r/tennis•
henrax

Comparison between Fed and Connors numbers of titles

As you know, Federer is now at 90 titles, 19 away from the crazy record of 109 titles won by Connors (and that's only the ones recognized by the ATP, he won 40 other "exhibition" tournaments that often paid more than the official ones and featured 4 to 8 players).

There are a lot of factors that explain why Connors won so many tournaments, and I wanted to have a more in-depth analysis of those performances.

Did Connors play more tournaments per year ?

A big argument often used to explain this record is that tennis was much less physical at that time and players could play more matches a year. This is somewhat true, but not as much as we could think. During Connors main career (1972-1985), he played 20 tournaments a year on average. Federer in 2002-2015 played 18 tournaments a year, so a difference of 11%.

That said, it's true that many players could play more than 100 games a year during that time. Vilas in 1977 played more than 140 games (even 160 if you count non-ATP tournaments). Illie Nastase and Ivan Lendl played more than 120 games some years (but after 1984, Lendl was at 80 games / year, he really changed his scheduling mid-career to focus on most important tournaments). Overall it's true that players nowadays play less, and top tier players are around 70-80 games a year when not injured.

The longevity

Before Federer, Connors was largely considered as the reference in term of longevity, reaching the semi-finals of the US Open in 1991 at 39. Surely this can explain why he won so many tournaments ?

It doesn't. Connors only won 4 ATP tournaments after he turned 32. To give a comparison, Agassi won 6 and Federer is already at 13. Longevity is definitely a factor that favored Roger, even if Connors played longer (he was in the top 100 for 22 seasons against 19 so far for Roger).

Connors had more success when he was younger. Both Fed and Connors exploded during the year they turned 22 (1974 for Connors, 2003 for Fed). But Connors had already 17 titles at that time while Roger had 4.

###The type of tournaments won

That's where the real difference is. Story time : In 1974, Connors was unbeatable. He won 95.9% of the games he played (second highest ever for a season for any player) and won 3 Grand Slams. He was banned from the French Open that year for very controversial reasons : the French Open president, annoyed that some players favored lucrative exhibition tournaments over competitive ones, banned a large number of (mostly american) players, including Connors. There is almost no doubt that he would have made the Calendar year Grand slam that year if not for this ban : It was Borg first French Open title and he really struggled to get it (3 5-setters including the finals where he came back from 2 sets to love). Connors beat Borg and Orantes (French Open finalist) on clay later that year. Because of that he didn't play in the French Open from 1974 to 1978, the five year during which he was #1 in the world.

Connors won 15 tournaments that year in 22 participations, his best for a single season (Fed best is 12 in 17 in 2006). After winning the Australian Open (his only win in that tournament in two participations), he won 7 tournaments in the US from January to March. It's like if in 2006, after winning the AO, Fed decided to play in a lot of challengers and ATP 250 in Europe instead of playing in Indian Wells / Miami. Out of those 15 titles, only 5 were equivalent to top tier tournaments : GS, WTF, Masters. 8 were equivalent to Challengers or Futures.

In the 70's, tennis was nowhere as lucrative as it is now. Players would often favor tournaments that offered them money over far-away tournaments with worldwide reputation. Traveling was expensive and more complicated than today. In his most dominant period (1974-1978) he played 14 out of 25 major tournaments (slams + WTF) and won 6 of them, and he didn't miss any because he was injured.

Without these decisions and the ban issues with the French Open, he would probably have won 12 or 13 Grand Slams (instead of 8). But if we remove the tournaments equivalent to challengers and Futures (32 in total), he is at 77 tournaments won. I think a fair equivalent in today's tennis would be around 80-85 titles.

Federer can maybe reach 100 titles (he needs two very good years), there is no way he can reach this record. It would need a complete change in the rules or the way tennis is played to see someone get it.

Posted Mar 22, 2017, 12:05 PM UTC

7420
Loading comments…