, 1080, 1080ti and combine it with a cpu that can (mostly) keep up Ie. (maybe R5), R7, i5 7600k, i7 7700k.
If you're multitasking or doing production tasks then Ryzen, if you're only gaming then i5 or i7.
Edit: I think the best budget 4k option is probably the R9 Fury (if you can get it at the $234 price) and an i5-7600. Could go slightly worse, could go better.
Makes sense. The only reason I was suggesting maybe even the R3 is because he said he's looking for 30-60FPS. I feel like an old FX-8300 series could do that if it were paired up with a GTX 1080, right?
I didn't mean to imply the CPU doesn't matter at all, but I was just thinking maybe it matters a lot less to someone who isn't chasing high FPS. But I was making the assumption that any of the Ryzen processors should be able to handle a 4k game at 30fps.
Right, your advice was good, just the phrasing made it sound like at higher resolutions the CPU has to do less work