r/AskMechanics•
ecle

2009 Miata (34k miles) Transmission Troubles (and I'm probably coping incorrectly). Help!

A bit long, but I tried to use headers and such so that it can be skimmed.

tl;dr: After parked at least 8 hours, car sometimes won't come out of first gear, sometimes gets to neutral then won't shift into any gear, sometimes won't shift into appropriate gear but will shift into a higher one (lugging my poor engine). When stuck in neutral, giving some gas allows gear selection. Problem gradually improves after driving a while. Why?

I know that my 2009's transmission is having issues at 34,000 miles, but I can't figure out what (and CarMax keeps trying to convince me my car is normal). I feel like the workarounds necessary to drive my car for the first fifteen to twenty minutes each day are hurting my car so I want to find the underlying problem and fix it.

My ignorant opinion is master cylinder, but is it even possible to have a faulty master cylinder that usually only acts up when the engine is cold (and is worse when it is cold out) ? Is it actually a different problem? Am I just doing something wrong?

Description of General Problem

--I have been having issues where my car doesn't want to acknowledge that the clutch pedal has been pressed--not wanting to start, the shifter getting stuck in first while driving, the car refusing to go into gear etc. It's almost like it sometimes doesn't acknowledge that the clutch pedal has been pressed at all, and other times it seems like it acknowledges it to get it out gear but then forgets by time I try to shift to the proper gear. --It behaves better for downshifts than upshifts. --Generally about twenty minutes into my drive, my car is starting to behave, and after a half hour or so, the shifts feel much smoother and the problem mostly goes away. Even when it is not really cold out, I have to go through this routine in the mornings. It does it after work (about 8 to 9 hours sitting) as well but usually for not as long/severely.

What Seems to Work

--In the mornings when it doesnt really want to come out of first gear and doesn't want to go into second and third gear, it is more likely to do it without a struggle if I change quickly and with some force at around exactly 3000 RPM--any more or any less and I get stuck in neutral. --If it is refusing to go into gear, one thing works consistently (gas) and the other sometimes (picking a higher gear). Consistently, if the shifter is in neutral and then has decided it doesn't want to go into gear, feathering the gas pedal to around 3000 RPM allows me to select the next gear. Also, sometimes, if it won't go into second, it will go into third (but then be at too low RPM). Same that if it won't go into third gear, I can get it to approve of fourth gear even though that puts RPM really low. I know that's really bad so I try not to do it, but sometimes I feel like I have no choice.

What Doesn't Seem to Work/What I Have Tried/Limitations

--Pumping the clutch doesn't seem to make too much difference so maybe it isn't the master, but I don't know what else to think about it. --I tried to feel the slave cylinder for leaks, but even though I can see it, I can't seem to reach it. --The fluid in master cylinder reservoir looks pretty clear and seems to be consistent in level (just below max once heated up). --I don't have a safe way to lift the car to change the transmission fluid to the good Motorcraft stuff (and I am having trouble finding a shop to do it for me.)

Possibly Normal/Unrelated but Perhaps Helpful

--There is some dried yellow stuff/discoloration on the metal under the hood below the master cylinder reservoir but not anywhere else, on the reservoir itself, or near pedals inside the car. --Sometimes I get the sensation that the gears are moving; the place where I need to put the shifter for a successful shift moves. Where third gear is located 4 minutes into the drive is not where it wants to go for that same gear 20 minutes later --It will not go into first gear unless at a complete stop

Conclusion

I am mega lost about what to do. I have driven other manuals for years without this kind of problem. I know being a little crunchy or notchy is normal when cold, but this is beyond normal and I know driving at higher RPMs on a cold engine is bad, lugging the engine/putting into an inappropriately high gear is bad, and using the gas pedal while in neutral might be bad, too.

Posted Mar 23, 2017, 8:02 PM UTC · edited

12
Aesopin•

You have a clutch problem it sounds like. Your shifting fine at 3,000 rpms as this is called "speed shifting" and isn't necessarily good for your car, although it works. The yellow fluid you see is most likely clutch fluid. The fact the you can get it in gear speed shifting gives an idea that the transmission is fine, or not totalled atleast. Find the yellow fluid and you've found your issue. Most likely a clutch master or clutch slave cylinder, but you must find the leak to be sure as the lines can be just as problematic.

If its under warranty, get a diagnoses.

Edit: clutch is sucking in air overnight. Giving you your morning issue. This will also give you your "gear feels like its moving issue. The air in the line will move when it sits and move towards the slave when you use it, you may need to bleed the system in order to find the leak. If the leak is exactly where the air bubble is, the fluid won't leak, this is a rare occurrence.

Edit 2: spelling, good luck.

3
Peepismycat•

I like Aeospin's answer. The first thing I would want to do is make sure all the air is blood out of the clutch system properly. I don't believe there's any physical adjustments that can be made, just that the air is all out of the clutch system or not.

1