What do you look for when getting a new whiskey?

So I'm pretty new to whiskey. I started about a year ago because I "wanted to like scotch because a decanter of scotch looks cool." Go ahead, judge. Anyway, I tried a few scotches, but didn't find much I really liked. I got a bottle of rye at Costco and actually kind of liked it. Fast forward a bit and I was talking to a friend who suggested I would probably like bourbon better. After a little research, my first bottle was Old Forester 86. I don't see much talk on here about them, but man, I LOVED it! Since then, I've tried a handful of other bourbons. I generally like something that does well on it's own on the rocks, and that I can also toss in an old fashioned as well. So I e only picked up one bottle I didn't enjoy straight (a bottle of Weller) but it did well in a cocktail. So, I guess the question is, when you're browsing and going out on a limb for something you've maybe never had, is there anything you look for or a description that gives you a hint of if you'll like it or not?

Posted Mar 23, 2017, 8:16 PM UTC

1712
quercus_robur•

It was a crapshoot back when I was looking, but now we have many experienced people here willing to help you.

I would recommend sticking with the recommended bottles, at least at first. They're often recommended for a reason, and it's not just high-end bottles. We can also recommend sub-$30 bottles.

5
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
brannongreen•

As a scotch drinker that tries to understand the appeal of bourbon I just look for the next bourbon that someone recommends because the last one probably didn't do it for me.

2
superboots•

When I buy a new bottle I'm landing somewhere on the spectrum from high learning (buying a heavily peated bottle when you haven't had peated whiskey before) to no learning (buying the same bottle you bought last month). This is just a mood thing but it has a big influence on what bottle I decide to pick up.

I actually have a to-buy list of about 70 bottles that I haven't tried yet, sorted by cost, that I slowly add to over time whenever I hear about a bottle that sounds interesting to me. I've got bottles on that list from $19 to $415. It's nice to reference when I want to go get a new bottle and also is really easy to hand to someone who is looking for gift ideas for you.

I'll typically watch and read reviews, look for bottles that are know to be good value, and find friends or reviewers who seem to have similar taste to me and see what they tend to like.

2
Fracking_ToastersOP•

This is really good advice. Thank you! Do you rate them on your list as far as like "this is the one I want the most"?

2
superboots•

No if there's a few on my list that I really want I'll have them in the back of my mind. And I find that when I convince myself that a bottle is going to be the greatest thing ever I'm usually disappointed.

I certainly haven't got to a point where I can read a bottles flavor profile description and tell you if I'll like it or not, so I find that I have the best experience when I just go in with an open mind and minimal expectations.

2
adrias5280•

I would suggest checking out r/ScotchSwap. Great way to trade samples with others so you can try before you buy.

1
ThinkAndLetThink•

Honestly, I'm looking for clearance price tags. I'll try any bottle at least one time.

1
t8ke•

God, Old Forester 86 is god awful.

Try the Signature or their 1920. I bet it will absolutely blow your socks off.

1
Fracking_ToastersOP•

I thought it was good, especially for the price. Now that I e had a handful of others that are typically considered to be better, and refined my pallet a bit I'd like to go back and try it again. I would like to try some of their other offerings as well.

1
bleedingjim•

Hello pads I'm drunk right now on gentlemen Jack and some off brand tequila which is quite good actually. I would recommend gentlemen Jack. Somewhat smoother than regular Kal daniels, nut I am very early on in my alcoholic adventures. So try it out of you want.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
tvraisedme dumpster arsonist•
0
recommendation_botactual bot•

Hi there, I'm a bot. You've included some things in your post that lead me to believe you're looking for a bottle recommendation. If not, sorry for intruding. I'll try to make sure this doesn't happen again in the future.


I've responded to your post to point you to some recommendation resources and help you get the most out of your request. If you haven't already, please review the collection of guides in the sidebar we've created to address the stream of recommendation posts we get here. Specifically:

 

If you've still got questions after reading the guides, please try to be as specific and detailed as possible with your request in order to get the most personalized and relevant responses.

  • Tell us which bottles you or your giftee have liked
  • Tell us which bottles you're considering now
  • Tell us where you live because pricing and availability can vary dramatically by region.
  • Let us know if your shop has a limited selection of whiskies so we don't recommend something that you might have a lot of trouble finding
  • Provide a price range that you're comfortable spending on a bottle.

 

A Few More General Tips
As far as exploring new whiskies, we generally advise novices to sample as much as possible by going to a bar, splitting bottles with friends, attending festivals/tastings or getting minis to ensure you buy bottles you enjoy. Most people need to try 15-25 whiskies to understand their preferences and tastes. It may make more sense for you to buy smaller portions of different whiskies rather than full bottles.

You're going to get the most flavor/aroma drinking it neat in a tulip-shaped glass like a Glencairn but most new drinkers prefer to water down their whisky a bit. If you do end up adding water, we usually recommend adding just enough to make it tolerable and take small sips. But really there's no right or wrong way to drink so as long as you're enjoying it, you're doing it right.

Searching r/whiskey may yield some additional insights as well. Thanks for reading, cheers!

4